Castello Pizza

I am embarrassed by how often I order from here. Their food is delicious! Salads, pizza, Stromboli, subs... everything I've tried from here has been great! I live nearby so I pick up often. The men working are always very friendly. This is definitely my favorite place to order from.

I ordered delivery tonight- ten boneless wings, a side of fries, and a can of root beer. It set me back $25 and it's some of the worst food I've had in Columbus. The wings are burnt to a crispy, and are barely tossed in Buffalo. The fries are soggy and tasteless. The ranch tastes old. The best thing about this meal is the can of root beer. Maybe I just got unlucky but I am shocked at how many good reviews this place has. My neighbor recommended the wings to me. We had had the pizza before and it sucked, too, so this was their second chance. Save your dollars and order from somewhere else.

This is seriously the best pizza in columbus. The margherita pizza is the bomb. Oreo cake is good but not my fave. #1 for pizza for sure though!

Absolutely loved this!! I tried the stuffed pizza with pepperoni and cheesy bread. The cheesy bread was pretty standard but the pizza was delicious! Reminds me of a calzone. The dough was cooked perfectly and was crisp without being overcooked. The cheese inside melted in your mouth. First time trying anything like that. Will definitely order again and try more things on the menu.

Emplyees are extremely rude, service is extremely slow and always behind, they also will not allow anyone to use the restroom, not even their delivery drivers

One of my all-time favorite restaurants in Columbus, my #1 for pizza. Very very friendly, fast, and accommodating staff. I've never had a bad experience here, and they once even drove out of the way for me when my location was out of Grubhub-range. I highly recommend the Shrimp Alfredo Pizza or the Buffalo Chicken pizza if you're looking for something different.

I ordered a "stuffed pizza" thinking it was a stuffed crust pizza, but I was disappointed. When you get the stuffed pizza think of a calzone with 0 sauce. If they gave you 4-6 cups of marinara sauce with the pie, i might have given it a 4.5-5 but it's drier than the Sahara are you force dry pizza down your throat.

Wanted to like this place because it's so close and local but my last three experiences have been really bad. The pizza is always thin and super greasy in the middle and it's impossible to eat without a fork! Additionally the ingredients are just not good.

The best pizza starts with the best crust! The crust here is amazing! My order is always ready on time, too!

Food is terrible. That I all I have to say. I can tell you my fettuccine Alfredo is so under seasoned I thought the bread was the main dish. My family even said their shrimp scampi is oily and just tasted like pure butter. We only got delivery from Uber eats. Tbh I would eat my father's pasta since it was at least flavored. Who tf thought it was okay to say water is seasoning. Never buy from here! I forewarned and bide you not to come there.