Gahanna Pizza Plus

Really good pizza !!Always made by same ownership much like Hank Newmans used to be

Been meaning to come here for ages, but we always forget about it till we've already gotten supper. Today, storm coming, Sweetie wanted pizza, and this is one of the closest local joints. Called and ordered easily (aside from kitchen noise.) 25 minutes, not bad at 630 on a Friday. They were jumping when I got there. Super friendly and professional. Got our food, headed home, car smelled great. Pizzas looked great. And tasted pretty darn good.K got cheese, said the sauce was "too spicy." I didn't think so at all. Sweetie got pepperoni and liked it. I got pepp and sausage, and a 6" sub. The pizza was pretty good: medium-thick crust, perfectly cooked, good sauce, good cheese, plenty of good toppings. Some complain about the sausage "bits" but I liked them. The sub is small, but I did that on purpose since I was getting pizza too. If you want just a sub, get the 9" at least. Perfect Italian sub: good bread, good meat and veggies, held together well. Gone in a flash.Standard menu: pizza, subs, salads. But a few interesting specialty ones, like Lorraine, Florentine, Greek.Price was reasonable for as much food as we got, and the quality. I'd go back.

We had a delicious "car picnic" this week with personal size pizzas from Gahanna Pizza Plus. I hadn't had pizza in several months, so it was especially delicious - I felt like I had died and gone to heaven. The ingredients were fresh and the flavor was perfection. I got pineapple on mine and it was flawless. Kiddo had plain cheese and wolfed down the entire pie happily.We met the owner and he shared that he's originally from Pennsylvania, which explains the definite East coast flair to this 'za. He also shared that you can order "half-baked" pies to take home and finish baking in the oven at home. Now that's a great idea.The lunch special is $6 or so for an 8-inch, 1-item pizza and a can of brand name pop. It felt like a good deal to us and we left stuffed. Those were very satisfying pizzas!There's noplace to sit or eat here, so it's takeout only. However, you can browse for candy at Buckeye Candy Co. next door while you're waiting for your pizza to bake, which is also a definite plus!

Really disappointed, I paid extra to get this pizza because I thought it was great- but when it arrived it was cold and had very little toppings. Won't be ordering from here anymore- see picture.

Honestly this pizza was completely garbage. I love to eat any type of pizza, but this pizza was not good at all. No taste and bad hospitality. The pizza was over priced, no offense even my school had better pizza.

First time ordering from here and would definitely recommend it. Plenty of toppings cooked just right.

Love this place. I work from home and can order a lunch special sub, walk down with the dog and get it in 5 minutes. The Super Italian is THE BEST SUB in the world!!! Try it, you won't regret it!

The pizza is good. I like the customer service a lot. I've been there twice in the past month. I'd go back.

It was okay... They have no tea... No water...Pizza toppings were good but it was really under seasoned...Def needed salt!

We've been going there for years. Food is great excellent service.All Meat The best pizza in town.