Fat Boy's Pizza & Ice Cream

Parking:Parking lot is half asphalt and half gravel. Always tons of parking spots availableSeating:Most people seems to buy carry-out, but if you want to sit and eat there, they have plenty of seating. I've never had to wait for a seat. Wait time:After ordering food, it's a 30 minute wait. Food:They have 3 different sauces that I'm aware of, I normally get the mixed sauce which is regular and sweet sauce mixed together. In my opinion, this is the best pizza in Bellefontaine. This town has a "world famous" pizza place and I think Fat Boys pizza taste better. Ambiance:It's a good place for friends to sit down and eat a pizza, but I wouldn't suggest it as a date night location. Room for improvement in the future, they definitely have the pizza perfected, now they need to get their ambiance perfected. We will definitely be back.

Fat Boys Pizza... The only thing better than taking a pizza pie home from here, is living into their buffet!We carried out from here and the pizza was great. Had to get extra sauce, bc why not, and I think without the extra sauce the pizza would have been a little dry for my liking.Crust was very good. We got one pizza with their regular sauce and one with the sweet sauce... The sweet sauce was killer! Would love to try the blend of the two.All in all, really good pizza on the south side of Bellefontaine!

Had the bbq chicken pizza, it was really good!! The crust was thin and very crispy just like I like it! Will definitely go back!

Fat Boys always delivers strong pizza. Great thin crust. Nice and crispy. The Big Daddy pizza with olives is incredible. They also have great friend pickle pieces- outstanding.

Very good pizza, but I don't recommend reheating! I feel it is a bit pricey for pizza.

Excellent service! The calzone is the best. The orders are ready on time. Plesant place to sit down to eat

Best pizza buffet in town! Definitely be there on Friday lunchtime! This is my favorite pizza in town. Owner is a great guy and place is always clean and friendly. Highly recommend!

The food was really good. I was really creeped out by the owner berating his daughter for being fat right in front of me. Will not go back for this reason.

Great pizza would definitely recommend the sweet sauce, if your not pizza lover they have other options for you as well and don't forget about the ice cream

Admittedly, I'm a bit of a food snob. I know what I like and know what I want. This is some great pizza!!! With dining closed due to COVID we had take out. Friendly staff, appears to be clean from a drive through look. Prices reasonable and the taste was great.I always tip for good friendly service and especially now dining is closed, and gave a little extra. Try it.