The Godfather
a hand holding a piece of pizza
Avery beer
Grab a seat
The Gobbler
Outside- sign
Outside - street view
Outside- back patio
All the food
View from back patio
How it works
Menu board
Outside side yard
Half of my Godfather. Delicious.
The Rancher on Parmesan brea with extra meat and bacon
Club salad
The Pickle Club
a neon sign for a restaurant
Cherie G.
Sep 24, 2024
Great sandwich/salad/pizza stop--sodas in cans and Avery beer on tap. Lots of outside seating. Your order at the bar but food is delivered to your table. We had sandwiches--both were large, well made and tasty. It's a great option for a casual lunch stop.
Read MoreJeffry L.
Jul 29, 2024
Might be the best sandwich ive ever had. Yelp only allows 1-5 stars. This place deserves 69 starsFood came so quick I feel like the server read my mind. I ate my sandwich (the godfather) and half my kids pizza. Great drink as well. If you are driving through town, you must stop here. You won't regret it
Read MoreJay B.
Aug 8, 2024
We had the The Gobbler, the God Father, and the Rancher. All were great- fresh and tasty. Their ordering system is clear and simple: pick one of their base sandwiches then fill out a slip to customize your creation. You get a 1/4 pickle with your sandwich - something to consider since the pickle side order is a full size gurken. We are on their back patio which had a nice view. Definitely worth the stop,
Read MoreEileen K.
Jul 11, 2024
Great stop! Sandwiches yummy and variety of beverages. Funky pub feel with really friendly staff. We will stop here again.
Read MoreKaylee K.
Aug 18, 2024
Definitely make a stop here, fun ambiance, great service from Colin and co, great sandwiches. Thank you!
Read MoreJ H.
May 30, 2024
These guys are killing it. Feels like they have been serving up great sandwiches for years here. We've tried many of the sandwiches and pizza - they're awesome. Have yet to try a salad but they look good. The outdoor area is nice to sit with your pup if you are so inclined. The indoor area and bar setting is just what you expect from a pub. Poncha Springs needed this.
Read MoreKimberly S.
May 20, 2024
Gluten-free options. Professional staff.. Good food. Nice environment. Additional outdoor seating.
Read MoreHailey K.
Jan 26, 2024
best sandwich ive ever tasted! you will love it too i promise!it's so so so so good! also i love pickles(Written by my 9yr old )
Read MoreKyra H.
Apr 7, 2024
Not bad for a sandwich in bumble. Nice people and good indoor/outdoor space. Would go back.
Read MoreChiyoko Y.
Mar 1, 2025
Perfect toasted sandwich and beautifully loaded pizza! Price was reasonable for the quality of ingredients. We will be back!
Read More