The Carmella. Big enough for 2!
Kim's convenience
outside
menu
1/2 of a Carmella
View
menu
menu
Carmella
a hand holding a sandwich
Street sign
Toasty Tammy
Let's do lunch!
outside
Mural
Paulie's Pastrami
a hand holding a sandwich
The Peggy Sue!
Toasty Tammy
Menu
Menu Dec 2022
The Yo Adrian
Mark D.
Feb 21, 2025
A delicious deli choice near me? Hell yes I'll be there! Every. Sandwich. Is. Amazing. The staff is awesome. Everything is great.
Read MoreLaura F.
Jan 15, 2025
Stopped back at Buck City Dec 29th with some friends. Decided to try the fried green tomato sandwich with bacon. It was good. Huge. Bug enough for two people. Came with chips. As good as it was, I still think the Carmella is better. I will be back to challenge another menu item against your perfectly created Carmella sandwich.
Read MoreJason M.
Sep 19, 2024
Let me lead with you need their 'Yo Adrian sandwich in your life. And you need Isiah to make it for you. This guy is a magician and crafted an exceptional combination of fresh cheeses, vegetables, quality meats and date I say it truffle butter for our lunch this morning. Take a look at the menu and you dimply can't go wrong down there in East Market. The venue has this awesome industrial hawker stall vibe and I'm going to return tomorrow because it was simply delicious. Give it a go!
Read MoreSonja C.
Feb 6, 2025
Tried this place out today and it was pretty good. The service was also pretty good. The guy that helped was was Isah and he was friendly. Also being that this place is in a market it was cool that they had their own seating attached to their booth. I ordered the cheese sandwich and it was a good sandwich. I'm not a fan of Swiss cheese but I was pleasantly surprised with the sandwich. Each sandwich comes with a bag of chips and that was nice too
Read MoreRon F.
Mar 10, 2024
If your a sandwich person you will need to put this spot on your list. Great local vendor located inside the East Market (the historic old trolley building). We ordered and split The Carmella for lunch. Yes half was enough for one person and it was delicious. I was sad when it was gone. Yes, the sandwiches are a little pricey, but they are worth it with all fresh ingredients and they are big.Service is spot on and the attention they make to prepare your sandwich shows. The is one both in their location but there is plenty of seating around the market.They have a large lot adjacent to the building so parking isn't a problem. I can't wait to go back to try one of their other creations. Stop by and give them a try...I promise you will not be disappointed.
Read MoreOli G.
Nov 9, 2024
They know what they're doing here. There was some cheesesteak pop up that opened next to them and it just looked like an overpriced waste of time. Instead I went to Buck City Sammie's with unique flavor profiles, not your run of the mill tasting breads from Krogers or Giant Eagle but fresh bakery level breads and girthy, meaty, thick sandwiches. Prices and quality here are on par with Brown Bag Deli and it's well worth the price for the high superior quality and flavors. On the other hand if you want a cheap sandwich, with cheap quality and meats like it came from a government food pantry then go to Subway or wack ass Jimmy John's where the bread overpowers the meat.
Read MoreSue D.
Mar 3, 2024
Soooo delicious! Great sandwich, friendly service! Can't wait to try more sandwiches. Definitely check them out at The East Market!
Read MoreMeg H.
Mar 13, 2024
Excellent sandwiches; a little pricey but big sized (you could split with a friend and still be satisfied!). I had the Karen (turkey, pimento cheese, cranberry jam, red onion, arugula on rye) and Yo Adrian (salami, traditional salami, capicola, house pesto, mozzarella, mayo, arugula, on sourdough) and both were so good and quite different. Service was quick and incredibly friendly.
Read MoreD H.
Aug 14, 2024
Ordered the Carmella !!! Baguette was a 10 out of 10. Huge sandwich. A little pricey at $19 but it will feed me twice. Quality meats. Girl fixing it was very nice!!!
Read MoreAvid R.
Mar 2, 2025
$17 sandwiches- good taste and selection, though I don't think we would get it again given price for the amount of food/protein in sandwich. Waited 35 minutes for our two sandwiches. Located inside of East Market, so very cool vibe and fun place to walk around as we live around the corner.
Read More