a plate of pastries on a table
Thinly sliced dried beef with cheese and a light coating of lemon on top. Yummy
a group of people gathered outside a house
two bottles of wine and a cork
two bottles of wine and a notebook
a collage of images of farm animals
hands holding a bunch of grapes
the outside of a house with a picnic table in front of it
ribs, food, bbq ribs
food
food
food, bagels
outside
3 huge meatballs with red sauce!
crepes, food
drink
steak, food
food
dough desserts, donuts, food
outside
Sausage
Focaccia Genovese
Frank D.
Apr 27, 2024
Owner is awesome, great food and service, pizza was great and non traditional. Will be back again!!!!
Read More
Linda M.
Dec 14, 2023
Food was delicious! The outdoor setting was so fun. Perfect for a spring or summer outdoor dinner. Will definitely go again!
Read More
RJ M.
Apr 15, 2021
In an area loaded with good pizza options, Yosteria stands alone.Our family has tried virtually every item on their menu and all are excellent. The fried calzone is amazing.
Read More
Dennis C.
Oct 9, 2020
The pear pizza is so delicious. I have never had a peach pizza it sounded crazy but it was delicious. I would tell you to try the pear pizza you will be nicely surprised.
Read More
Peter W.
Feb 2, 2025
The good: The food is every bit as good as people told me it was. The attention to detail in every dish is so impressive. I won't tell you what to eat, just pick a few things and enjoy. The not so good: It's dark. Like, reeeeally dark. One half of the place is brightly lit, the other half is a bat cave. A modest proposal guys, a little light isn't going to hurt the ambiance. Noise. My word the noise. For about $30 you could have some pieces of cut plywood covered in a dark carpet sample and hang them on the walls. They would deaden the sound enough to make it tolerable. And because it's so dark nobody would even notice. The food is why you come here. The service is great, too. The ambiance is sh*t, but it's Youngstown and the ambiance pretty much everywhere is sh*t, so you might as well go to the place with the best food.
Read More
Karla C.
Feb 9, 2025
This was our first visit to Yosteria. We had a wonderful experience. The charm and character of the restaurant was remarkable. We ordered from recommendations of the owner and the dishes were amazing. This is definitely on our list of favorites. Looking forward to visiting when the weather warms up to enjoy the outdoor dining area.
Read More
David K.
Dec 29, 2024
Awesome!!!!! You'll be thrown off by location, exterior and the first room you walk into but don't worry! We sat in a quiet, dimly lit back room. There aren't many entree options. Prepare to share small plates with the table instead. We got 2 pizzas, focaccia bread, Gnudi and the meatballs. It was too much food for the 4 of us! Everything was delicious! Service was great which we needed since the menu is in Italian! We will definitely be back!!!
Read More
Elizabeth M.
Apr 3, 2024
Total gem! The food is outstanding, the atmosphere is incredible. The staff enhances the entire experience onto another level. An absolute must try and you will be hooked!
Read More
Zach C.
Apr 2, 2021
I'm not sure why Yosteria doesn't have 1000+ reviews all 5 star. This was my first time having their pizza. I contacted them early in the AM asking if he could have 12 half sheets ready by noon so I could offer lunch to my employees. Without hesitation he was on it! Walked in and they were done just on time. The service was awesome from the moment I walked in. I ordered all off the options he had available. Every single piece was perfection! The sauce is one of its kind in the Youngstown area. You will only have it at Yosteria. The fresh chunks of tomatoes almost made you feel like you were in Italy. Thanks again! You will be seeing me again!
Read More