The Most Scrumptious Sandwiches in Columbus

Ron's Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.2 (26) • $

"Good pizza. They carry anchovies. For me a big plus!! Place is clean, staff is friendly."

Matt and Tony's Kitchen x Tavern

★★★★☆ 4.1 (285) • $$

"My husband and I stopped in for a late dinner the night before Labor Day. The service was great, and the food was fantastic. We ordered the pimento cheese fried chicken sandwich as well as the portobello mushroom sandwich. The fries were hot and crispy. Everything was seasoned well. Just superb. Reasonable prices and great ambiance. We shall return!"

Picnic Pizza Col. Sq. Mall

★★★★☆ 3.7 (3)

"Great place for pizza and subs! Fresh and Delicious! Nice sized portions. Staff very friendly and hardworking. very clean environment with a lot of choices. We decided on the Italian Sub and a slice of pizza. The sub was amazing. Soft bread and fresh lettuce, tomato, onion and banana pepper. Overall, a wonderful place to sit and quickly eat before doing some shopping. Will return!"

Biggby Coffee

★★★★☆ 3.5 (17)

"I've been here twice and both times have had a good experience. I got the cold brew with cinnamon and honey. I got hubs the butter bear. It's not an everyday coffee (too rich & too many calories) but it's a nice treat. The employees have been super friendly and the line goes pretty quickly."

Challah Food Truck

★★★★☆ 4.2 (48) • $

"When an establishment makes such bold proclamations like "BEST CHICKEN SANDWICH IN COLUMBUS," I have to investigate such claims. Between this and rumors of Chicken & Waffles ice cream, I was beyond intrigued when I approached the truck on a recent Sunday. Unfortunately, they were out of the aforementioned ice cream, but I was able to get my hands on the crispy chicken sandwich. Was it the best? I don't know, I haven't eaten every chicken sandwich in town (yet), but they're damn close. The chicken isn't weighed down with heavy breading, it's somehow light and crisp, with fresh tasting toppings, and a fluffy bun to boot. If you like dill, you will appreciate the herby sauce they use. My companions had the fried potatoes as well, and were in heaven. I still need to go back for the ice cream, but if this sandwich was any indication, it will be worth the trip."

Liberty Gathering Place

★★★★☆ 4.2 (17)

""Small town with a big heart." That is what I would describe the Liberty Gathering Place as. Stopped in here after walking in the West Liberty Labor Day Parade last month. I had the pulled pork sandwich (which was homemade I think) with their fries. It was pretty tasty. If I ever make it back to West Liberty, I will have to stop by again. Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Yelpness!5/5 stars"

Brewfontaine

★★★★★ 4.5 (152) • $$

"Our server/bartender was great. Everyone's food was good but mine was not great. I ordered the loaded tater tots as an appetizer they came out with the meal and they were not hot. My entree was the French Dip. The meat and onions were cooked perfectly and the au jus was good. My only problem was the bread was just a smooshed hoagie bun. A sandwich like that needs to be served on a nice French Bread or Italian roll. The Hoagie bun was soggy and smashed."

Barry Bagels Westerville

★★★☆☆ 3.4 (109) • $

"I've been wanting bagels all week, but I am a night person and bagel places are morning-centric. Most close at 1 or 2. This one is open till 3, and was handy for my errands today, so I stopped in.Small place tucked away in a strip. Parking is cramped. Plenty of options at the counter for bagels, sandwiches, etc. I got lox on onion, and egg salad on garlic. Plus made a combo with drink and chili, and added an Asiago bagel with scallion cream cheese. The lox was great- bright "fresh" tender salmon, excellent bagel, some onions and capers adding texture. The egg salad was good- I asked for two scoops so it was overflowing. Again, good bagel, and the egg salad was lovely. The simple bagel and cream cheese was also good. The chili was like my mom's, tasty but not too spicy. There is a little heat hiding in there, so if you don't like spicy maybe stay away.Great service. Decent prices (and a check-in offer.) Fast and good. And open "late." Glad to find them."

Waynes Country Market

★★★★☆ 4.4 (21)

"I absolutely love Wayne's. Their seasonal produce is almost always cheaper than anywhere else. They have lots of unique offerings as well as a nice deli. In response to a couple other reviews: I've never had an issue with their produce spoiling quickly compared with other stores, and I've never noticed that their produce is consistently poor. I think all produce anywhere you buy it is hit or miss. Also unlike at the supermarket, their produce rotates in and out because they tend to have whatever is in season. I rely less on labels and more on appearance to find what I'm looking for. There's always some difference between what a sweet pepper and a hot pepper, for example. I've almost always had positive experiences with the staff in all parts of the store, and I think the employees, young and old, are generally friendly and helpful. The deli is a busy place but I've never had anyone be rude to me there. The only time I've had any issue was when I didn't grab a number because they didn't look too busy. Word to the wise... they still go in order and you will get skipped if you didn't grab a number!"

Dad's Coneys & Wraps

★★★★★ 4.7 (7)

"Today is the only time in history when the past meets the future. That is what I felt when I walked inner this establishment. An establishment with a rich and proud history, but also participating into today's technology to make your time spent here comfortable. The menu is sure to make you feel compelled to return to try everything. American comfort food that also does tacos. Shut the front door you can't go wrong. I had the coneys. I love Coney's. I don't like hot dogs with chili on top. The cheese was perfectly proportioned, the coney mix was beefy with character The onions added a nice kick. I may have just found my next bad habit"

Lang's Pizza And Subs

★★★★☆ 3.8 (10)

"Raspberry vinegar and honey French sauce are packs by Marzetti. Try them on pizza. Had them with lasagna. Takes longer at forty minutes about time went by fast. Surprised by how long a pizza place has been here. Logo and everything after the remodel look very modern. Customized dish with vegetables which are baked on the side. They got cool chips and basically menu-wise a neat selection . Clean too. Has outlets. WiFi also looks open. Has juice boxes. So not just soda. Found staff to be detailed. Kid's and Sub meal deals. Can find a pic of their freshly made Apple pizza on the website only over Google or Yelp. On Sides section. Their cheese is all made (right now) w premix shredded provolone and mozzarella."

Creno’s Pizza

★★★☆☆ 2.7 (3)

"Just your run of the average pizza shop ran by highschoolers. Food is a 4/10. Everytime time i ordered there was always a problem with our food or they didn't include something with it. Their boneless chicken was dry and pizza is just plain tasting. The sub i ordered was burnt. You'll be better off just getting McDonald's right beside the restaurant."

Lu Lu’s Kitchen

★★★★☆ 4.2 (26)

"We stopped in Bucyrus for a quick overnight stay and decided to try this place out for breakfast. So glad we did! My husband and I split an omelette and it was plenty of food! Very delicious, sometimes omelettes can be too greasy and this one was definitely NOT! It was cooked perfectly."

Senetaste Restaurant

★★★★☆ 3.8 (16)

"A local gem - after multiple.trips I'm always impressed with the service and how helpful they are. Often giving samples of tea, coffee. Great unique dishes. Watch out for the peppers they are sneaky spicy!"

Pat's Pizza & Pub

★★★★☆ 4.4 (18) • $$

"Pat's serves up a solid Central Ohio style pizza. Yeah, it's good as they've nailed that crispy cracker crust. They also top their pies with a good amount of sauce, cheese and whatever toppings you want and it'll still be steaming as it hits the table. Not into a pizza? No problem. They have a pretty decent sized menu that offers various subs and other sandwiches, hot wings and the usual deep fried good stuff that most bars tend to offer. Prices are more than fair too. Pat's is typical, laidback, smalltown casual. They offer bar seating, a dining room and they also have a really nice and comfortable patio for some great al fresco dining. They are one of the few places in West Jefferson that has a liquor license so you can get a brew or cocktail which is nice.Their service is good and friendly. What's not to like?5 StarsAndHere'sAnotherSliceOrTwoForYou:** If you're on the westside of Columbus and you want a little afternoon escape, Pat's is only about a 10 minute shot straight out West Broad Street.** Their alcohol selection isn't huge but they can make most standard drinks."

D K's Drive-In

★★★★☆ 4.1 (7) • $

"This place is awesome I only come here for the desert and its always good! Umm maybe not the s'mores flurrie... Don't get that it tastes like fake chocolate and nasty crackers thrown in there... But yeah everything else is AawESOMe I must have been there like 5 times when I visited my sister in the area..."

Mary B’s Diner

★★★★☆ 4 (22) • $$

"I'm a long time fan of Mary B's Diner on the other side of town. So, I was excited to try this new location out.I was seated nearly immediately after the gaggle of waitresses finished their personal conversations. My waitress was very friendly.I ordered a unsweetened Iced tea, Hot dog with chili, slaw and onions with side of vegetable beef soup with crackers. Very good and definitely recommend"

Beyond Measure Market

★★★★★ 4.9 (8)

"A nice store to visit near Amish country. A great selection of grocery items with a deli section in the back with hand made to order sandwiches and a dining area to eat. Don't miss the bakery fresh fruit hand pies, I liked the cherry the best. Out front is a very large horse draw wagon which is a great place for a photo op.We will be back again."

Quaker Steak & Lube

★★★☆☆ 2.6 (5) • $$

"Been there with family and friends. National chain. This one holds the standards for presentation and service. The motif is a bit funky but still fun. Younger crowd it seems. Basic fast food fare. Never a bad experience."

Station1

★★★☆☆ 2.9 (33) • $$

"Yup, just a whole in the wall that paid off. Needed a spot after a long drive and stumbled on this bar instead of the brewery for some reason. Either way we had some nachos and jalapeño cheesy bread they hit the spot. Nachos were burnt which was actually perfect and the bread had a hefty amount of cheese. Also got some beers and they filled up a growler for us. Definitely a cool spot to hang out in. Eat well and travel safe -ant"

Cumberland Trails Bar and Grill

★★★☆☆ 2.6 (16)

"Had lunch with our Church Group! Oh my what a nice surprise. 10 of us and happy 10. Wide selection of food and everything was hot and good! Definitely a new favorite for us! Worth the Drive. Play Golf there now we will be eating there!"

Sparano's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.9 (88) • $$

"This is a very solid choice for a Columbus style, party cut, or whatever the hell you want to call it pie. Mine was extra cheesy so I really liked that, and they don't skimp on the ingredients here.I think my favorite part overall was the crust. It's super thin, and super crispy but not burnt. It really provides a nice crunch when you're digging in to this pizza and was probably the highlight for me.I don't have a whole lot to say about this place other than I wish I had tried it sooner. It's definitely a good option for people in the Grandview/Quarry/Riverside area and just a straight up good Columbus pizza."

Los Guachos Hamilton

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (34) • $

"So if you're a regular or my reviews, you'll know that I have an Achilles heel when it comes to Al Pastor. I used to have a regular place that I loved to regularly go to in order to indulge my delicious weekness with, but they have sadly changed the recipe and style of their Al Pastor tacos! *shaking fist to the sky* Why God, why?? After years of perfection, they have finally peaked and fallen, which left me without a taco place for my fix . Luckily, I have found my new place to get those delicious little tacos at that know how to marinate, cut, and fry up just perfectly (cooked on a spit with a pineapple on top with big flat pieces cut off and lightly grilled to perfection). It's so mouth wateringly delicious! The texture is crispy but juicy, the marinate isn't spicy but flavorful, and the amount is plentiful per taco but not so much you can't fold it to commute the little sucker in your face thankfully. Other than my Al Pastor tacos for my daughter and I, I picked up a carne asada monarco burrito (mozarella cheese, pico de gallo and guacamole stuffed with steak) for my partner who seemed to be filled and pleased! It was definitely a big burrito and should tame even the hungriest beast of yours. I also was blessed enough to be treated to a cancelation carne asada torta (thanks and good looking out Los Guachos!). The bread was fresh and fluffy, the steak was good (not as good as the Al Pastor IMO but still yum) and half will fill you up if you're someone who doesn't eat a whole bunch and the entire thing would DEFINITELY make you full. The fish taco is crispy and flaky. They serve it in a flour tortilla, which tastes freshly made in house IMO. The Chipotle sauce that they drizzle on top of the fish is smoky and not too spicy, so if you are afraid of it being too hot to enjoy, don't worry. The al pastor gringa YES. JUST YES. Truly, you can't go wrong with the tacos or gringas. The only difference between the gringa and taco really is that it comes with cheese... might be something else in there too, but sadly, I inhaled that too quickly to report... well, it's not sad for me .... You can tell the word has gotten out about here because people were waiting on the parking lot for it to open including myself! So if you're near this place, just GO. Oh, and try that orchata because it won't disappoint ."

Rosebud's

★★★★★ 4.6 (8)

"We went for dinner Saturday night. The place was packed, but we were seated fairly quickly. The service was friendly and fast. And the food is amazing! I had the wedge salad & mushroom rice soup. Fantastic. Hubs had the roasted cabbage Caesar and soup. SNL had sausage ragu, loved it. Definitely will be back. Sadly forgot to take pics."

Fluff

★★★★☆ 4.2 (76) • $

"What a delightful surprise. My wife & I came here for lunch. We had the Thai rice bowl. The food was excellent. The pastries look fantastic (we did not order them). This is the type of coffee/bake shop you will find in Greenwich Village.We spoke to the owner who is a delightful woman & OU alumna. Why go to Starbucks or Panera when you have Fluff?"

Route 22 Cafe

★★★★★ 4.8 (4)

"This place was the best part of our Salt Fork trip, hands down. Stopped in on a whim on a Saturday morning and were greeted by a welcoming shop selling Amish goods, cute decor, and delicious food. We ordered an iced blackberry lavender latte and a hot coconut milk cappuccino and both were excellent. My husband got a sausage, egg, and cheese breakfast sandwich on a croissant and said it was great too. It was huge and very reasonably priced! The staff working behind the counter were very friendly too. After we placed our order I walked over and got a few dry goods from the attached shop as well - all great. Thank you, Route 22 Cafe!"

Bags Sports Pub Sugarcreek

★★★★☆ 3.6 (67) • $$

"Maple Bacon Burger was excellent!! Not to sweet and the onions blended perfectly with the chipotle infused maple syrup. My girlfriend got the Bourbon Salmon and shrimp combination, and it was cooked perfectly. They fish was tender and seasoned well. The shrimp were big in size and not overdone at all. Our server,Ciana, was fantastic!!! She gave us recommendations that accommodated our tastes! Nice pub with great atmosphere and and well taken care of, clean bathrooms and good music!"

Wilson's Sandwich Shop

★★★★☆ 3.7 (75) • $

"Customer service here is impeccable, they treat you as if you are family. Your order comes quick and fresh! Portions are decent and price is fair $10 for a burger, drink, and dessert!"

Buehler's Cafe at Towne Market

★★★☆☆ 3.4 (14) • $$

"We were in town for a family reunion over in Dundee and needed to make a "pot luck" dish for the event.Buehler's came to the rescue and everything was great!Thanks Buehler's!"

Wings Over Columbus

★★★★☆ 3.5 (201) • $$

"Wasn't sure what to expect here. Maybe because of that, I was very pleasantly surprised.Ordered a 12-piece tender with honey bbq and "fire" sauce. My friends enjoyed the honey bbq but I like a spicy, tangy Buffalo sauce, and the fire sauce did not disappoint on both fronts.Got a side of hot garlic sauce as well for dipping the waffle fries. It was perfectly spicy but also full of great flavor: the spice didn't overwhelm and take away from the flavor.Chicken is nice, fresh, and juicy white meat- not that weird squishy composite chicken you see at some other wing places. I ordered delivery via a third party app, and everything was prepared and delivered on time.I also requested a lot of different sauces and sides (multiple ranches, bleu cheeses, celery, etc.), and none of the items were missing. That isn't always the case with delivery, so I was pleased to see no mistakes with my order.Also, small detail: the side of celery was clean, no brown/oxidized spots, and tender. Other places give you the nasty, tough outside celery pieces that are all brown from sitting out in the air for too long. It's the little things, man."

Wally's Pizza

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (12) • $

"TL;DR: Close to freeway, clean, cheap, friendly, solid pizza.Nice place that isn't too far off the freeway (about 1.5 miles) if you are driving through and looking from somewhere to eat that isn't a chain. You can get pizza by the slices by request, took about ten minutes, but wasn't too bad (could have called ahead). The staff members were very friendly and the everything looked clean and orderly. We ordered six slices of pizza and a can of pop, and it was less than $9, so you can't beat that. The pizza was good, I've had better, but solid nonetheless. Would recommend."

The Grainery

★★★★☆ 3.8 (98) • $$

"Love this place. Would highly recommend. Ordered the barbecue brisket. Wonderful and delicious. Candied Bacon appetizer is the best. Great food. Bands are great. Must come to enjoy food and atmosphere"

Jersey Mike's Subs

★★★☆☆ 3.2 (13)

"Love this place. Always friendly, order online most of the time and sandwich is always done correctly and on time. Delicious fresh ingredients and are hands down the best sub in town.I read where someone complained about they ordered online and it wasn't ready when they arrived in 20 minutes. Thing is that's almost exclusively what I use to order and every time it's 30 minutes so if you arrive in 20 yeah it may not be ready."

Station

★★★★★ 4.7 (40) • $$

"New place in Granville! Always nice.We stopped in for a quick bite, which became quicker and more of a bite than we had anticipated. We walked up to the counter to order, and you could see they were a bit busy. The lady at the counter was kind enough to let us know that any items from the kitchen would be a 30 minute wait. We instead opted for a cheddar sausage jalapeño muffin type thing, plus an iced mocha and an iced lavender honey latte.The sausage biscuit was super tasty! And the coffees were actually some of the best, most well-balanced iced coffees I have had in a long time, and I have had a lot of iced coffees from a lot of different places.Hopefully they can get their kitchen up to speed with the demand they are having from customers! No stars taken because the staff was still nice and they are still pretty new. Looking forward to trying more from the kitchen."

Sí Señor Peruvian Sandwiches

★★★★★ 4.9 (8)

"Just a short one, as I'm about to start one of my usual games at the Origins Game Fair. I was in Santiago on business last November. While there, i had a lovely sandwich at a Peruvian/Chilean restaurant called Hijo del Sol.The sandwiches at Si Senor are identical to what I got in Santiago. Delectable, flavorful, and a prefect balance of textures. Can't beat it!"