Supreme
food, pizza
Cheese pizza slice
Pepperoni and sausage
Slice
Large pepperoni and green pepper pizza.
Forgot to take a photo before digging in. White pie with spinach, tomato, and bacon. Incredible!!!
pepperoni and sausage
pepperoni and mushroom
a pizza with pepperoni and onions
Burnt pizza.
Karen M.
Dec 1, 2024
Really friendly service here! Walk through the food court and head upstairs to find another bar and Upstate Pizzeria.You can order slices or from their full menu. We opted to order a freshly-made pie and the large was huge! The three of us could barely make a dent in it. We also enjoyed a house salad that was also generous enough for the 3 of us to enjoy.Note: the bar is a separate entity from the restaurant. Not an issue, just know that you're buying from different providers. I thought the pizza was good: nice flavor to the sauce and fresh toppings; the crust is more dense than some I've had. It was out of the oven and on our table in less than 15 minutes! Definitely check it out if you're in the neighborhood and looking for a slice or a full pie.
Read MoreDave C.
Mar 7, 2024
Really good NY style slices in Colorado Springs, possibly the best of its pizza type. It's thin, has a little crunch, but is still foldable and the cheese to sauce ratio is just right. The people at the stall are also very nice, especially because you'll be back a couple times to get another slice. It's hard to go wrong with good pizza in a food hall, and this is a great spot when you need a NY pizza fix in the springs.
Read MoreLaura C.
Nov 15, 2024
This place is disgusting, we ordered through DoorDash and we got a burnt pizza when we called them they blamed DoorDash for their burnt pizza and told us to call them. DoorDash said they'd redeliver, of course they never did but claimed that they gave us another pizza. These people are nothing but trash and so is their food. See picture, it was a gorgeous burnt pizza.
Read MoreAlia A.
May 19, 2024
So yummy! I'm from upstate New York and it was pretty much spot on. We will be returning to this place for our pizza while living in Colorado Springs. Two slice special with a drink for ~$10.50 not NY prices but still worth it to me to return. The cashier was really nice and the service was pretty quick. Also the restaurant itself is located in Avenue Nineteen which also contains other restaurants, a bar and plenty of seating - tables and more casual seating like oversized couches and chairs. We went for lunch but would love to come back in the afternoon / evening as I feel it would be a great spot to grab a few drinks and a slice of pizza.
Read MoreBailey L.
Apr 27, 2024
This is our third time ordering delivery from here and they never disappoint! We decided to try the white pie this time and I am so glad we did! I like it better than the traditional one, but both are delish! Our go to spot for NY style pizza in the springs!
Read MoreGus S.
Jul 26, 2024
I'm from NJ and I was expecting typical NYC style pizza. It's not what we got, I guess upstate NY pizza is different than NYC pizza. But with that being said the pizza was excellent!!!! Quality ingredients and flavor. Worth it if you want to try something new. Would 100% order from them again.
Read MoreAlec J.
Nov 21, 2024
Food was awful. Service nonexistent. Ambiance... uhhh there was a basketball game in that's cool.
Read MoreCurtis L.
Sep 23, 2024
Great pizza! The staff is great and the upstairs location is unique. I will recommend this restaurant / bar!
Read MorePenny H.
Aug 8, 2024
Great food and great service. Loved it! The slice of pizza was huge so more then enough for me.
Read MoreJohn G.
Dec 23, 2024
Really chill and lowkey place with nice and friendly service. I purchased a 2 slice lunch special, but the slices were pretty burnt. Judging by the pictures and reviews, you'd probably have more luck getting a good slice if you order an entire pie for dine-in.
Read More