Carsonie's

Great food, great service. If you are looking for quality Italian, this is the place!

Pros:Good location and lots of parkingDecent Menu with lots of optionsAmble seatingHas a full barCons:Wait staff not very friendlyWait times can be long for larger groups Not much light in dining areaPro tip:Leave plenty of time if you are placing a carryout order. They can get pretty backed up.

I have been a fan of Carsonie's for so long! Their Strombolis were one of my favorite items to get. Our most recent order of Stromboli's was not so great, we couldn't figure out why at first....but it's the bread! They used to use actual good quality dough, and it was chewy and dense in the best way. The current dough just reminds me of those pillsbury dough rolls at the grocery store. Taste and texture was completely off. Not sure if the cheese changed as well or it the new dough made this Stromboli meh. I'm really hoping it was just a fluke but if this is the new recipe they're using, I'll get off my Stromboli train. The quality is just not worth it for the price.

Great Stromboli! They have the best Stromboli crust around. This was a good rainy day lunch treat. They were very busy for lunch and the service was still excellent. Very authentic atmosphere here.

Ordered 3 pizzas and a salad for carryout. All 3 pizzas were cold, greasy and pretty disgusting. All 3, except for a few pieces, were thrown straight in the trash. Not sure who's cooking or managing, but the food quality has gone downhill for me over the last few years. After 30 some years of going there, I'm done. There are too many good pizza places way better for the money.

Always a delightful time at Carsonie's and the food is delicious! I had the Mediterranean Pasta with shrimp and my friend had an Italian sub, both were amazing! Reasonable pricing, lots of choices, friendly staff and always a military discount, what more can you ask?

I can't believe I've lived in Westerville almost all my life and just now tried Carsonie's. Even though it took me this long, I'm glad to have broken the seal. I ordered a cup of the wedding soup to start and holy wow. The soup was incredibly flavorful and full of pasta, spinach, and meatballs. This is a must order for me going forward, even on a really hot day. I had the Chicken Carsonie for my meal, but I did all alfredo sauce because I don't like anything tomato. The chicken was incredibly crispy and cheesy and I really liked their alfredo sauce. It also came with a house made roll that was great. I of course got dessert and tried their tiramisu which was delicious. The reason for my docked star is because of service only. We were seated inside as we aren't outside dining people and it was a hot day. However we were clearly in the minority because the patio was packed. I'm not sure if this is why we rarely saw our server but after we ordered we didn't see her again until it was time to pay. We ended up flagging down another server who was really kind and helped get us parmesan (which our server told us she would bring), butter, and even took our dessert orders and brought the desserts out. I really appreciate her for doing that because a lot of servers wouldn't want to. I would love to come back but hope to receive better service.

Stromboli is outstanding, my family and I get it every year for Super Bowl parties. Guess are always amazed at it.

I have always heard rave reviews on Carsonies food. Since I did not have a car and did not feel cooking. Had a taste for lasagna I decided to order delivery and see what all the hype is about.I have never been so disappointed in a food order, I could have ordered from Fazoli's, received a much better lasagna with garlic bread for $10.49. I could have ordered from Angie on Karl Rd, they have a great lasagna with lots of cheese, a nice piece of garlic bread, plus a salad for less then $14.00.Carsonies lasagna, I could not find any meat or cheese other than on top of sauce. I am not sure what kind of dry bread that came with the meal, that I paid $17.00 for.I guess it is more of a bar then a real restaurant, if I was drunk the food have might have tasted great.Don't waste your time if you have a taste for pasta.

My girl and I came here for the first time to try it out. Service was very slow. When they finally took our order, she let us know that pizza or Stromboli would take up to 45 mins (also posted in the restaurant as well as the menu) We thought that was ok and placed our order, put in a couple drinks and some salads to tie us over til the Stromboli was done. When I got my salad, I noticed a strange looking "stem", I assumed. When I touched it, it felt cold and very hard. I pulled it out and it was a nail. A literal nail you could hammer into a wall. I notified the server and she took it back and brought me a new one she insisted she watched the guy in back make. By that point we decided to cancel our orders, pay for our drinks and leave. Not a great experience for a first time and I will not be back. Bummer, too.. I was looking forward to my Stromboli. :(