Toft's on 250
Toft's on 250
Small Banana Split (6 scoops with toppings)
Back of Tofts.
Taco sundae = awesome. Friendly staff too.
Brownie bandit + lake Erie cookie monster
a hand holding an ice cream cone
a cup of ice cream
three cups of ice cream
Belgian Waffle
a cup of ice cream
Classy, modern interior
Super Duper Scoop
Holiday hours for December 2022
You'll have to get a peek at all three coolers to be able to pick a flavor (or 2, or 3)!
Our holiday special milkshakes 2022
T-shirts, sweatshirts, and hats are all available for purchase
Menu, Part 2
Menu, Part 3
food
Enjoy your ice cream in our bright, cheery dining room
We offer 40 flavors of ice cream in half-gallons containers
Sip a shake surrounded by beautiful local artwork
Order a custom ice cream cake with your favorite flavors
Menu, Part 1
Caramel Espresso Chip
James A. Y.
Oct 17, 2024
We had eight in our party and everyone enjoyed their ice cream. One person got a root beer float and the others a variety of ice cream. Prices our reasonable I felt for the inflation we have experienced the last few years. They have a kids cone which was still very big. Not on the menu, but some of us got a baby cone which was plenty of ice cream. Be careful not to order to big. It is alot of ice cream. The person working there was extremely pleasant and accommodating. She could not do enough for you. They also have a very nice little area to sit and eat. I highly recommend.
Read More
Mikala T. S.
Sep 16, 2022
This may be a smaller location, but it is still just as yummy! Been here several times, & the girls working are very sweet! We had the small banana split, & it was so big that we had leftovers for a couple days! The strawberry ice & topping was my favorite part! Tofts has the best ice cream!
Read More
Annmarie Q.
Jul 15, 2023
Wonderful local ice cream spot. Great service and delicious treats. Locals so friendly
Read More
Michael N.
Jul 7, 2023
Wow...fast and friendly service. The ice cream scoops were great sizes and were awesome.
Read More
Tracy W.
Jul 13, 2020
Stopped here after dinner one evening. Desert at the restaurant didn't sound good, some Tofts Ice Cream did. We took our son and fiancé. She's from Columbus and never had Tofts. Boy we were in for a treat. First order was a small waffle cone. WHOLY COW. 3 scoops is a HUGE small cone. We all had more then enough ice cream from a local company. Great job tofts. Keep it up.
Read More
Judy H.
Aug 10, 2024
Tofts is best ice cream around and I was born in Cleveland area!!! They give giant portions too!!
Read More
Nikolaij L.
Jun 14, 2024
Very bad service, and the ice cream was freezer burnt. They all were sitting around and taking a very long time to make everything and everyone's ice cream
Read More
Brad T.
Mar 6, 2024
Always a great stop after volleyball tournament for some team bonding. Workers are always friendly and helpful. Not much seating inside. Who really could pass on some tofts ice cream
Read More
David C.
Jun 24, 2023
Had banana split and single scoop of pralines and cream (can't remember exact name).Ice cream was very creamy and not super sweet. Portions were gigantic. The small banana split was too much for 2. And the single scoop could have easily fed 2 more. My wife made them stop putting on more ice cream.
Read More
Steven S.
Aug 3, 2023
Decent ice cream The ice cream had great flavor but a little bit icy. Prefer creamier consistency. Fantastic whipped cream though.
Read More
