two slices of pizza on a plate
Small Side Salad with Ranch dressing
Turkey Club Sub
Stromboli
a slice missing from the pizza
Menu
Menu
a half eaten pizza on a plate
Cheese bread
two slices of pizza on a plate
Stromboli
Small pepperoni
a half eaten pizza in a box
a slice of pizza in a box
food, pizza
Menu
Menu
XL Cheese (29") (5/18/2018)
pizza
pizza
XL Cheese/Mushroom and Sausage (29") (5/18/2018)
Not sure when the buffet closes, but these were here the entire time I waited. Glad I don't get grossed out by this sort of thing!
sushi and sashimi, interior
Great tasting sausage! (5/18/2018)
Nancy L.
Apr 7, 2024
We have been to Fat Cat Pizza many times over the years. We especially like to go when the Rendition's are playing! The music is great with tunes from the 70's but it is loud and not conducive to much conversation with your dining partner. Our server was Hannah and she was attentive to our dining needs! We had adult beverages and started with the side salad. The salad is simple with lettuce, tomato, and cheese. We then had the pepperoni Stromboli which is always tasty. It is a bit greasy but there are plenty of napkins on the table. I also had the turkey club sub which was really good but had too much mayonnaise on it. I will order it on the side next time. We always take some of the food home as leftovers. We will be back!
Read More
Teresa R.
Jan 28, 2024
The pizza was ok if you like overdone crust and sweet sauce. There were two waitresses working. One was working her tail off the whole time we were there. Ours, the young one, was too busy playing on her phone to realize my husband's glass had been empty for 15 minutes. She didn't come over to our table once to see if we needed anything.
Read More
Will F.
Dec 27, 2022
I love visiting Lancaster and always have to get several fat cat pizzas each time I do! I've had pizza all over the country including Chicago and New York - Fat Cat remains my top favorite. The sweet sauce might not be everyone's favorite but it makes this pizza stand out. I really like the crust as well, and the cheese is so chewy!
Read More
Richard J.
Dec 4, 2021
We stopped by for a quick lunch. It seems like they have live music on the weekend. We may go there and enjoy the music sometime. Anyway, we love this place! The Stromboli was awesome!!!!! So tasty and cheesy! The best Stromboli I've ever had. The lady was very nice, great service! Will go back again soon.
Read More
Patrick R.
Dec 7, 2021
Two words: Sweet SauceIf you are into that, you'll love this place. Otherwise, Donato's is your best option in the area. Seriously. It's like they pour sugar into the sauce. The cheese and toppings are great. But I digress. Do you me self a favor...stick with the two D's - DiGiorno or Donato's.
Read More
Lori C.
Sep 12, 2021
Very average pizza. Sweet sauce, which we don't like. You have two choices of crust. We always opt for any pizza offering a thin crust, but it wasn't really that thin. We waited about 90 minutes for our food while dining in. If it had been exceptional, the wait would have been worth our time, but, again, the pizza and appetizers were just average.We likely won't return.
Read More
Jersey R.
Feb 18, 2025
ive tried pizza from all over , and I've never had anything come close to how good Fat Cat's is! I drive 45 minutes just to go get pizza! it's amazing !
Read More
Scott B.
Nov 24, 2023
I've had approx. 5 pizzas from them in the last 6 months. 1 good pizza and 2 ok pizzas and 2 horrible pizzas. I've had 2 Italian subs as well. Both times the subs were disgusting. Brown lettuce and hardly any meat. I'm done with them. No more ordering from me. Back in the day the original Fat Cats was the best in town. Too bad it couldn't have carried on. Not to mention the ridiculous "carry out" policy they choose to have.
Read More
Carol F.
Dec 31, 2023
Mom. And I eat at fat cats at least once sometimes twice a week the food and staff are wonderful and go out of their way to please us and everyone around them ..the prices are great and the staff has a wonderful sense of humor, they have music sometimes live ,or jute box TV fir sports or an occasional soap opera if needed its the place to be...so give it a try
Read More
Michael A.
Dec 10, 2023
Service has always been pretty good here, I'm honestly a big fan of the pizza here, it is hit or miss for some but me and my family like it a lot. They have a few good appetizers but the pizza is the star, everything else is meh, but definitely worth stopping by and trying it out!
Read More