Papa Roni's Pizza & Ice Cream

Papa's Favorite Pizzas

Papa CBR Pizza

Chicken, double bacon & ranch - perfect 1,000! Topped with a homemade chipotle ranch swirl.
$14.29
Deluxe Pizza

The classic - pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, red onion, and crumbled sausage.
$14.29
Meat Eaters Pizza

For the carnivore in you! Pizza sauce, 3 cheeses, pepperoni, crumbled sausage, diced ham, and crispy bacon. How can you go wrong with that?
$14.29
Chicken Philly Pizza

We start with a creamy cheese sauce and load it with red onion, green peppers, mushrooms, grilled chicken, and our 3 cheese blend.
$14.29
White Garden Pizza

Our homemade garlic butter sauce, fresh spinach, cheese, banana peppers, feta cheese and fresh tomatoes, finished with basil & balsamic glaze after baking.
$14.29
Meaty Menser Pizza

This is a creation of our manager, Tim. Crumbled ground beef, crisp bacon, and crumbled sausage start it off. It's then topped with pepperoni for a crispy bite. After baking, we turn up the heat by adding special hot spices!
$14.29
Chipotle Steak Pizza

A garlic butter cheese sauce with steak, mushrooms, banana peppers, mozzarella cheese, and a chipotle ranch swirl on top!
$14.29
Gold Rush Pizza

Enjoy the sweetness of gold. Carolina gold sauce topped with our 3 cheese blend, cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, pineapple, and mild banana peppers. Scott's favorite.
$14.29
Gyro Pizza

This pizza is amazing, but don't take our word for it! A thin crust with tzatziki sauce, red onion, gyro meat, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, and roma tomatoes.
$19.79
The Gym Pizza

Inspired by a fellow gymgoer. The perfect balance of protein and green vegetables. Pizza sauce, cheese, pepperoni, chicken, spinach, and broccoli. Not your typical pizza combination, but it is delicious!
$14.29
Spinach Chicken Pizza

Our homemade garlic butter sauce covered with our 3 cheese blend, chicken, fresh mushrooms, spinach, and parmesan cheese.
$14.29

Specialty Pizzas

5 Cheese Pepperoni Pizza

Love cheese? Love pepperoni? We thought so! We use our 3 cheese blend, add extra pepperoni, cheddar and Parmesan.
$13.19
Hawaiian Pizza

You've never had one like this before. Pizza sauce with 3 cheeses, diced ham, crispy bacon, and lots of pineapple. We also add sliced almonds and top it with cinnamon-sugar!
$13.19
Monster Roni Pizza

We use a NEW Monster-sized pepperoni on this along with our regular portion of pepperoni and extra cheese. Enjoy the layers of flavors!
$13.19
Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Pizza with a little kick to it! Buffalo sauce covered with chicken, red onion, cheddar cheese, and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with ranch dressing.
$13.19
BBQ Chicken Pizza

We start with a sweet BBQ sauce and add three cheeses, red onions, chicken, and bacon.
$13.19
7 Cheesy Cheese Pizza

For the cheese lovers, this pizza is for you! We top our fresh dough and sauce with 7 cheeses: mozzarella, provolone, Muenster, cheddar, feta, Parmesan, Romano & extra cheese!
$13.19
The Brier Hill Pizza

A unique Youngstown pizza classic on a thicker crust, a more traditional Italian "Sunday sauce", lighter Parmesan cheese with sliced meatballs and fresh green peppers.
$13.19
12" Margherita Pizza

This pizza's history dates back to 1889. The red tomatoes, white fresh mozzarella cheese and green basil represent the colors of the Italian flag.
$18.69
Veggie Pizza

For those looking for a healthier option: pizza sauce covered with 3 cheeses, red onion, fresh mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and Roma tomatoes.
$13.19
Dill Pickle Pizza

The iconic dill pickle pizza from Barberton's red horse winery! Served on a medium thin crust with garlic butter sauce, cheese, dill pickle slices, spices and a swirl of homemade ranch dressing.
$18.69
Tiki Torcher Pizza

We start with a hawaiian pizza and instead of the almonds and cinnamon-sugar, we add jalapenos and red pepper flakes. The sweet perfectly balances the spicy.
$13.19

Create Your Own Pizza

14" Large Cheese Pizza

10 slices. Hand-tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$15.39
Big Papa Sheet Cheese Pizza

32 slices. Hand-tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious 3-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$32.99
12" Medium Cheese Pizza

8 slices. Hand-tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$13.19
10" Small Cheese Pizza

6 slices. Hand-tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$9.89
8" Personal Cheese Pizza

4 slices. Hand-tossed dough that is made fresh daily and cold risen for 48 hours. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$5.99
12" Medium Thin Crust Cheese Pizzas

8 slices. Made on a delicious thin crust dough. Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin / cauliflower crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$13.19
10" Small Cauliflower Crust Cheese Pizza

6 slices. Made on a cauliflower crust (gluten free). Our homemade no heartburn pizza sauce is next, topped with our delicious three-cheese blend. Add toppings to make it yours! Be aware - pizzas ordered on a thin / cauliflower crust will not enjoy the same heat retention as our original crust.
$13.19

Cheese Bread & Bread Stix

4 Piece Cheese Bread

Thick pizza dough covered with garlic butter, mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, and Romano cheese. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with marinara dipping sauce.
$8.79
Garlic Stix

Thick pizza dough topped with garlic butter, Parmesan, and Romano cheeses. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with marinara sauce.
$6.59
Garlic Bread

A delicious mini ciabatta baked with our homemade garlic butter.
$2.75
Pepperoni Cheese Bread

Thick pizza dough covered with garlic butter, mozzarella, cheddar, pepperoni, Parmesan, and Romano cheese. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with marinara dipping sauce.
$8.79
Bacon Cheese Bread

Thick pizza dough covered with garlic butter, mozzarella, cheddar, bacon, Parmesan, and Romano cheese. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with marinara dipping sauce.
$8.79
1 Dozen Caramel Cinnamon-Streusel Stix

Thick pizza dough covered with butter, cinnamon-sugar & a homemade streusel topping, drizzled with caramel after baking. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with icing on the side.
$7.69
1 Dozen Raspberry Stix

Thick pizza dough covered with sugar, butter, and raspberry topping. Cut into a dozen pieces, served with icing on the side. Tastes like a jelly doughnut!
$7.69

Oven Baked Subs

Spicy Italian Sub

Ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, mild peppers cheese, lettuce, Roma tomatoes, and Italian dressing.
$9.89
Italian Sub

Sliced ham, Genoa salami, and melted cheese. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, Italian dressing on the side.
$9.89
Buffalo Chicken Sub

Grilled chicken breast strips covered with Buffalo sauce and our 3-cheese blend. Topped with lettuce and tomato, served with a side of blue cheese or ranch.
$9.89
Ultimate BLT Sub

Bacon, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, mayonnaise on the side.
$9.34
Meatball Sub

Marinara sauce, all-beef meatballs, and our 3-cheese blend.
$9.34
Pizza Sub

Pizza sauce and cheese are standard. Add any 3 topping of your choice! Add toppings for an additional charge.
$8.79
Chicken Cordon Gold Sub

Try our delicious take on a chicken cordon bleu. Grilled chicken topped with gold sauce, Swiss-American cheese, and sliced ham. Lettuce and tomatoes after baked plus mayonnaise.
$9.89
Chipotle Steak Sub

Our perfectly seasoned steak topped with American cheese, banana peppers, and mushrooms. Served with chipotle ranch on the side.
$9.89
Philly Steak Sub

Our perfectly seasoned steak topped with American cheese, grilled green peppers, and onions. Served with mayonnaise on the side.
$9.89
Turkey Club Sub

Turkey, ham, melted cheese, and bacon. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, mayonnaise on the side.
$9.89
Veggie Sub

Fresh mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, black olives, banana peppers, and cheddar cheese. Topped with lettuce & tomatoes, Italian dressing on the side.
$8.79

Salads

Antipasto Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes, red onion, ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, black olives, and a pepperoncini pepper.
$9.89
Buffalo Chicken salad

Mixed lettuce, Roma tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta cheese, crispy Buffalo chicken and a pepperoncini pepper.
$10.44
Chef Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes, red onions, ham, turkey, cheddar cheese, black olives, and a pepperoncini pepper.
$9.89
Garden Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes, cucumber, red onions, mozzarella cheese, black olives, and a pepperoncini pepper.
$9.89
Grilled Chicken Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes, red onions, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, and black olives.
$9.89

Dippin Chicken

6 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

Served plain with sauce on the side to dip. 6 piece come with 1 free sauce.
$7.14
12 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

Served plain with sauce on the side to dip. 12 piece comes with 2 free sauces.
$13.19
24 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

Served plain with sauce on the side to dip. 24 piece comes with 3 free sauces.
$24.19

Pasta and Meatballs

Meatball Bowl

Enjoy 12 whole meatballs baked with your choice of sauce. Add cheese if you wish!
$7.69
Buffalo Chicken MagicRoni and Cheese

A delicious portion of our white cheddar macaroni and cheese with Buffalo chicken and feta cheese.
$13.19
Papa's Peppers

2 Hungarian hot peppers stuffed with 1 of four topping combinations. Covered with marinara sauce and garnished with fresh basil and Parmesan cheese.
$8.25
Pasta

Penne served with our marinara or garlic butter.
$8.24
Deluxe MagicRoni and Cheese

A delicious portion of our white cheddar macaroni and cheese with fresh broccoli, bacon, and grilled chicken.
$13.19
MagicRoni and Cheese

A generous portion of delicious white cheddar macaroni and cheese.
$9.34

Papa Roni Roll

Papa Roni Roll

Pepperoni & mozzarella cheese stuffed inside freshly made pizza dough and baked to perfection. Served with your choice of 2 side sauces. No additions or substitutions.
$6.92
4 Pack of Papa Roni Rolls

A 4 pack of our soon to be famous Papa Roni rolls. These are served 4 in 1 box and come with a total of 8 dipping sauce cups.
$25.30
Jalapeno Popper Roni Roll

In the mood for some jalapeo poppers? Look no further! This jalapeno popper roni roll is as close as you can get without the fryer. We roll up a pizza dough and stuff it with 2 different cheeses and jalapeo. Served with 2 sides of ranch for your dipping pleasure.
$6.92

Gyros

Chicken Gyro

Grilled chicken breast, red onions, Roma tomatoes, & tzatziki sauce served on a 7" handmade pita. Try it with Kalamata olives & feta cheese to make it a deluxe gyro.
$8.79
Gyro

Traditional gyro meat, red onions, Roma tomatoes & tzatziki sauce served on a 7" handmade pita. Try it with Kalamata olives & feta cheese to make it a deluxe gyro.
$8.79

Cookies

3 Chocolate Chip Cookies

Fresh-baked otis spunkmeyer chocolate chip cookies. Because you can't eat just 1 or 2!
$4.40
1 Dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies

1 dozen fresh-baked otis spunkmeyer chocolate chip cookies. Plenty to share!
$13.20

Beverages

2 Liter Soda

Coke products. Choice of flavor.
$4.06
20 oz. Soda

Coke products. Choice of flavor.
$2.96
16.9 oz. Water
$1.65

Shana K.

★★★★★

Jul 27, 2021

This place is a staple in my household. The pizza is delicious and the ice cream is the best around. At least once a month we order delivery and have a pizza and movie night. The pizza isn't overly greasy and the balance between sauce, cheese and crust is on point.I'll never forget a few years ago when I had a new fridge delivered the day of a snow storm so I had no food in the house. I tried to order from multiple places but no one would deliver because of the roads. That didn't stop Papa Roni's. They brought me enough food for the couple days I knew Id be stuck at home until I could get out to the grocery store. They care about their customers and it shows.

Travis L.

★★★★★

Aug 30, 2022

We really enjoy their pizza, it's consistently good, haven't tried their ice cream is great too

Jeremy B.

★★★★★

May 17, 2021

Yesterday I ordered the Peanut Butter Cup Sundae. It was delicious. Excellent.

K. M.

★★★★☆

Aug 19, 2015

Papa Roni's is your basic ice cream stand that also sells pizza. Picnic tables allow you to dine outside. The ice cream is from Katie's Corner, so you know it's good. I was there munching on some ice cream the other day with friends and decided to take a pizza home with me. I ordered my standard medium pepperoni, of course to go. A medium at Papa Roni's goes for $8.99 plus $1.50 for the topping.They advertise that their dough is made fresh daily, and it taste like it. The medium is listed as 12 inches, but mine measured in at 11 1/2. Not a big deal; freshly made dough will shrink a little once it's in the pan. The outside crust measured 1/2 inch. I counted 31 slices of pepperoni, but they were a bit smaller than most other places so it's probably comparable to what others do.I thought the pizza was O.K. It was baked well; the pepperoni developing a slight crunch. But by the time I arrived home the pizza had cooled down, so that didn't really give a true representation. One of the reasons why I always order at least a medium pizza is so I can have enough left over to enjoy the next day. That's what I did with these leftovers. The pizza didn't look all that great the next day, but I threw some slices on a plate and microwaved it for 99 seconds anyway. I'm glad I did. Once properly reheated, the pizza was fabulous. Flavor of the sauce came through. The crust sprang to life, a tiny crunch on the outside and a soft and chewy inside, representative of the "Cleveland style" pizza we Ohioans love so much. I'd go back. But next time wouldn't wait as long to eat it.

Cara S.

★★★★★

Sep 20, 2021

i suggest (HUGELY SUGGEST) a calzone, the most AWESOME mac and cheese (bacon chicken and broccoli say whaaaaat?!?) and a pint of the the strawberry ice cream to split for a dinner in for two or three! sorry, i've had it three times and still can't get a pic before it's gone but trust me, you won't be disappointed!

Angela C.

★★★★★

Sep 26, 2020

We came up to walk some trails at Portage Lakes State Park. On the way home, we spotted Papa Roni. It caught my eye because the sign said they had fall flavors of ice cream. Then we saw they serve pizza by the slice and decided to get that too. They are only taking orders at the drive-through. So when we order, the pizza needs to cook first, and we get to eat out dessert first! They had us park around the front while we waited and ate our ice cream. When the gentleman brought our pizza out, he apologized. We said it was all right. We got to eat dessert first!The ice cream was all great. I had apple pie, and I asked for whipped cream. It tasted just like a piece of pie with ice cream and some whipped cream. My husband had butterscotch ripple and Blue Moon(a soft raspberry flavor). It was nice creamy, and delightful,The pizza came out in one of their boxes, piping hot. Everything about it was so good. The crust was light and not doughy, cooked just right. Just the right amount of sauce and seasoned well. The old world pepperoni on my husband's piece was good. Good amount of mozzarella cheese was usedSo glad we stopped.

Robert L.

★★★★★

May 20, 2019

Pizza was good, but the ice cream must be tasted to be understood. My wife and I shared a single scoop chocolate and a single scoop banana in the same cup. I have had custard and it won for strength in flavor over ice cream for me....until now. When I say the flavor is a kick in the mouth its meant as a sincere compliment. I got a full scoop of flavor of any ice cream I had before in half a spoonful of Hershey's or Toft's. It breaks my heart to say that because I love Tofts bluberry waffle cone. They get the ice cream local so if you aren't from the area I doubt you've had something at this level of flavor. It has probably ruined me for other ice creams for a while. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did!

Lydia O.

★☆☆☆☆

Apr 8, 2024

I will never order from the Barberton location ever again! Watch your money! My bank called me saying someone was using card number after the Super Bowl they found out it was when I ordered from Papa Roni's! So a month ago I wanted a sub I had cash I said I was not leaving a tip I gave the driver my cash and I received no change! Twice I they stole! No more Papa Roni's for me!

Gwen B.

★★★★★

Jan 5, 2023

Ordered 2 sheet pizzas ahead of time for a New Years party. Everything was ready to go at the time I requested. The staff was friendly and clearly working hard on such a busy night. The pizza was great too!

Cortney E.

★★★★★

Mar 1, 2022

Buffalo chicken magicroni & cheese is my favorite! I get it for lunch at least once a month! Service is always super friendly & the meal is always hot!

Papa Roni's Pizza & Ice Cream

Menu

Papa's Favorite Pizzas

Papa CBR Pizza

Deluxe Pizza

Meat Eaters Pizza

Chicken Philly Pizza

White Garden Pizza

Meaty Menser Pizza

Chipotle Steak Pizza

Gold Rush Pizza

Gyro Pizza

The Gym Pizza

Spinach Chicken Pizza

Specialty Pizzas

5 Cheese Pepperoni Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza

Monster Roni Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

BBQ Chicken Pizza

7 Cheesy Cheese Pizza

The Brier Hill Pizza

12" Margherita Pizza

Veggie Pizza

Dill Pickle Pizza

Tiki Torcher Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza

14" Large Cheese Pizza

Big Papa Sheet Cheese Pizza

12" Medium Cheese Pizza

10" Small Cheese Pizza

8" Personal Cheese Pizza

12" Medium Thin Crust Cheese Pizzas

10" Small Cauliflower Crust Cheese Pizza

Cheese Bread & Bread Stix

4 Piece Cheese Bread

Garlic Stix

Garlic Bread

Pepperoni Cheese Bread

Bacon Cheese Bread

1 Dozen Caramel Cinnamon-Streusel Stix

1 Dozen Raspberry Stix

Oven Baked Subs

Spicy Italian Sub

Italian Sub

Buffalo Chicken Sub

Ultimate BLT Sub

Meatball Sub

Pizza Sub

Chicken Cordon Gold Sub

Chipotle Steak Sub

Philly Steak Sub

Turkey Club Sub

Veggie Sub

Salads

Antipasto Salad

Buffalo Chicken salad

Chef Salad

Garden Salad

Grilled Chicken Salad

Wings

Bone-in Chicken Wings

Dippin Chicken

6 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

12 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

24 Piece Oven Baked Boneless Chicken Wings

Ice Cream

Ice Cream

Pasta and Meatballs

Meatball Bowl

Buffalo Chicken MagicRoni and Cheese

Papa's Peppers

Pasta

Deluxe MagicRoni and Cheese

MagicRoni and Cheese

Papa Roni Roll

Papa Roni Roll

4 Pack of Papa Roni Rolls

Jalapeno Popper Roni Roll

Gyros