Bexley Pizza Plus

Ordered around 8:50 PM and was told they'd have it ready shortly but they close at 9PM as opposed to whats on Google/Yelp. I told them if it was too late to order it wasn't a problem but they assured me it wasn't and again they'd have it ready shortly. I was very happy with the service provided and the pizza itself was great and will definitely be ordering again in the future!

After returning to Bexley after 10 years, I had a yearning for pizza. This was my go to spot when I lived in Bexley. I called for delivery, smallest pizza with pepperoni, meatball and carmelized onions. I remembered to ask them to slice it like a pie and not in little squares. I also got a hot sub for my dinner the next day- Meatball parm. Both the pizza and the sub were soooo good. I'll be ordering from them often.

Had an amazing experience at Bexley Pizza Plus, tonight. Ordered a meatball sub, over the phone, easy, friendly service. Picked up in about 10 mins on a Saturday evening. Food was spectacular, portion was large, sauce was so good. Pizza is good but don't sleep on the subs!

Small pizza shop with a wide array of toppings. We enjoyed the cheesy garlic bread, sausage and pineapple pizza, plus a chicken florentine. Having the variety of flavors worked well. I'm glad i decided to stop here on my pizza trail!

Came here around 8 to find they were already closing the inside and only serving take out. I was excited to try some Columbus style pizza so I happily took my order to go. Got and 8" pizza and a salad. Pizza was delicous, would highly recommend, the crust is the perfect crispy thin and the toppings were plenty. I'd pass on their salads. The salad itself didn't match the menu description, it was missing a lot of ingredients and the salad dressing wasn't very good.

Thicker crust than most "Columbus Style" places.Good pizza, super friendly staff. Good stop on the Columbus pizza trail. Got the kids the basic cheese (Not the 6 cheese), they loved it

Plus: Hot, fresh, with very minimal grease. For a thicker style crust, it is very light (almost too light, lacks some needed density) & crisp. The ingredients are fresh & the toppings were an adequate quantity (they don't skimp nor do they overload it). Closer to 4 stars then 2.Minus: Nothing special to write home about or leave you dreaming of your next visit. While fresh, the sauce is in need of that signature touch that most popular pizza joints stand on, I struggled to find any real flavor separation. The cheese was also low on the flavor meter. Overall an above average, decent, hot & fresh pizza that is definitely worth trying, but it wont make any "top 3 lists" in my opinion.Service: Fast & friendly. Both the dining room & bathroom were clean.

I LOVE pizza and try to get to as many different places as I can! I drove out to Bexley to give this pizza joint a try. It did not dissapoint! I just gota small pepperoni pie and I loved it. It Putney in the mind of the pizza you get at a fair, but even better. Good in its own unique way. Can't wait to go back.

A Bexley original and always a great lunch. Pizza and sandwiches always delivered with a smile. Seems that most people do carry out but decent dining room. Service is no frills but hospitable.

Today went for lunch. I ordered the 8" one topping pizza with a beverage for $5.50. The pizza was ready when I got there, although I was probably 3minutes late. The taste was good and there was ample amount of the one topping.