Reel Bar

This place was awesome. Came here to see our friends from Key West play and we weren't disappointed in the food, the bartenders and the atmosphere.Very cool inside, clean and hip. If we come back to Put-In-Bay, this is a must stop.

Great guest service in a high ceiling, open bar setting with a small patio area. They have Vegan options with a couple menu alterations. I got the Sloppy Joe with a lettuce wrap and a side salad. My partner got the grouper sandwich which they loved!! If you are vegan--the staff and cooks were very accommodating and helpful in figuring out what could be arranged. Just gotta ask :)

We visited here our first night and found it charming. We sat outside and enjoyed the lobster rolls and a local IPA. Our server was friendly and attentive.

Food was good. Comedy show was a nice extra. Service was good as well. Price was pretty normal for the island.

2nd try is the charm. Tried for breakfast that morning and just stood & stood with no acknowledgement from staff as the sign clearly stated wait to be seated....Tried later in the day for a late lunch ... outdoor seat with N umbrella... great wait staff! Recommend the 1/2 shrimp and it was fantastic!!! Had a pork belly taco and a shrimp taco both very flavorful!Live music was great! Beer selection and the blueberry vodka lemonade with fresh blueberries fabulous!

Stopped in to the Reel Bar to try the Reel Royal Red Shrimp. We were not disappointed!! These deep water shrimp were amazing. When dipped into the melted butter, they tasted just like lobster. Thumbs up to our waiter Vito too.

The food was great, very fresh! We had a grouper sandwich, shrimp street tacos and a caprese salad. The highlight of our meal was our server, Nate!! He was kind, knowledgeable and lots of fun. He made the meal a pleasure. Look for him when you visit and I hope the restaurant rewards him for his efforts!!

QUALITY SERVICE so we all love the reel bar it's a great alternative to roundhouse if ur not feeling it! Fantastic reel burg. Beautiful waitresses. Cheap booze for the island anyway. Funny T-shirt's. It's always a must visit for me anyway, but this time I parked by the police station. Save a trip later I thought HA. So I walk up the stairs & the boss man is telling people to hold up, we shut down for a minute for cleaning around 4. So I walk right by oblivious and sit down the bar. I get a couple rum & cokes & chat up Erica and blah blah blah drink drink drink. Couple wraps up their lunch and leaves. Meantime there's a line out the ass outside waiting to get in. They're cleaning the tables sweeping restocking and there I am. People are looking inside like what's with Gilligan there at the bar?? Well I wrapped up the day drink said my goodbyes to the bartendress and see the man on the way out. He unchains the stair gate, there ya go buddy. I said hey Man whoops u were closing it down and I had my happy hour anyway. Nice guy, WHO CARES HE SEZ, SOMETIME'S ITS ALL ABOUT TIMING. Another memorable trip to the reel bar, where apparently we're all VIPs. 10 stars.

this was the worst espresso martini I've ever had and will ever have. I'm not sure how something could top how awful it was. Do not waste $14 on it. It's a ploy because they're trendy right now. DO NOT I REPEAT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THE ESPRESSO MARTINI. food was fine.

Worst service on PIB. Marginal food can't overcome the lack of passion of Staff. There are a lot better options on the island...