Black Dog Pizzeria
Black Dog Pizzeria
Six large oven baked knots tossed in garlic butter, parmesan and herbs, and served with a side of red sauce.
Fresh pizza dough baked with roasted garlic butter, mozzarella cheese, and served with a side of red sauce.
Buttery oven baked pretzel bites tossed in coarse salt and served with a side of house-made queso.
A warm pan of cheesy, creamy Buffalo chicken dip, served with tortilla chips for dipping.
A side cup of crispy baked cup and curl pepperonis.
Customize your own 10 pizza work of art: Columbus style is a thin, crispy crust, topped edge-to-edge and square cut. All pizzas made with mozzarella cheese unless otherwise noted.
Customize your own 12 pizza work of art: Columbus style is a thin, crispy crust, topped edge-to-edge and square cut. All pizzas made with mozzarella cheese ONLY unless otherwise noted. DOES NOT COME WITH PEPPERONI unless added as a topping.
Customize your own 14 pizza work of art: Columbus style is a thin, crispy crust, topped edge-to-edge and square cut. All pizzas made with mozzarella cheese ONLY unless otherwise noted. DOES NOT COME WITH PEPPERONI unless added as a topping.
Customize your own 16 pizza work of art: Columbus style is a thin, crispy crust, topped edge-to-edge and square cut. All pizzas made with mozzarella cheese ONLY unless otherwise noted. DOES NOT COME WITH PEPPERONI unless added as a topping.
Red sauce, mozzarella, double traditional pepperoni, double old world pepperoni.
Red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onion, mushroom.
Red sauce, mozzarella, meatball, banana pepper, topped with whipped ricotta and fresh basil.
Much cheese, wow! Red sauce, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, colby, parmesan, chihuahua cheese.
Spicy red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, mushroom, topped with hot honey and crushed red pepper.
Red sauce and mozzarella, topped with extra virgin olive oil dressed burrata cheese, basil pesto and fresh basil.
Classic red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, topped with baby arugula, shaved parmesan, balsamic vinaigrette and hot honey.
Barbecue sauce, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, roasted chicken breast, bacon, diced red onion, jalapeo.
Roasted garlic and shallot white sauce, extra virgin olive oil, mozzarella and goat cheese, balsamic marinated portobello mushroom, roasted red pepper, baby spinach, finished with a balsamic vinaigrette.
Red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, meatball... Just a whole lotta meat.
Garlic and shallot white sauce, Carolina gold barbecue sauce, mozzarella cheese, chicken breast, bacon, caramelized onion, baby spinach, topped with fresh cilantro.
Basil pesto, mozzarella, roasted chicken breast, tomato, caramelized onion, topped with shaved parmesan and fresh basil.
Red sauce, mozzarella cheese, sliced ham, crumbled bacon, sausage, topped with whipped ricotta cheese and hot garlic chili crunch oil.
Stromboli filled with cheese, your choice of up to three toppings, and served with a side of pizza sauce. Large serves 3-4. Small serves 1-2.
Traditional bone-in baked wings tossed in a sauce or dry rub of your choice and served with a side of ranch or blue cheese dressing.
Boneless breaded wings tossed in a sauce of your choice and served with a side of ranch or blue cheese.
Salami, ham, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, and our house-made creamy Italian dressing. Served toasted on an Auddinos sub bun.
Meatballs baked in our classic red sauce, mozzarella and goat cheese. Served on a toasted Auddionos sub bun.
Iceberg and romaine lettuce tossed with sliced tomatoes, diced red onions, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, crisp cup and curl pepperonis, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing.
Romaine lettuce tossed with shaved Parmesan, croutons, and served with Caesar dressing. Add chicken breast or bacon for an additional charge.
Bite sized balls of chocolate and funfetti cake coated in frosting and put on a stick. Its a cake pop! Available in three festive designs.
Four Italian rainbow cookies made with almond cake, sweet raspberry filling, and a chocolate coating.
Four Italian rainbow cookies made with pink and red almond cake layers, Nutella filing, and a rich chocolate coating with colorful sprinkles.
Crisp pie crust filled with chocolate and peanut butter, and topped with a creamy whipped chocolate topping.
Pie crust filled with a whipped cookie filling and topped with crumbled sandwich cookies and chocolate chips.
Crispy pie crust filled with whipped marshmallow filling and topped with toffee, almonds, sesame bites, and a caramel drizzle.
Black Dog's signature sweet pickled garlic jalapenos. Available in a side cup or a pint.
A side cup of our very own house-made Ranch dressing.
A side cup of our house-made dragon's breath chili pepper spicy ranch dressing.
Our classic red sauce, available in a side cup or a pint.
A serving cup of our garlic butter--great for dipping pizza and knots!
Side cup of Mike's Original Hot Honey.
Grated parmesan cheese packets.
Crushed red pepper packets.
3x3 round glossy Black Dog Pizzeria logo sticker.
Sausage Stromboli is off the hook..... as are al zas. Love the cheery staff and owners Jessand Nick.
Columbus style veggie
Gluten free pizza with creamy Buffalo sauce and chicken. Delicious but could use extra sauce.
Angie's Rainbow Cookies
Cujo
Wall art
Outdoor Summer Seating
Outdoor Seating
Bottom of gluten free pizza .. cooked perfectly
bagels
Indoor Seating
$23 is too much for burnt pizza
interior, sushi and sashimi
Man's Pesto Friend
Gluten free pizza w/ creamy buffalo and chicken
Lego Black Dog Pizzeria
Atta Boy pizza
Garlic Knots
Labradoo-Dill Pizza
Fishdog Anchovie Pizza
interior, tacos
Larry Bird-Dog
Betsy T.
Jan 4, 2025
This is our favorite pizza in Columbus! The garlic knots are next level! We got two orders tonight! The service is always fantastic! Such a cute shop too!!
Read More
Micah T.
Feb 17, 2025
Got takeout so I'm unable to evaluate the bathroom, but I'm sure it's nice. This pizzeria caught my eye due to some dedicated foodies on the FB page and one of the owners sharing pictures of their delicious pies. I gotta say, I was not disappointed. The pizza has that classic crispy texture of NY style pizzas without being overly cracker-ish that I see in these more tavern style pies. I really liked the sauce and they were very generous with the peps. The price seems about average but that's a plus since I think the food has quality. The staff are lovely humans and even address by name at the counter. I really liked the ambiance Overall. Overall i'd give it a 3.8/5, Im excited to go back and try some of their other styles!!
Read More
Marie B.
Nov 12, 2024
What an absolutely underrated gem! I was looking for pizza in the Hilliard/Dublin area and saw Black Dog on the map. I had never heard of it but saw good reviews and the menu looked delicious so decided to go for it. Now I'm sad that I live on the other side of town away from it! I can't remember the name of the pizza we had but it was a white style pizza with onions. We also had garlic knots and Angie's rainbow cookies which were both delicious. I will definitely be ordering again and have recommended Black Dog to others!
Read More
Ben M.
Jan 5, 2025
I've had Black Dog now a few times. Typically have it delivered via a third party. It's a good price and ingredients seem to be high quality. My only knock is that it has been a bit inconsistent in my orders. Sometimes it's shown up perfect then other times it looks like it was just thrown together and shoved in an oven.
Read More
Danielle H.
Mar 28, 2024
The BEST pizza in Columbus. Absolutely love Black Dog. Could not be more thrilled that they are back open. I have several favorites but Atta Boy squeaks by as my #1, delicious. I like it New York style. You can not go wrong with any choice!Owners are super kind! Community involved. And always happy to answer pizza questions. If you delicious and fresh...this is your place.
Read More
Carla F.
Mar 9, 2024
I was sad to hear they were closed for 5 months due to a fire. Now that they are reopened, we decided to order some pizza for delivery. When ordering online, it will redirect you to the "Slice" app, which is relatively easy to use/place your order. It gives you an ETA but it's not 100% accurate. Our order ended up being delivered even though the app still said they were "prepping it". Even though it got delivered sooner than expected, the food was not hot when it got here, more like warm. We love their Cujo, NY style pizza. The flavors are great - pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms, topped with hot honey! I also decided to try their cheesy pesto sticks. I was a little disappointed when I didn't see a sauce since the menu stated it came with a side of pizza sauce. I'm not sure if they forgot to pack it in my order but my palate was really searching for it while I was eating the sticks. Without the sauce, the cheese sticks are good, with a mild pesto flavor, but they are very dry. They have a good crunch to them though!
Read More
Andrius S.
Nov 22, 2024
Passing through town from Chicago. Read the reviews and decided to give Black Dog a try. The staff was great! Warm welcome and made sure everyone waiting for an order was taken care of. I ordered the Ultimutt and a small house salad. The house salad was good size for a small, generous, and filled with fresh veggies, lettuce and pepperoni. It was delicious. The pizza was OUTSTANDING. One of the best I've ever had. It was loaded with fresh ingredients and the tomato sauce was awesome! If I'm ever back in the Dublin area, I will definitely be back!
Read More
Andrea Denning D.
Oct 22, 2024
Great food delivered! Priced right! Fresh salad and toppings a new favorite! Served hot!
Read More
Lakie F.
Nov 24, 2024
super yummy! the pesto cheese sticks are crazy- also that sauce is so so yummy. nice people and cute art!!
Read More
Al G.
Jan 25, 2025
We ordered for the first time tonight--a regular pepperoni pizza and the "Three Little Pugs." Our family of pizza lovers is delighted to have found our new favorite pizza in Dublin! I immediately texted all our friends and told them how great it is...can't wait to come back again.
Read More
