Carfagna's Italian Market

Went for a Christmas Santa event that they hosted and had the best time! It was my first time in since they moved to this new space (about a year ago). It's huge and stocked with a great assortment of high-quality foods!I bought a few basics (ezzo pepperoni, a couple cheeses, some bread) and loved everything. They have very reasonable prices considering the quality. Don't sleep on their premade meals and deli items!! The cheesemonger is VERY good and has an incredible selection (that won't break the bank)Despite it being organized chaos at the Santa event, every single employee was welcoming and friendly. I will def be back!

Walked in to this shop and was immediately impressed! Beautiful open floor layout, many great products for a pasta maker like me, and a variety of cheese & pasta choices :)! I especially loved their bakery/pastry section and the history behind making pasta that is displayed over the station they show you how to make pasta. The workers are so kind, and they are very helpful.They also have fun activities through out the year that sometimes offer free samples of meat and cheese, and their prosciutto is absolutely amazing.

A trip to Carfagna's generally results in lots of carbs and meat. The Italian market is packed with specialty items, house-made pastas, sauces, and sweets. The meat and seafood counters are well-stocked, even on the busiest of days and the service is friendly and attentive. Even though it is located in what looks like a big-box warehouse-sized store from the exterior, the vibe is one of a bustling Italian market. The aisles are tight, and people can be elbow to elbow with carts (usually on weekend days), but that is part of the experience and fun of shopping here. We left with lots of ravioli, sauce, filet mignon, ground beef, sausages, and whoopie pies! Impressively, Carfagna's also has a full-service Ristorante, Cafe, Bar, Wine Cellar (Enoteca), liquor store, and cooking school all under one roof. I was excited to include it in my book, Insiders Guide to Columbus, 3rd ed.

Market is great, restaurant is the best! The place is clean and reasonably priced. Service is terrific. We drive nearly 100 miles to enjoy the place.

Been here a few times now and was introduced to the market thanks to Yelp! This trip I grabbed some Carfagna's sauce and some handmade pasta. They carry so many varieties of sauces and pasta. This trip wasn't bad but Inside is usually busy and crazy packed on the weekend. It's a cute market with all kinds of selections including a butcher, cheeses, pizza, and desserts.Definitely recommend checking it out and know I'll be back for sure.

I remember this place when it was a small shop off Dublin-Granville Road and this location has some much to offer. Their selection of meats, cheeses, pastas, etc. is superior and they also have a nice liquor area available. The only knock I have is their checkout lines can get really long. I do appreciate that the line seems to move quickly but when you are standing 20 feet away it feels like it will be forever. I have always used self-checkout and found that I tend to wait around 5 minutes to check out.

Came for a Yelp event awhile back, have returned a couple of times since. So much good stuff here, it's hard to walk out empty-handed. Kind of pricey, but it's good stuff that you can't find elsewhere. Good bakery, nice butcher counter, interesting prepared foods, loads of dry goods and other Italian and European specialties, plus frozen food, snacks, etc. Worth a trip once in awhile. Service generally very helpful.

Returned to Carfagna's to see how they'd progressed since their opening weekend a while back. And have they ever. This place is an amusement park for people who like to cook ... and eat. Huge, super well organized and just fun to go around and check things out. Plus, if you buy a jar of Carfagna's sauce, you get a free bag of pasta of your choice! Pretty awesome! Go there.

Great shopping, food is delicious,and service is very good. I will shop and eat here as often as possible.

Get over to Carfagna's market and take home a container of their Chicken Paprikash, it is fantastic!!! This dish is hard to find around here and their recipe is excellent. Also don't forget to grab some good rolls for that sauce!