The Forge

Food, service excellent. Nice ambiance. Yes, a LITTLE pricey, but the steaks were wonderful. The sides were good, and the crepes were nice enough. Can't expound on the crepes because it was our first time. Anyway, very good. Would probably come back.

This place was amazing! Food delicious!! Drinks were definitely not spared with the alcohol. We appreciate that kind of a pour! It was our first time and it's on our "do again" list for breakfast places.

We ate at the Forge 3 times in one weekend!! Dinner twice and then breakfast. It was amazing. Food, service, sat outside each time. Recommend 100% the Brussels sprouts, garlic fries, salads, bacon wrapped date. All were so very good! I only got a picture of my drink because the food went so fast!

What an awesome place to have breakfast. They utilized the space perfectly with front and side outdoor setting with two bars, one inside and one outside. Plenty of seating and the service was fantastic. Once order was placed, food came out quickly and was so delicious. So many options from crepes to breakfast burritos. Family friendly. Great friendly attentive service. Many vegan options. I got the bowl with vegan sausage. Can hold the eggs to make completely vegan.

Came here for breakfast, on a sailboat race. Food was great, service was superb... would recommend

Former employee here! This is the worst place I have ever worked for. The owners are holier-than-thou jerks who don't seem to care about their staff. They have cameras throughout the restaurant and sit at home watching them like a reality tv show. Several phone calls a day to the store to nit-pick. They force their employees to be on call multiple nights a week without pay and know that most of their employees have given everything up to be there so they'll take it. Colleen once told me "You are less than me. I am above you." That being said, the food is decent and so is the coffee but there are other places on the island that are more deserving of your money.

Food was great! I got the avocado toast!Drinks are good as well and strong ! Would recommend and come back here.

Amazing food, service, ambiance!!!! Love the unique and delicious menu, the super friendly and always smiling servers, and the coziness of the inviting and beautiful decor, always a great dining experience.

We come to Put In Bay once a year and always stop at the Forge. It is not cheap, but you will get what you pay for. The food and service are phenomenal. Abby was a great server.

If I could give the forge a six star rating, I would. We went there for Sunday brunch. Big Al took care of us. He was efficient, he was attentive, and the food was cooked to perfection. I also want to point out that unlike some of the other places I rated on Put in Bay, the quality to cost ratio was extremely high. Please see some photographs below. Parking right outside could be a problem so we used the parking lot across the street that has the general store and just purchased some things in the store that we needed.