Joey's NY Pizza

We're so sad. We've been coming for years and love the pizza here. You've changed to tiny little pepperoni and it's totally changed the taste of the pizza now. Unfortunately we won't be back. The service was good though. Clean business.

Great classic NY style pizza. The wings are great. Go in and get a slice for lunch. I love the pizza by the slice!! Crispy!

My daughters and I were hungry for Pizza. We just finished visiting Garden of the gods. We quickly scanned the area for a pizza joint and saw "NY pizza here" sign. We double checked Yelp app for the reviews of Joey's and we saw that it has great reviews. We ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza, house salad, drinks and took advantage of the 1/2 dozen free garlic knots coupon. The service was excellent! The pizza was delicious and yes tastes just like New York Pizza. I would definitely come back here.

I ordered for the first time to try it out. Pizza was burnt and very salty my kids would not even eat the toppings pulled off the pizza because of all the salt, and I have never seen them turn down a pizza even a frozen one. The garlic knots were burned on bottom and raw in the middle. Will not order from them again. I do not recommend. A frozen cheap store pizza would be better.

The pizza is sooo good here! I've had pepperoni sausage red onion, pineapple, and a pepperoni mushroom red onion. Each one I've had has been very tasty. If you like pizza you can fold in 1/2 and eat this pizzas for you! What's nice is it's foldable without being soggy which is tough to do but they do it! Their toppings are always cooked perfectly. I highly recommend this restaurant!

Tasteless. No sauce. i'm serious absolutely no flavor of any kind of Italian seasoning or cheese or garlic. Had to wait an extra 25 minutes for delivery when it was supposed to be ready for pick up. There are disappointing. I won't be ordering from here again. It was the best pizza around. Tip and $40 for supreme with meatballs...scraps of hamburger but no meatballs or flavor of meatballs. at least it wasn't salty like it was last time as was there Templeton gap location. Thought I would give it another try.Total rip, off I would not recommend.

Do we really need to request peppers and parmigiana? You're having DoorDash deliver which makes a $30 pizza cost $50. Throw some crushed peppers and Parmesan into the box. It's really not difficult to make people happy until you're lazy and piss them off.

Warm, flavorless, undercooked cardboard. Just so bad. Just so so bad. What's wrong with this city?

Amazing pizza! We've been looking for a great pizza since moving here and we finally found it. Pizza has great crust and the sauce is perfectly balanced. Owner is super friendly and always ask for feedback. Fast service and friendly people.

My first order I had placed was a calzone and it was delicious! I decided to get a pizza this time and it was awful. It was cold and there were hardly any toppings on it. Both orders were delivery & the first one it was hot when delivered.