people shopping in the store
In action!
Spring
a man preparing food
The Haystack
Mix of Fried & Baked Chicken from Harley's Smokehouse BBQ at The Amish Market
a customer's notice of the customer
a variety of items for sale
a man at the counter
people shopping in a grocery store
interior
outside
interior
interior
food
food
food
Outdoor summer sale fry pies!
Summer sale!
Outside eating always a plus!
Tender smoked pulled pork
COVID-19 UPDATE
Main entrance
Amanda K.
Sep 6, 2023
Stopped in the Amish Market to check it out. We had heard amazing things and were not disappointed. There are so much great things to check out and buy. We grabbed ourselves some donuts and Oh boy! THEY WERE DELICIOUS!!!! We plan to go back for more!
Read MoreKalah Rae F.
Aug 28, 2023
What a cool place!Every time I'm in Youngstown I try to visit this place.It's an indoor market with lots of different stalls around, and they have everything from fresh donuts and pies to handmade furniture.My local friends like to go there and buy the 'old' produce for their chickens at a discounted cost. I know they are always super satisfied with the quality.They also have premade foods like cold salads and sandwiches that you can grab for lunch.I would highly recommend a visit here if you're ever in the Youngstown area.
Read MoreAngelina G.
Oct 25, 2024
The Amish never disappoint! Best Pretzel Logs ever!!! Tried them first in Baltimore them again in Pennsylvania. You must try!
Read MoreRalph P.
Jun 29, 2024
The Restaurant has amazing food. Never disappointed when I go. The fresh donuts are out of this world. Apple fritters are my absolute favorite!
Read MoreKevin E.
Oct 18, 2024
This place is awesome. Has a really good donut shop, a good restaurant, a good pretzel shop, a furniture shop that makes really good quality furniture and so much more. The service there is also really good.
Read MoreKymberly M.
Aug 30, 2023
As soon as you walk in, you know the finds are going to be good! Donuts and pretzels made fresh in front of you. Fresh meats and veggies, flowers and deli. There's handmade furniture that's as beautiful as it is sturdy. You can even enjoy a home cooked meal in the cafe! Definitely go and visit. I guarantee you will find something you'll love. Teas, coffee, honey, candies... the staff are courteous and will answer all your questions about the products and goods they make. So glad I bought a few donuts and pies. Didn't have a favorite because they were all fresh and delicious. But I will say that the raspberry filled pies... heaven!
Read MoreLaurie V.
Aug 17, 2023
I hadn't been through Boardman in a long time, but this was a nice little find. I went in specifically to bring donuts home for my family and the Amish market was exactly what I was looking for. Don't let the line intimidate you- it moves pretty fast.
Read MoreJeanine A.
Mar 22, 2022
What a great place to pick up cheese and meats. We picked up some horseradish cream cheese and honestly, I've been putting it on everything ever since! When you first walk in, the smell of the donuts is intoxicating and really draws you in. Don't get stuck there! There is so much more to see and buy. Keep walking!
Read MoreKyla L.
Aug 26, 2023
The market is a treasure trove. The fish is a MUST try, the seasoning is so good. The donuts always smell like heaven, and the produce is fresh and crisp.
Read MoreLin B.
Jul 14, 2024
Make sure to go here when they are open Thursday-Saturday. Their baked goods are delicious & so is their produce. Haven't bought meat here but our neighbor did & he enjoyed it. Be sure to buy a soft pretzel or two on your way out. They are yummy & addicting. Clean & well maintained building.
Read More