Super Sub @ColumbusFoodDude
Special Salad @ColumbusFoodDude
Pepperoni Pizza @ColumbusFoodDude
the HUGE salad
Ham & Cheese Sub
Special Salad
a half eaten pizza
Bar area, salad very good, pizza good!
food, grilled fish
Great pizza! Pic is half pepperoni and half all the way. We also love their special salad, so yummy!
Well done!
Plain Cheese Pizza
14in pepperoni
Med. Cheese Pizza with 3 Items (pepperoni, onion, banana peppers)
Pep/sausage pizza
Special salad
Small mushroom
Pepperoni & sausage
10" Sausage, Mushroom and Onion!! (5/22/2021)
Meatball Sub
Small Special Salad
Special salad
Brian K.
Feb 15, 2025
Been there since the 60's for a reason. Restaurant side is nothing special so we get takeout. The pie is outstanding! Nice crisp crust, plenty of toppings and great flavor. Love the pepperoni. Piping hot and if they say 20 mins it'll be ready in 20. Fair prices and worth an try.
Read More
Micah T.
Feb 7, 2025
Got delivery so can't comment on bathroom, but my bathroom is pretty nice. Anyways I think this is my favorite tavern-style pizza in Columbus. They really perfected the thin and crispy and next time I eat this I won't order Well done. I was just worried it'd be floppier kinda like Donatos but I don't think that would be the case. The cheese tasted amazing and they're sauce has a fantastic balance sharpness and acidity without overdosing on sugar. The staff were even kind enough to give us 2 extra sauces! Bonus for the cheesy bread too it was great. I had a promotion from Ubereats so the price came out pretty decent, but the in person prices looked pretty decent on the website. Overall I really enjoyed it, I'm still a Neapolitan or NY style pizza fan at heart but I think this is the pizza to try if you're really into tavern style.
Read More
John M.
Jan 28, 2025
So after watching Dave Portnoy on Barstool Pizza Review I had to come here try it myself. I can tell you right now Emelio's Restaurant doesn't disappoint! Special Salad is now my standard of what salad should be at a Pizza restaurant and their pizza has this crunch & flavor that I can't get over. If you live in Columbus, it's a must try! Emelio's folks, Emelio's! Perfectly simple, the way pizza should be! I ordered the Special Salad, Pepperoni Pizza and Super Sub I'm giving Emelio's a 9.3!
Read More
Michelle O.
Feb 12, 2025
Good pizza, waited at the bar... service was kinda slow. Also the pizzas took longer than expected but overall good pizza.
Read More
Mark B.
Jan 28, 2025
Was very good pizza . One all the way ! One pep and cheese . Large salad very tasty. Just a bit pricey but worth it
Read More
Nancy L.
Mar 1, 2024
Try the special salad that comes with the baked pepperoni. It is really tasty and the portion is huge. We order the small and my husband and I still have some leftover. The subs are meaty and baked the way I like them. The pizza is thin and greasy from all of the cheese! Delicious! Napkin dispenser is on the table! This is a neighborhood bar with a limited menu of pizza, subs, and salad. The TVs have sports playing but it is quiet enough to enjoy a conversation. The server was quick to take our order and she checked on us multiple times. The parking lot is tight but many people are just picking up a to go order.
Read More
Myra W.
Feb 18, 2024
This place has gotten a lot of hype so finally ventured to the other side of town to try. When I first walked in I was taken aback . Expected a restaurant but this was small and more like a bar with booths. I think there was another room maybe for larger families or groups. Nicely decorated with photos of local sports teams over the years. Service was good. I'm not a fan of thin and crispy but still my mushroom had great flavor with perfect amount of sauce. My 2 companions shared a large pepperoni and sausage. Yay for the pepperoni nay for the sausage. They had half left and asked for a box but it came back stacked and wrapped in foil. Definitely not my favorite but #5 in list of top 5. If you have never tried you absolutely should. I've heard the salad and subs are great .
Read More
Donna G.
Mar 28, 2024
Huge special salad with fried pepperoni discs and really good Italian dressing. Pizza was a winner, too. Basically a neighborhood bar with good pizza and salad. Friendly service.
Read More
Sarah M.
Aug 4, 2024
They always have great pizza, never disappointments. Cheesy bread is good, too. We order carry out.
Read More
Maddy C.
Jan 17, 2025
Amazing food and service!! Never disappoints, been eating here all my life and food is always consistently delicious! Definitely check it out if you haven't already, a true Columbus gem!
Read More