Antolino's Pizza
Antolino's Pizza
a half eaten pizza in a box
a half eaten pizza
Exterior entry 7/2022 #UpCloseSavor
Drive thru pick up window 7/2022 #UpCloseSavor
Front entry and some dining. 7/2022 #UpCloseSavor
a burnt piece of pizza
Entrance
I guess this qualifies as patio dining. 7/2022 #UpCloseSavor
Specials
Lobby area before planned dining room expansion. 7/2022 #UpCloseSavor
Menu
interior, burritos and wraps
Lots of grease soaked into the pizza box under the crust
interior
Founders favorite - we asked for it to be cut pie shaped.
Burnt pizza- over cooked, dry & flavorless
Cannolis
interior
Founder's Favorite Pizza
Founders Founder's Favorite Pizza
pizza, food
pizza, food
sushi and sashimi, interior
Laura F.
May 1, 2024
Update: (Order from here you will love it!) Two weeks ago we discovered this place. I left a favorable review. I am not joking or exaggerating.... I have been craving this pizza ever since. Tonight almost 14 days later we got the founders choice (pep, sausage, mushroom) on their regular crust. It was even better than before. You know how you try something and love it, rush back have it again and find it meh... that is not the case here. It was delicious. To me, I dont think there is a better pizza anywhere near New Albany (sorry, sextons, this is way better) We ordered it from the center of downtown town New Albany and it was almost ready for pick up by the time we got there. Oh, tip: and ask for it to be cut pie shaped. The crust here is excellent for pie shaped slices. Yum
Read More
Ron F.
Apr 30, 2024
Stopped in as we make our way thru the CBus Pizza trail and discovered a great CBus style pizza. We ordered the Founded Favorite and enjoyed the combination of sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, and fresh mushrooms. It was delicious.Service was very good. Staff and owner were very personable. We enjoyed our dinner time conversation as we ate at the counter. There are also a few tables and other areas where you can relax.Stop in and give them a try. You may find a new pizza spot you add to your rotation.
Read More
Patrick M.
Jun 27, 2023
3 stroms, a sub, two cannolis and a great time.Fantastic food, truly great experience. We'll be back for sure!
Read More
Andre C.
Mar 5, 2024
Awesome pizza and subs! I just hope that they are thriving in their newer, tucked away location
Read More
Lisa M.
Dec 10, 2023
We love pizza and we found this place at an event that hosted 10 pizza places. And this was one of the ones we sampled. And we had no idea it was so close to home. I personally love the crust and toppings I can say I'm a pizza snob. So if you like pizza give Antolino's a try!! You will thank me later. At least I thought it was amazing!!
Read More
Daniel P.
Dec 19, 2024
This was my third time there. I guess I am working my way through the menu The spaghetti and meatballs was made with handmade pasta; it was wonderful. The first time we had the Founder's pizza And second time their Italian sub. Wonderful people serving great food.
Read More
Al M.
Nov 4, 2024
Had their pant based special pizza. Fantastic! Pizza has amazing flavors and is vegan! Other pizzas were great also.
Read More
Monica D.
Jan 20, 2025
It's delicious & the service is great! So happy to have this awesome pizza place in Gahanna! Thank you.
Read More
Debby A.
Nov 8, 2024
This is our go to pizza! It is the most delicious pizza and they never fail to deliver a piping hot pizza. We always order the medium Special Deluxe pizza with the Quart salad. We always ordered from the big local pizza chain in New Albany and it was always hit or miss. Cold or skimpy deluxe pizza and their salad was consistently bad as the lettuce was always brown and old and so bad I had to remove a good portion of lettuce and use my own. Not so with Antolinos salad, it's always fresh and perfect for two people with plenty of cheese, pepperoni, tomatoes, banana peppers. We order at least every week or every other week. Do yourself a favor and get your pizza here. I want to try their subs but their pizza is soooo good, I order it every time. Thanks for serving up such a great pizza and salad everytime. Love the drive thru pick up window. Happy to support our local pizza restaurant..
Read More
Justin H.
Sep 7, 2024
Restaurant reached out and explained what happened. Fully refunded me and I'm satisfied with the outcome.
Read More
