The Ice Cream Mill

100% recommend.I'm personally not an ice cream lover but if you want something to hit the spot, get the pioneer sundae. It's very family friendly, I love the atmosphere! It's so fun! Definitely a nice place to go for a couple after a date or something.They were also accommodating as well as I'm not a fan of root beer, I prefer Coke and vanilla ice cream and they were able to serve it!

Came here on a cold night looking for a sweet treat! We came here because they advertised dairy free ice cream, we have a friend who can't have dairy. It was disappointing that they only have 1 ice cream that is dairy free, strawberry. I hope they can add more in the future. I ordered the black cherry and I loved how it has real cherry bites! It was very creamy and rich in flavor. The waffle cones were perfect, crunchy and sweet. Very enjoyable, the 1 scoop was just the right amount.Walking in feels like playing the Oregon trail game. Very Midwest late 1800 vibes. Not a lot of seating, not recommended for groups larger than 4. Overall the ice cream was good and they have some unique flavors but I wouldn't go out of my way to come back.

New local ice cream place in town. When you walk in you immediately see the cute decor. It's very obvious someone took time to make the inside welcome and warming.They have a very large selection of novelties to choose from with great prices. Everything is Al preservative free and made in house. The berry jam ice cream was wonderful as was the banana split. Only thing that could have been better was the orange sherbet. Unfortunately it had no flavor of orange but tasted more like a mix of graham crackers and vanilla. Everything else was wonderful along with the service and environment.

Just recently heard about Ice Cream Mill & really wanted to try a local shop. We stopped in on a Friday afternoon & were greeted immediately. We were advised of their flag of flavors & we began deciding on what we wanted. The shop decor is really awesome with a working mill wheel & rocking chairs. Such a cool place!!! Love their pre-packed pints deal!! We got one chocolate & one rocky road with 2 cones to go. They quickly got our order together & we're very polite! The ice cream was absolutely delightful with a custard type consistency. Rocky Road typically has almonds, but theirs seemed to have walnuts instead. I really enjoyed it!!! We've definitely found our new go to ice cream shop. In this case local definitely is preferable for not only quality & flavor, but the price was reasonable for the quality you're getting. Keep it up, we'll see you soon!!!

Great customer service , great ice cream and the inside is so cute . Fast service. Just a really amazing ice cream shop .

This place is awesome! Fun crew and cabin feel inside. They have cowboy themed specials on the wall when you come in. Very affordable! Probably the most affordable ice cream place in town. Be sure to grab a 2-pack cookie bag with your savings!!

Genuine place with great atmosphere and even better ice cream. Nathan and Maddy helped us, very respectful and attentive. The ice-cream mill has phenomenal hand rolled waffle cones and in house ice cream. Cannot beat this place.

This place is great. Very welcoming and friendly staff! The ice cream is homemade in the back and it is very creamy and outstanding!

Loved the ice cream and the prices were very reasonable. Staff was helpful and stor was clean.

I love this ice cream place! The hand made cones actually taste delicious. I don't normally order them but these are yummy! The ice cream is creamy and delicious. Lots of flavors so everyone can get what they want which is nice. Super affordable too.