Borgata Pizza Cafe
Borgata Pizza Cafe
This is a 4 cheese pizza with sun-dried tomatoes. Mozzarella, parmesan, Romano and gouda.
Chocolate chip and buckeye cannolis
Borgata menu, which does change.
Sign inside Budd Diary Food Hall
Meatball sub to go! Unplanned, but the dogs stole and ate a bunch of this "tomorrow for lunch" take-home LOL!
Borgata store front suite in Budd Dairy.
Three Cheese Pizza with Hot Honey
Menu
a hand holding a slice of pizza
pizza, food
$45 for a half-cooked pizza with 85 cents worth of bacon.
Emily W.
Feb 28, 2024
I promise you they have the best hot honey in the city. Absolutely delicious pizza as well!
Read More
Marissa C.
Mar 4, 2022
I stopped at Borgata in Budd Dairy Food Hall to pick up some cannoli (chocolate chip and buckeye, though they also have a tasty sounding pistachio!). The pizza looks absolutely amazing, though! They had several fresh ones coming out of the oven and in the case, and the pies and slices were huge! We definitely want to try some pizza in the future. The chocolate chip cannoli was really good, and the buckeye cannoli was amazing!The staff was so friendly! They got us all set up with beautiful looking cannoli in to-go boxes and a bag. Parking is available in the lot along the side of the building (follow the signage) and some nearby street parking is available.
Read More
Dawn A.
Aug 22, 2023
Wow! So disappointing. We live out of state and used to always go to the location on 161. Had to order from this location this time. The food was so disappointing. Will not be back. It is not the same quality of food that it once was.
Read More
Joanna M.
Mar 20, 2022
There has been a death in the Borgata Family: whoever did their quality control is clearly no longer with us. Seriously though, if Borgata is actually a local family... all I can say is that you should swing by the Budd Dairy location and look what is passing for "Borgata Pizza". The other two locations of this restaurant (Linworth and Worthington) make the most fantastic pizza I have ever tasted in the US. Absolutely incredible. Perfection. Worth every penny and more. Budd dairy... seems like maybe it was franchised by a Sbarro.
Read More
John B.
Mar 4, 2022
You can purchase by the slice YES YES YES . It's not new york pizza but it's a new York slice of pizza. Love band on Friday night gave it the 4th star. GO and Enjoy.
Read More
Walt S.
Mar 2, 2022
Borgata Pizza Café came as a recommendation from a close friend. She claimed Borgata served top shelf pizza. And,....drum roll. She was telling the truth. This tiny suite served me a single-slice, NYC style, four cheese pizza topped with sun-dried tomatoes (julienne cut). First - the pizza's heat. The pizza maker knows the biz because that single came piping hot and stayed hot the entire eating time. I don't ask HOW. I smile!!! The mix of mozzarella, parmesan, romano and gouda cheeses was heaven. I was told it was the first of its kind for them. I said, "A masterpice." Go go get yah some Borgata "pee-zzah".
Read More
Rob R.
Apr 1, 2023
Columbus Underground named this restaurant the 6th best pizza place in Columbus. We ordered a 20" pizza with meatballs and sausage, and the pizza we received was undercooked and inedible. My wife pointed this out to our waitress, whose response was "Well, that happens sometimes because of the oven". We boxed the pizza up and took it home, hoping to save it and it was still terrible. We won't be back.
Read More
Mike L.
Aug 27, 2022
The food & reviews look great. I ordered the full 20 inch pepperoni pizza for delivery. It was easy & arrived way ahead of its estimated delivery time. Unfortunately the pizza was soggy including the crust & pepperoni topping. I may have got a pie that's been under the warmer for quite a while. It's pizza, so it wasn't bad but nothing amazing or worth ordering again. For $40+ a pizza I expect more, one made to order.
Read More
Shawn F.
Jun 21, 2022
Pizza flavorful - crust was chewy- toppings fresh Didn't follow any instructions left with the order. It needed few more minutes to be done in middle. The pizza was not well done.
Read More
J A.
May 6, 2023
Bad pizza and bad, slow service. Avoid. Tons of other better pizza options that arent rude to their customers.
Read More
