Brooklyn Pizza

Authentic NY style pie here. The white pie was amazing. I thought it edged out the regular cheese pizza. Would return!

Ordered two pies online. Pick up was fast after floating in cartoon character-style on the smell from the parking lot. Employees were very nice but most importantly the pizza crushed. The plain cheese hit my NYC cravings and the guys loved their pepperoni and banana peppers.

I'm not even sure how to word this other than HELL YEAH. I'm from New York and it's impossible to find good NY style pizza and this guy nailed it. He's a Long Island native and he knows exactly what's up. We will be returning for sure. This breathes life back into this New Yorker for sure!! Do it.

This is our go-to New York pizza. We always order two pies for a family of four. We eat it for two days and it keeps well.

Pizza was good but the cannolis stole the show!! Best ones we have found in Columbus by far.

After hearing so much about how this is the closest thing to NY-style pizza, we finally got around to trying out Brooklyn Pizza. It is definitely the best NY-style pizza place that I have been to in Columbus. The restaurant also has the NYC vibes going with minimalistic pizzeria ambience, no-frills and to-the-point customer service, and delicious, foldable slices (to fold or not to fold - that is up to you). We ended up getting two pies - the cheese and the pesto chicken. The cheese was the clear winner between the two. I will definitely go back here for the cheese pizza, and wish they had other meat topping options such as beef or chicken for non-pork eaters.

Quaint little pizza shop in Powell. The pizza here is decent, much better than others I've had in Ohio. Is it NY pizza though? No the sauce is a little too sweet and it's lacking cheese, the crust is nice and crispy and it is foldable. The price is also decent compared to what you pay for other large not as tasty pies in Columbus. I ordered pickup and it only took them about 20minutes to get it ready, the cashier was super pleasant!

Just not it. Been trying it for years. Ups & downs like regular shops. Last straw was changing the sausage. ARE YOU SERIOUS?! The recipe was perfect. It used to be the best sausage pie. Nah I'm done.

Decent pizza but the owner is an ass. Acts like you are doing him a favor by ordering a pie. Never on time they quote either.

Great pizza! Limited indoor seating, but the food is great! Folks taking our order was helpful and kind. We'll be back!