Fantasy Cupcake

Love their monthly cupcake flavors. Coffee is also really good, too. Our dog loves their pupcake!

My first review was closer to their initial opening, I can say with certain that they've developed into a great local sweets shop/catering business! Their name is out and about, especially around the Canal/Pickerington area. I've been to several events on the southeast side of Columbus that are sporting Fantasy's cupcakes. Yes, their cake batter is moist and flavorful. The icing used is made from scratch, light and they don't douse the cupcakes with icing - a personal pet peeve. A wonderful treat!Their new location, three doors down from their old, much-to-small, space is great: tall ceiling, white and brick walls, a nice serving counter that incorporates several display cases; several tables and chairs line the opposite wall. Their gluten free offerings are in a separate area, which keeps stuff apart so no cross-contamination.The only thing holding me back from giving 5 stars? Their cupcakes are small for the price. Yes, the icing is quality and tastes great, but the physical cake part does not justify over $3.

Every cupcake on the menu is delicious. When they come out with new flavors, I'm not scared I'm not going to like it-- the staff are friendly and it's a bright and welcoming atmosphere.

I have used Fantasy Cupcake for many custom orders for events. Always easy to work with and friendly. Just place your orders far enough in advance. The lemon poppyseed cupcake is THE GOAT. They have lots of gluten free options and they are all wonderful. I am pretty sure I have tried every GF cupcake and coffee cake options they have. I do love the cinnamon coffee cake as well. Be prepared to pay top dollar for gluten free custom orders. It ain't cheap but it's worth the money. You get what you pay for. This is a great local establishment.

Delicious cupcakes and fresh baked the same day! They also have a sitting area where you can enjoy your treat! Overall, great cupcakes and laid back atmosphere.

I consider myself a cupcake connoisseur so I was apprehensive about this place when I walked in and saw dog treats amongst the offerings. Could they make cupcakes for me and Fido?? Answer: Yes!The prices were a bit steep for the size of the cupcake, but I liked that they offered mini and full size treats. They had a wide assortment of flavors including seasonal. My favorite was the raspberry merlot seasonal. I tried a mini which was the perfect bite with a blend of raspberry filling and chocolate ganache. I loved how all of the cupcakes had some type of surprise middle, like the unexpected ball of cookie dough in the middle of the chocolate chip cookie dough. I want to go back and try the cake pops and the frosted sugar cookies but definitely a great cupcake experience.

Cupcake were just alright. In my opinion overpriced. Nearly $4 for an "okay" cupcake is kinda nuts, but we had already promised our children cupcakes before seeing the prices. We got Wedding Cake, Salted Carmel, Chocolate Fantasy, Snickerdoodle, Buckeye, and Red Velvet. All the other snacks were expensive as well $1 for one Buckeye, nearly $3 for a cake pop. Mediocre at best.

The name is absolutely fitting for this cupcake shop, you'll think you're imagining the amazing taste. Everything about these cupcakes is spectacular. They're fluffy, perfectly iced and come in mini or regular sizes. Be prepared to shell out some cash though, less than 6 cupcakes will cost you $3 each and 6 or more are $2.75 each. They do offer a 10% military discount. They're a great treat though and come in a variety of flavors like mint chocolate chip, birthday cake, buckeye and more!I called on a Thursday afternoon for a 40 cupcake order to be picked up on Friday. They were super helpful and accommodating and my cupcakes were ready to go on time! Everyone at our work party raved about how good the cupcakes were.Not only do they have cupcakes, but they have cake pops, ice cream and several different pupcakes and dog treats available! My dog loved the pupcake I brought home. They do not have their own parking lot, but there is street parking and a free public lot right behind.

I was so excited to see that Fantasy was open for limited hours during quarantine to do pick ups for order boxes. The boxes went quick (sold out in three hours online) so I won't get . They had the coffee and milkshake bar open during pick up hours and I knew I had to be there to A) support one of my favorite local business and B) to get my favorite beverage!I didn't realize how much I needed this outside (in a mask, with disinfectant) interaction until I walked in and saw Leah's smiling face. Honestly if you were to ask me the truth I think I may have gotten a little misty-eyed under the mask. I got my favorite drink, a caramel and vanilla iced latte, and went on my way.Once again I was so thankful for this opportunity to visit one of my local favorites during this time as I have so much love for Fantasy Cupcake and the staff that welcomes me with a smile.Until we meet again and I get to have more of that delicious cinnamon coffee cake that keeps me going in my dreams.

Cupcake tastes like any grocery stores bakery cupcake or something you could make yourself. only thing you are paying for is they are decorated Nicely. not worth it. So I make the 30 minute drive to small cakes s in Gahanna. Now those are delicious and also are decorated nicely.