The Yummiest Custom Cakes in Columbus

Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery

★★★★★ 4.6 (117) • $$

"Just got done eating a red velvet cupcake from here and WOW. So good! I've been in this shopping center tons of times and never noticed this place until going to lunch at 101 beer kitchen today. On a whim we decided to stop in for dessert and this place didn't disappoint. Service was super fast and friendly and they have tons of cupcake options. The red velvet cupcake is top tier! So moist, soft and the icing was great. Will definitely come back!"

Mrs. Goodman's Baking

★★★★★ 4.5 (94) • $$

"They did a great job with a custom order. I had 2 dozen cookies with different designs. It ended up being $4 a cookie, which seems pricey, but the cookies were large and very delicious. My guests raved. The shop is really cute and they do cakes, other pastries, cupcakes and cookies"

Golden Delight Bakery

★★★★☆ 4 (114) • $$

"I stopped in for the first time yesterday after hearing great things. Golden Delight did not disappoint! I needed a last minute birthday cake. I know they are known for their strawberry cake but we went with the mocha. They offered to add a message on the spot! The cake was extremely light with mocha flavor in both the frosting and cake. It was excellent! There are also decorative coffee beans on top- they are chocolate. Highly recommended!"

Sugar Rush Columbus

★★★★★ 4.6 (61)

"I'll start by saying that I've only experienced Sugar Rush once and it was specifically for their cupcakes. My friend's boyfriend put an order in for us and even delivered them. He's a sweetie. I got a lemon blueberry cupcake with blueberry icing and I couldn't put it down. There were whole blueberries inside, sort of like a muffin, but it was all cake. It was gone in a flash. My friend went with the red velvet and raved about it as well. I'm not in the Reynoldsburg area very often but I know my first cupcake from here won't be my last."

Cakes and More

★★★★★ 4.6 (36) • $

"SO much love for Cakes and More! It's been a couple years since I've been able to stop in, but they are still making those shortbread buttercream filled butterfly cookies that are just my ultimate jam, and I get knock-out sugar cravings for.I also tried some sort of Chilean or Ecuadorian truffle type of dessert with caramel, meringue and caramel and.... my-oh-MY was it delicious! Glad I decided to take that one home to try. The cakes here look phenomenal. The cooler was filled with orders ready for pickup and each one was meticulously decorated to specifications, and looked really fun! The lady in the back works her magic with a smile of acknowledgement through the glass window peering into her world. Lots of natives were flooding in here. My guess is for the empanadas and other treats they make here. I've only had the sugar coma inducing goodies for now, but man, did I forget how great this little Mom & Pop place is!Worth a stop if you're in the area! You can't go wrong with anything in their cases! Delicioso!"

Clown Cones & Confections

★★★★★ 4.5 (32) • $

"Sometimes I don't think about recommending some thing that's been around so long. My 50 year old niece used to love to go to this place when she was a kid.I've been taken nephews and cousins and my own children here forever.Their chocolate ice cream is my chocolate Favorite, the kids love the chocolate cones!And I must say the service there is good because it seems to be like we spent about 1000 years in there to spend five dollars per kid lol and nobody else got impatient except me.There's not a lot of room in there but it's just a fun experience for kids and grandmas too"

Carolyn’s Bake Shop - The Hills Market

★★★★★ 5 (10)

"This bakery is amazing! She is so flexible and willing to work with you on whatever you may need. She did my entire wedding dessert table with cupcakes, cake, macaroons, cookies... the list goes on! From then on out she's my go to from birthday parties to just because cakes :) her flavors are so freaking good whether you go traditional or one of her fun flavor combos. My favorite is the PB&J, caramel banana, and the lemon blueberry!"

Country Cakes and Bakes

★★★★★ 4.9 (7)

"Always delicious no matter what you order! Fresh and visually appealing. Order ahead online. We've ordered a variety of items for several large events and been extremely pleased."

Biscotti Cookies and Cakes

★★★★★ 5 (4)

"I stopped in randomly after driving past on the way to the BMV. I wondered if they had cupcakes.The friendly owner said she makes them special order and gave me her card. I purchased two mini cakes - one chocolate with chocolate frosting, and the other strawberry with strawberry frosting. I also zero'd in on the Iced Almond Sugar Cookies and bought two. She said it was her most popular flavor.Now that I know this shop is there, I will make it a regular stop."

ShuGar Daisy's Bakeshop

★★★★★ 4.5 (2)

"Let me first start out by saying...WOW. Now it's time for the review. The owner of ShuGar Daisy was very responsive and ensured the right cake was being made. I ordered a birthday cake for my mother's 40th, and requested the design of a 'Skull Cake', similar looking to the Day of the Dead tradition. It turned out better than what I expected. I mean, I can't describe to you how awesome it turned out, almost speechless. The creative design with the colors, edible pieces on the top, and overall look was amazing. The other note I'll add is it was a pricey cake but creating art is expensive so this is open to debate. Overall, if you want an creative designed cake, I would highly recommend ShuGar Daisy's Bakeshop!!"