Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen
Carsonie's Stromboli & Pizza Kitchen
Italian fries=fried dough, grated Parmesan, marinara. This is my gorgeous Mom/Dr. Barbara Keller of Upper Arlington.
Fly found in ravioli
Ravioli
Fly found in ravioli
These are the unique and delicious Italian Fries w/Parmesan cheese and marinara sauce. It was new to us. It was delicious! $4 happy hour.
Penne Alfredo and Italian "Fries"
Pasta Rosa and LG ORIGINAL
1 Cran Walnut (no chick)
It has two kinds of meat in it. It is rather salty. Wedding Soup (CUP)
Cheese Carsonie
Italian Fries
I Sausage & Peppers Hoagie
Chicken Carsonie
SM Nutella Stromboli
Italian Fries
Calamari
Godfather-- STEAK Hoagie
Italian Fries
Cranberry Walnut Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Carsonie
food
Exterior
Cool atmosphere, great Stromboli!
Cool decor
Gregory F.
Sep 25, 2024
One of the most reliable places I've frequented in Columbus. Love their Stromboli's - plenty big enough to split amongst at-least two people, reasonably priced and cooked with love and affection! This place feels so incredibly homey and familial - will miss it so much since I moved out back in May. Great service always - feels like I'm being served by family.
Read More
Brent T.
Jan 29, 2025
This review is of their Italian Wedding Soup. Rip-off! $6 for 12 oz of soup. 90% of it is just chicken broth. The other 10% is spinach, cous-cous, some nearly undectable tiny shards of chicken, and no little meatballs anywhere to be found.
Read More
Gretchen T.
Mar 22, 2024
If you need to know anything before coming here, it should be that it takes about 30-45 minutes to make the stromboli (no matter what you get inside them). The menu does explain this, so it's no secret! There are some tasty appetizers though that come out relatively quickly, and the serving sizes are pretty generous. When we first arrived here, there was no one at the hostess stand -- though we did come lunchtime on a Thursday so that may explain it. We had to wait for about five minutes before even seeing an employee. After that, though, we were seated and waited on very quickly. There was only one or two servers, but we were never forgotten about, and our drinks were refilled regularly. We ended up getting two small stromboli. Normally, we get one large one to split, but since we both wanted different 'toppings' (for lack of a better word), we got two smalls. I will say I was still a bit hungry after mine, something I usually don't feel after splitting the large. It was just a little disappointing to wait that long for it to come out and still feel partially hungry. Overall, this is a tasty place, and it has a stellar environment. It's clean and well-decorated. It would probably just benefit from a few more staff members!
Read More
Anna V.
Jul 6, 2024
Ordered take out: Large original Stromboli was good for the value Chicken pesto pasta was fair, only a few long pieces of chicken. The chopped salad was a bit disappointing for $14 but at least they honored my request for cheese on side. Good lot parking
Read More
Pamela A.
Jul 9, 2024
Everything is homemade was delicious. Our favorite dish was the Italian fries. It was new to us. Landon, our server was exceptional. Not only did he advise us on items, but also was very welcoming and attentive. He made our visit even better! You should give him a raise. I also thoroughly enjoyed my Italian sub. It's made with top quality ingredients, especially the meats. Thank you for happy hour prices. because of the top quality ingredients used fair prices and wonderful service by Landon we will be back
Read More
Tawfiq M.
Feb 26, 2024
Bought the Pesto Stromboli and the Veggie Pizza. $35 for a store-bought dough with some salad and balsamic dressing, and a lackluster Stromboli is not the best start to the weekend, I'll be honest. Old school pizzeria vibes, and the service was fine for takeout, and it was made pretty quick but the taste was just not there and lots of corners were cut. Will definitely be checking out some of the other spots in the area but most likely will not be back here.
Read More
Jim M.
Aug 27, 2024
Nice neighborhood joint. Good food. Pleasant staff. Relaxed atmosphere. Enjoyable
Read More
Dane S.
Dec 27, 2023
The Stromboli is a home run but the pizza is a miss. I'm use to PA Stromboli which is way different but this was excellent. The pizza on the other hand was bowling alley pizza or something out of a pizza making kit where the dough is premade and you just add the sauce and cheese yourself.
Read More
Alex S.
Oct 27, 2024
You have to adjust your expectations accordingly. Obviously, this isn't going to have amazing Italian food. It's Americanized Italian food made by high school and college students. That being said, it's very much an OK place to eat.I ordered takeout and my order was ready in a little less than 10 minutes. The food was fine. It tasted like something I could have made at home myself. I don't think I could recommend what I ordered but it seems this place is known for their Stromboli. Perhaps that's good?I probably won't order from here again, but it was not terrible. If you want your food in a hurry and don't care about quality, this place could be for you. As mentioned, my order took less than 10 minutes after I placed my order online.
Read More
Dani R.
Oct 27, 2024
The food is fantastic and the people who work there are very kind and generous. 5stars!!!!
Read More
