Cardone's Restaurant & Bar

This is our 8th Valentine's Day at Cardone's. We found this restaurant our first year dating and usually find our way back here. This year we went with some wine, arancini, manicotti and a Caesar salad with chicken. It was pretty good :) the atmosphere is romantic (although we were a little packed in and could hear the tables next to us) but it was nice. The service was good and we had a lovely time. I think this is a great date night spot. Definitely leave the kids at home as I think this spot is a little more adult oriented than other restaurants.

Service was very good. Food wasn't great. Cold butter for bread. Servers appear to also be your bartender or drink mixer.

First time here and probably not going back. The menu posted outside had different prices than the menu which was given to us at the table, however didn't realize that until the bill came.Anyway, I ordered the soup of the day which was Manhattan clam chowder (bowl) which actually was very tasty! Then I ordered a wedge salad which in my opinion, had way too much dressing on it and wasn't huge like other establishments!The bread was good that was served.

5/5 on all fronts. Hannah, our waiter, was fantastic with quick and attentive service. We came in with my 1 year old nephew and they showed great patience despite being a higher-end restaurant. Food felt like home and was worth every dollar. Great choices on wine as well.

I was looking for an Italian restaurant that was NOT Olive Garden. Mom loves OG and I hate it as I only get salads and OG has no salad option. Yes, I know they have the endless soup, salad, breadsticks. But all I want is a decent salad and not one drowning in OG dressing. Mom loves the tour of Italy - essentially the lasagna.So I was looking in Westerville as she also wanted to drive thru Otterbein as she had been on the campus 65 years + ago. As luck had it, I found Cardone's on Yelp. I peaked at the menu and it looked fine. A little pricier than I had hoped but I also think I need to get used to higher restaurant prices.We did not have reservations and the waiter that greeted looked down his nose at us as a result. Sorry - never been here before so I didn't know that all the cool people make reservations. Fortunately, they had a couple open tables for "people like us" - as well as outdoor seating. Nevermind that they had PLENTY of other empty tables that were not filled while we were there. In fact, not many people came to eat in while we were there, I think every single person walking in the door was picking up carry out.But back to our meal - we were seated in one of the 2 tables for non-reservation people and were lucky enough to have David as our server. He did not look down his nose at us and didn't make us feel bad for only getting water and a diet cola for drinks. Neither Mom nor I drink alcohol and she doesn't even do tea or soda. She's strictly a water girl.I had to help Mom with the menu as she wasn't sure what bolognase sause was. She wanted the lasagna but has a very bland palate and avoids all spicy dishes. So she was good with the lasagna and side salad. I, on the other hand, was happy to pick from several salads and add a protein. I went with the Cardone's salad ever though I don't normally like fruit with my greens. I added chicken and we were set.David brought us a basket of warm bread which was absolutely delicious! I usually don't do carbs but I hadn't eaten all day and just had to try and piece in the olive oil. I love the heals and this one did not disappoint. In fact, I may have also eaten the other heal in the basket. But I'm not owning it.Meals arrived in good time. Mom's lasagna came in a nice square bowl. She absolutely LOVED it, eating more despite being full and saying she was done. As a follow up - she took some home in a doggie bag and it was just as delicious on reheat for lunch the following day.My salad was also superb. The perfect size and built in a lovely bed of greens. The fruit choice was just perfect and complimented the grilled chicken and vinaigrette that came with it. I ate and enjoyed every bite.So I was vindicated for taking us to an Italian restaurant that was not OG as the lasagna was likely better than her usual favorite with the tour of italy. Will I be back? Not sure. Hubby works up this way and I'll mention it for future consideration. Final thanks to David for making great suggestions and being so friendly and helpful.

We had a wonderful dinner here last night! Their lasagna is huge and delicious. Intimate inside and wonderful patio. Excellent food. Attentive service. Nice wine selection too. We will go here regularly.

Amazing! My daughter and I just enjoyed the best homemade meal in a restaurant setting. Let me say - the pictures do not do this place justice. Fresh fresh fresh! We shared the eggplant appetizer. Then, split the gnocchi with beef ragu - a very generous serving even once split. The gnocchi was soft and pillowy. Finally, fresh stuffed cannoli that were room temp, crispy and creamy all at once. Highly recommend you stop by for a warm welcome and meal of true indulgence!!

Found this place on Yelp, while in town on business.A wonderful refreshing change from chain restaurants.Staff was attentive and knowledgeable.I had the lobster bisque and the Gorgonzola gnocchi.Both were wonderful.Gnocchi had a great flavor without being overpowering.Small intimate space would be perfect for a date or special occasion.

This was our first time visiting this upscale Italian restaurant. Our party of five came on a Friday night, and we didn't have a reservation. However, it's a good idea to do so because the restaurant was quickly filled up after we arrived.All entrees are served with a House Salad. Their bread didn't look appetizing, but don't let that fool you. The taste and texture was amazing!The Stuffed Shells (large pasta shells stuffed with beef, pork, cheese, and herbs, baked with marinara) was a hit. The Chicken Parmesan (breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and fresh mozzarella, served with spaghetti) was also good.There is a section called Pizzas & Flatbreads, meaning you have a choice to have it made your way. I ordered the Pepperoni & Four Cheese (Pepperoni and tomato sauce with mozzarella, parmesan, gorgonzola, and pecorino cheeses) as a pizza.Be aware, this is not a Pepperoni pizza for a ten-year old. That is, unless they like gorgonzola. I should have read the fine print, because I wasn't expecting the gorgonzola, which is my kryptonite. My whole body weakened, and I could only manage to eat a couple of small pieces.So, if you really, really don't like gorgonzola (like me) maybe you could ask for a substitution of cheeses.Now, I always like to try an authentic Italian cannoli, and theirs is the real deal. Two good-sized cannoli come filled with cream and chocolate chips, and drizzled with more chocolate. The presentation was spectacular!Will I come again? Yes. The ambiance is tasteful, calm and serene, and there is outdoor dining as well.

We have gone a few times and each time we've had Awesome food, Great service and a very nice atmosphere. Highly recommend!