The cake we wanted
a guitar cake
The cake we wanted
the united states marine corps emblem
a bottle of champagne
Almond flavor 6 inch round cake with raspberry filling SO tasty and came out looking awesome
a heart shaped cake
Happy Birthday Julie!!!
Fabulous Cake!!!
What I got!
Cake
Almond cake with strawberry filling and ballerina pink buttercream
Fruit tart made specially with no blackberries delicious
Birthday Cake! seriously the most beautiful, best tasting cake I've had in my 33 years!
even had glitter!
food
The cake we got
This was the small round cake we requested for our wedding, which was in September and was "Aspen" tree themed. It came out perfect!!!
Frosting fight!
Nom
My wedding cake and 3 dozen cupcakes
interior
Amazing baby shower cake! Lemon cake with strawberry between the layers. Was so beautiful!
Ed S.
Dec 22, 2024
Wonderful customer service and cupcakes were decorated beautifully! Sugar cookie was cute, but just above average for flavor - this will not hinder my patronage.
Read More
DeShawn A.
Oct 7, 2023
Let's start with the service!!!! A+++ I contacted Sugarplum explaining that I was coming into town and needed a cake for my friends surprise birthday! They told me yo email a picture of what I was going for. They promptly responded with a yes they can create the cake and pricing!! This cake was far better than what I could've imagined and it tasted even better!!! Ashley snd entire staff was absolutely incredible! Thank you for making the most beautiful cake and making my friends birthday celebration special!!!
Read More
Chelsea N.
Mar 1, 2024
I had to place a last minute order due to miscommunication but they handled it like pros and exceeded my expectations. Couldn't be happier with my sisters birthday cake. I will be a returning customer
Read More
Sarah W.
Jan 9, 2024
Ordered a fruit tart with no blackberries, and an almond cake with raspberry filling for a 30th birthday! Both tasted great, told them the b day boy did not like cake too much because it is normally too sweet. They made a great recommendation with the almond flavor. He loved it! 10/10 would order a cake from them again, and the grave on the cake was so cute!!
Read More
Shailla A.
Aug 26, 2023
I order a graduation cake, it was beautiful! The whole experience from placing the order to pickup was flawless, and very reasonable prices.
Read More
Heather J.
Jul 27, 2023
amazing birthday cake with great flavor! We had the chocolate with chocolate pudding filling - delicious and beautiful!
Read More
JM S.
Jun 26, 2024
Amazing experience with this cake shop. The process for building a custom wedding cake was very collaborative where the end product looked stunning & everything we had hoped for. During the tasting, we had asked for a custom frosting that was not on their standard list (strawberry balsamic) and they did not hesitate even for a second to honor this request-- you know they are passionate about their work when you can see their brain tinkering with excitement on how to make this custom flavor work-- their energy was infectious.Above all, both flavors were AMAZING (champagne cake with strawberry balsamic + chocolate with cream cheese frosting & chocolate ganache) to the point that the cake is a core taste memory that makes me salivate anytime I think about it. All the cake was gone as the guests loved it so much.
Read More
Livia D.
Jul 14, 2024
I talked with Veronica over email about the cake. I had wanted to have it have nature decorations like leaves and flowers, but I couldn't afford to pay $30 extra for it on top of $60 for the cake. So I said I'd do without decorating, and they said they'd do a simple border.Flash forward, I picked up the cake and they had put leaves on it for me with no extra charge!! I was so happy, and so was my partner who the cake was for. They loved the cake so much! As someone who is a cake connoisseur, they said they'd only had a cake this amazing one other time in a bakery in their hometown in Chicago. They said it was perfect!!! We are both so happy with it!! Thank you!! 10/10 recommend.
Read More
Suzannah O.
Oct 5, 2024
We ordered our wedding cake and dessert selection for our wedding from this bakery. Everything is delicious, I was truly blown away. They also went above and beyond when it comes to customer service! I will be in town for Christmas and am hoping to pick up some treats to share with family over the holidays!
Read More
Jeremiah J.
Aug 29, 2024
Our experience with the Sugarplum Bakery for our wedding was amazing! The cake turned out beautiful and so unique - and also tasted amazing! From our initial tasting appointment all the way to cake cutting on our wedding day, Amanda and team were so helpful and a joy to work with. Highly recommend!
Read More