The Yummiest Custom Cakes in Colorado Springs

Spiced Jasmine

★★★★★ 5 (6)

"I called Haleema less than 2 days ago to arrange a cake and cupcake delivery for my son's birthday today. She was quick to respond, lovely to work with and had goodies delivered to his door by noon today. Customer service like this is a gift. Thank you so much for helping to make his day special when we can't celebrate together!"

The Cake Company

★★★★☆ 4.3 (39)

"Best cupcakes I've had. They're light, not too sweet and delicious. Customer service is top notch. I'll be returning for a sweet treat or celebration."

Just My Imagination Twin Pastries

★★★★★ 5 (1)

"Awesomeness!!!!!Ordered the sweet potato cheesecake with praline sauce and "Oh my" it was the "Best" cheesecake ever, better than any restaurant cheesecake I have ever tasted. I highly recommend ordering from here. Melissa was very friendly and made it worth the money. Can't wait to try other desserts they make. Definitely recommend this place for your next dessert craving or for a party."

Petite Gateaux

★★★★☆ 4 (7)

"I called to order a German chocolate cake for my husbands birthday. Ordering was easy and I opted to pay at pickup. Finding the location was a bit trickery (the signs outside are faded) but once I got in there, the bakery was gorgeous! They had an array of different cakes and pastries. My cake was ready on time and was gorgeous and delicious. $50 and fed easily 8-10 people. Can't wait to order our next cake from here!"

Panaderia Tlaquepaque

★★★★★ 4.8 (25) • $

"This place is a hidden gem. They have the best pastries, breads and desserts. So many options are available. The cost is low. The people that work there are friendly. Please note, this is a place to pick up and go. No place to sit. Place is also clean and organized."

Little London Cake Shoppe

★★★★☆ 3.5 (70) • $$$

"I was so happy that Little London could make a cake for my son's 1st birthday which falls during that awkward time between Christmas and New Years Day when a lot of small businesses seem to be closed. We ordered a month in advance, sent a photo, followed up with an email about a week before the event out of paranoia. The cake was ready on time and looked exactly like the photo. It was bright and vibrant and perfect for a kid birthday. I have no concept of cake pricing but I'm sure this took a bit of work--plus it was heavy and huge. So to me, the price was very expensive but justified. People raves over the impressive look of the cake and also the flavor. Everyone wanted the strawberry cake layer. I don't imagine a need for a big scale custom cake like this again but I wouldn't hesitate to use and recommend them even for smaller projects."

Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

★★★★☆ 4.3 (279) • $$

"The true European pastry shop, the eclairs and napoleon are AMAZING!!! Don't get me started on the bread, omg it's to die for. The staff...the poor girl looked upset but other than that the baked goods are phenomenal!"

Sweet Nothings Catering

★★★★★ 5 (4)

"Ordered my son a baby shark smash cake and cake to eat for his first birthday. I also ordered "1" shaped cookies with his name and macaroons that were shaped as clam shells to match! Everyone complemented the deserts. Asked for the cake to be red velvet inside and it was delicious!"

Cakes by Karen

★★★★☆ 3.6 (97) • $$

"OMG! You haven't had cookies until you've had these. I got these at work ones, and I am constantly dreaming about the next time I can have more. These cookies melted in your mouth with sugary goodness, and it is dangerous how easily I can consume them. These cookies are so good, our entire organization has a deal to order them in bulk. While I have never been inside one, I've seen them in strip malls on Colfax and Colorado, which may be the only downfall. I imagine traffic may delay you getting these cookies, but they are worth any wait."

Astonishing Cakes

★★★★★ 4.6 (13) • $$

"Astonishing Cakes is as their name describes -- astonishing! Renee created a unique + stunning James Bond cake for a rad styled bridal shoot we collaborated on. Her attention to detail was incredible, and I was blown away when I saw her amazing creation. She also crafted cake pops + caketinis, which are perfect for any wedding or event. They were delicious + rich. Can't wait to work with her again!"

Robin's Cupcakes

★★★★★ 4.8 (5)

"These are the absolute best cupcakes you will ever eat! The owner, Blythe is very easy to work with, her prices are fantastic and her cupcakes will disappear before your eyes. It is an easy and affordable way to surprise friends, treat your co-workers or bring to a party! She offers a wide variety of flavors, even a protein version. Robin's cupcakes are a sure thing! Try it, you'll be glad you did."

Cheesecake Haven

★★★★★ 5 (3)

"Every year my family orders juniors cheesecake from NY and ever since we have been enjoying cheesecake haven, we swear it's just as good! The presentation is as beautiful as it gets and the rotating flavors are all incredible!"

Divinity Sweet Shop

★★★★★ 4.5 (12)

"I called on a Saturday afternoon and they were able to deliver my cupcakes a few hours later. I even received a text when my cupcakes were on the way. Customer service was great. I ordered red velvet cupcakes and chocolate cupcakes. I could tell that both cupcakes had recently been baked as the cake was warm in the middle. They used butter cream icing and it was really thick. Needed more cake for the amount of icing. I would also recommend using a different container for the cupcakes. It was hard to get them out with the holders being shallow. Maybe something that sits up higher. I'd purchase again."

The Sugarplum Cake Shoppe

★★★★☆ 4.4 (101) • $$

"Ordered a fruit tart with no blackberries, and an almond cake with raspberry filling for a 30th birthday! Both tasted great, told them the b day boy did not like cake too much because it is normally too sweet. They made a great recommendation with the almond flavor. He loved it! 10/10 would order a cake from them again, and the grave on the cake was so cute!!"

Custom Cakes By Chelsea

★★★★★ 4.8 (4) • $

"I've not sampled the goods here yet, but appreciated the prompt return call from Chelsea to give me a quote on a custom cupcake order."

Sugar Rush Cakery

★★★★★ 4.8 (9) • $$

"Here's the thing. Reviews can be cheap. Rah, rah, rah - this place is great. No, that's not my vibe. I only leave reviews for places that deserve to be reviewed and let me just tell you - THIS PLACE DESERVES ALL FIVE STARS.I ordered the Thanksgiving cookie kit. A family of cooks and bakers were FAWNING over these cookies. Jodie figured out how to make Christmas cookies taste better than Danish butter cookies. Slightly soft in the middle, bursting with flavor, and guess what? The adults ate them just as much as the kids!And, no, I did not store the leftovers in a secret hiding spot in my kitchen so no one could find them. I totally didn't do that. I totally didn't eat them all myself in the subsequent days. Noooo, not me. ;)Trust me - buy the cookies. Your mouth (and family) will thank you!P.S. We didn't take photos of the cookies, because people ate them so fast! So, here's a photo of our family from that day, for good measure."

Bird Bakery

★★★★☆ 3.9 (95)

"The food here is really good! I had an avocado breakfast sandwich that was excellent, with a cappuccino that was also very good! The restraint is very cozy, but the chairs are super uncomfortable and need to be replaced ASAP! It's a new restaurant, so I've ran into some issues where an employee tells me these things already come in my breakfast sandwich, but they don't, so I have to send it back so they can add it... I'm just going to ask them to humor me and put it on there for the kitchen anyway hahaThis place is also great when Pancake House is packed or is "missing" your reservation haha..."

Iced and Dazzle

★★★★★ 5 (4)

"Linda did an incredible nightmare before Christmas cake for my sisters baby shower in ! It came out 100% just how I wanted it to look, I am still getting compliments on how great the cake came out! Thank you Linda for making the day so special! The cake really pulled it all together!"

BiteIt! Bakery

★★★★★ 5 (1)

"Planning a party & in need of a delicious cake and desserts? Look no further than BiteIt! Bakery! Helmed by the talented Polina Astafyeva (a seasoned Cake Artist with a passion for all things sweet), BiteIt! creates cakes & desserts that are as beautiful as they are delicious.From the moment I contacted Polina, I knew I was in good hands. She made the entire process, from discussing my vision for the cake & desserts, to picking up the final masterpieces (delivery is also available), so easy. For my sister's baby shower, I had a spring floral theme in mind. Polina listened attentively and translated my vision into a delectable reality. The cake was not only stunning, it was a crowd-pleaser. We had the 'Letter Cake' made with honey biscuits, white chocolate ganache, & berry confit (this is BiteIt!'s most popular flavor, and we can see why). The honey biscuit cake was soft with a crumbly texture (comparable to shortbread cookies, but with a subtle sweetness and floral hint from the honey). The white chocolate ganache had a smooth, sweet, and milky chocolate flavor. The berry confit was a refreshing and tart jam that added a fruity burst to each bite of the cake.Polina also baked up macaron boxes as party favors for each guest - raspberry & mango-lemon (both heavenly, the raspberry was my favorite). This was such a fun way to leave everyone with treats to take home.BiteIt! Bakery made our celebration so much sweeter & I can't wait to order from Polina again in the future!"

Margaret's Munchies

★★★★☆ 4.3 (3)

"My boyfriend and I were staying in an eco-tiny house outside of the town Florissant, CO where there are a total of 3-4 restaurants. The people from the grocery store suggested getting dinner at the food truck in the museum parking lot rather than the other establishments in town. We enjoyed our dinner so much we decided that we would get breakfast there on the way out of town. I was surprised I didn't find any reviews, so I thought I should write one. I did find this page for Margaret's Munchies, where you might otherwise have no idea that you can get breakfast and lunch, sandwiches and burritos. While other meats are offered, yak is their specialty.I'm not sure I've tried yak before but per Google, here are some of the benefits: "Yak meat is a healthy, lean protein that is lower in cholesterol and saturated fat than beef. It is also a more environmentally friendly option, since yaks require significantly less land and water than cattle. Ground yak meat is a versatile ingredient, and perfect for making burgers, tacos, meatballs, and more!"We each had the Yak steak sandwich with peppers and onions. Me being a former New Mexican, couldn't say no to a cup of the fresh green chile stew after asking about putting some on my sandwich. I'm very particular about French fries when I eat them; these were steak cut and had an amazing flavor. The next day, boyfriend got a breakfast sandwich on a hoagie roll and I got the breakfast burrito. I really appreciated the organic ingredients and that we could decide how much salt is appropriate.Margaret and the other folks operating the food truck were very gracious and nice to chat with. I learned that they've been around for about five years, and that Margaret is a baker by trade and later broke into the food-truck and catering business.Except when they are busy with catering and events, they said they are the only establishment in the are that has a fixed schedule. Soon, they will be expanding their operation into a building with full kitchen/dining area. This is amazing food made by amazing people, and I wish them all the best as their business expands!"

Posh Cakes

★★★★☆ 3.9 (169) • $$

"Ordered apple pie, cinnamon rolls and birthday cake online (all gluten free) Monday to pick up after our flight landed Wednesday so we'd have easy Thanksgiving/birthday treats. Oh my goodness! The staff had our boxes ready with a huge smile, and even though we didn't eat them until the next day, they were amazing! We loved all it. And no gluten reactions at all! We'd order them again for sure!"

Whisk N Pin

★★★★★ 5 (7)

"If I have anymore events I am booking with Amanda! She was SO easy to work with and went above and beyond! She was very professional and so helpful in coming up with the design. I have her some inspirational photos and she came up with it all! The cake was not only beautiful but so delicious! The flavor was marble with ganache and chocolate buttercream. My friends cake was lemon and blueberry. They were a hit! Not to mention everyone loved the design! Her husband came with her to help deliver, and they were on time. Which is always a plus. The price was awesome for a 3 tiered cake! I will post pictures, but it does not do these cakes justice!"

Katherine's French Bakery and Cafe

★★★★☆ 3.6 (212) • $$

"What a great day to sit in the patio at Katherine's. If there wasn't so much noise that's coming from University, this would be a perfect spot to feel like dining in a cafe in Paris. The background music at the right volume soothed me.I met up with a friend of mine at this place for a brunch at 10:30am on a Saturday. From the past experience, I knew it might be hard to grab a table during the peak time in the morning especially on a Saturday. I needn't worry; there were a good number of tables available inside and outside.This place has everything: from benedicts to crepes to quiches to French toasts to fruit cups to salads, I mean you name it. Out of so many items on the menu, my friend and I went with crepes.I went with Boulder (crepe). It's got sauteed mushrooms, caramelized onions, spinach, haystack goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes. I asked for an addition of one-egg scrambled. My friend went with Breakfast (crepe) (bacon, egg and cheese) with avocado addition. Just so you know, they have both savory and sweet crepes.My crepe was amazingly good; A little tanginess that comes from the sun-dried tomatoes did the magic by adding a great flavor to the entire dish. And both hers and mine crepes were a good size (we couldn't finish it so we asked for boxes.)Now, this place got busy after 11:30am. It took such a long time before our waitress got us the boxes and the bill (because she was busting her bottom.) We were very understanding of it; it appeared a little short-staffed and fortunately, we had time.We, of course, stopped by at the display of cakes and pastries to look at before walking away from the restaurant. Everything looked amazing but I went with the lemon tart. My friend got her a chocolate croissant. There was a huge display of Eiffel Tower built with Lego pieces (which had a sign that said "Do not touch"); I took a picture of it. Cookies that are shaped like Eiffel Tower were very cute."

Baked in Breck

★★★★★ 5 (3)

"I've been buying these cupcakes since the owner opened up the business. They're bomb. Not a big a sweet tooth but these are perfect! Love that the flavors are always changing. Recommend checking this place out if you're in Breckenridge. Great for little ones and just as an overall treat!"

Alpine Pastries

★★★★☆ 4.2 (52) • $

"Me and my lovely girlfriend, had a wonderful time at this donut shop/bakery. Got a donut a a history lesson with us. Then he recommended the store next to us. That offer gooder coffee."

Little Bears Bakery

★★☆☆☆ 1.6 (5)

"My husband ordered me a "sugar free" birthday cake, the reason why the cake does not display happy birthday because this place did not have "sugar free icing" This cake still was delicious, and it would've been better with fresh strawberries inside. $30 My husband could've gotten a half sheet for 20 at Safeway; but it's always the thought that counts!"

Sugar Buzz Cakery

★★★★☆ 4 (4)

"Great cake, very moist and the decoration was amazing! Thanks, you made our event special."

The Makery Cake Company

★★★★☆ 4 (96) • $$

"I ordered a custom cake for my son's first birthday. It came with a complimentary smash cake. He liked it very much. (We liked our cake too)"