a skillet of mexican food and a bottle of tequila
Chimichanga Grande
Vibe
Patio!
Dining room is clean
a pink cocktail in a glass with a straw and garnish garnish
House Marg
Decor
a table and booths in a restaurant
Skinny margarita- Tequila with orange and lime juice
Chicken Fajitas
tacos, food
Chicken Mole Enchiladas
food, nachos
Chicken Fajitas
Tamale on top, chimichanga on bottom. A la carte
nachos, food
Bill should of had 5 items totaling under 23 bucks. They adjusted it.
Bathroom
Chimichanga and rice both a la carte
Chicken enchilada a la carte
Chicken chimichanga and chicken tamale
Melinda T.
Feb 3, 2025
Was there fo lunch.A lady and I started talking. Had a great conversation.She was so kind and bought my lunch.I was so surprised.She left and I continued to eat.A male manager was at the bar, where we were sitting.He came over to me and said just because she paid your lunch does not mean you do not have to tip. WHAT!He leaned against the bar right across from me and glared at me.Very intimidating.I'm sure she did tip for me.Him being a manager should not be so concerned about tips.The clincher I was going to leave tip.I did but it was not as large as I was initially going to leave.Very intimidating lunch.Will not go again.
Read More
Laura F.
May 31, 2024
Bad trip in to Blue agave. The host was amazing and that was about it. Food took a while to get. That is unusual here, even on a busy day. Today, it wasn't packed...the house was 25% full., so Im unsure what the long delay was.Meanwhile we ate complimentary chips and salsa. The salsa tasted like it had zero cilantro and zero onion. What we compared it to is : if you took just plain canned diced tomatoes and zipped them in the food processor and served just that. It was not good. There was little cilantro and onion, if at all. It took so long to get the food, we ate the entire bowl of chips -hardly touching the salsa. They nicely asked if we wanted more. We declined on that. LolOur dinner was hit and miss. We ordered all a la carte items: The chicken chimichangas and chicken enchilada were excellent.... They had good flavor. The chicken was perfect. Good size for a la carte. Had some fresh veggies inside. Yum. Although my chimi had hardly any cheese topping, which was odd as my husband's had a nice amount. . My husband's chicken tamale was disappointing- hardly any chicken in it.. the side of rice I got was flavorless and a bit dry. Our issue here today wasn't the slow service or the delay in the food, or the quality of food. It was the bill: pay attention to what the menu says your food costs. Every single item on our bill was charged incorrectly. No joke. All but one item was charged too much and one item was charged 20 cents too little. Two items were billed as an entree even though ordered al a carte, but even that pricing was over charged as well. It was so weird and a bit frustrating. We ordered five items that should of come out to 22.75. Our bills total was 27.15. When I saw only four prices on the bill (with no item designation) I went to decipher it, which is hard as there was also no itemization of what the pricing corresponded to. We found "none" of the pricing on the bill was correct. I nicely explained this and it was adjusted with an apology... but a guest should never be put in this situation, as its embarrassing to have to say... "can I see the menu again" do math.... then say "uh, my bill is five dollars too much." Blue Agave... I want to like you.... I want to give a good review. I keep coming in and hoping it will go smoothly. Sadly for us, It rarely does.
Read More
Matthew H.
Nov 24, 2024
Food was awful this evening . Tasted like unseasoned beef and boiled chicken in my burrito. I've had better Mexican food at Taco Bell, they actually season the meat. My Wife hated the beef on the tostada and the chip salsa tasted like tomato juice ketchup. Service was awful and they charged me more then the check. Extremely unhappy and don't ever plan on coming back. If this is the kind of food and service offered, I hope they go away and make room for some good food.
Read More
Phil T.
Mar 21, 2024
We are regulars to this establishment, and as usual the food was absolutely amazing. However, tonight the service was sub-par. Our waitress was not very attentive, did not really listen to our requests. My wifes fajitas came out, did not have the tortillas with it. We waited and waited for our waitress to come back around so she could eat. We ended up having to ask the waiter of the next table for the tortillas. I ordered some extra enchiladas, the plate came out and was missing part of the order (back to waitress not listening)All in all it was 5 star food and 2 star service. We will absolutely be back, but if that waitress has our section we'll request a different server/seating change.
Read More
Nathan F.
Jan 26, 2024
Update. Post-Covid, it seems they've resumed normal operations. Average Mexican joint. We're do it several times a year now and it rarely disappoints. Based on expectations, it's a 4 star. Compared to all other local options it's more like a three star.
Read More
Liz A.
May 13, 2023
A friend had a doc appointment in New Albany and picked a place nearby for a group of us to meet. Living in Gahanna and having been to Blue Agave in Westerville, it was convenient and I knew I'd like the food. I think there ended up being about 8 of us, meeting during the week for lunch around noon. I was about the 5th person to arrive and found them right away. There were plenty of open tables and room at their table for me!I had checked out the menu ahead of time as I always do. I knew there was a salad or two for me to pick from. The waiter took our drink order and I stuck with water. Being in a big group, I wasn't confident I'd get my money's worth on refills if I ordered a soda. We waited for everyone to arrive to put in our food order. And our waiter was ready as soon as the last arrived.I went with a basic salad - steak for a change. I knew the quality of the steak wouldn't be great and they didn't bother asking how I wanted it cooked. I figured the steak would be in strips and it turned out it was.Our order came our in a decent amount of time. And I forgot to mention the complimentary chips and salsa. We each got our own little bowl for salsa so no worries of others double -dipping. I, however, don't do chips as I'd eat too many if I ate just one. Mindless munching is far too easy for me. And I don't need the carbs. They did have a hot salsa available as one of the other ladies requested it. She did confirm that it was HOT!I was pleasantly surprised when my salad arrived at the amount of steak it had. It was rather generous which makes me happy. There was a fair amount of greens but not much avacado - or much else really. Tomatoes is the only other thing I remember. I ordered it without dressing as they didn't have oil and vinegar. It was fine and not too dry.The other ladies were retired but I work. So I had to leave as soon as the checks came out. For a salad and water with tax and tip - I was out the door for $20. That's about what I'd pay elsewhere at any other seated restaurant. Would I return - sure would! Decent food at fair prices.
Read More
Kyle B.
Dec 9, 2023
One of our favorite Mexican restaurants in town. We used to go to their location closer to Polaris, but the food is equally as good at this location. The atmosphere is always fun with the mariachi music and TVs. Overall, would recommend.
Read More
Rose Z.
Apr 29, 2023
Lovely spot! We are originally from the west coast, so super picky and hesitant about trying any Mexican food out here out of fear of being disappointed. This place was as close to home as it's gonna get and was great! Amazing service, food was amazing. Their margaritas are top notch! Also their guac. I loved the cheese sauce on my California burrito. Might be our new go to Mexican spot for us.
Read More
Megan C.
Dec 30, 2022
I would give this restaurant 3.5 stars if possible. We were able to get right into this restaurant without a wait on a Thursday at 7:00pm.My favorite part of this restaurant was the fresh tortillas. They have a tortilla press and you can see the employees making the tortillas. They were delicious! I also really liked the chicken fajitas and if I go back I will order fajitas 100%.I got the chicken mole enchiladas. I did not like these and wouldn't order again. I thought the chicken had little flavor and wasn't a huge fan of the sauce (I prefer spicier sauces with more of a tomato flavor so that is probably a personal thing and nothing against the actual sauce itself). There also wasn't any cheese besides the little bit you can see on the top. I was also hoping the refried beans would have a bit more flavor.The inside of the restaurant is casual and clean looking. Our server was friendly. The food took a while to come out but they were busy and they have free chips and salsa so that helped with the wait.
Read More
M G.
Jan 6, 2025
Management must have changed or something because I have been coming here for a while and you can tell the difference. For one the drinks now have a bunch of fruit that don't have none to do with it... sometimes less is more.. Two food prices and portions don't add up.. food quality and taste has gone down as well.. And third they try to sell me food and drinks im not there for. I just want to get my usual and enjoy it!
Read More