Papa Nick's Pizza & Pasta

Ordered the Italian sun and it was delicious and had it with a nice cold beer for dine in. The owner was a delight!

I had high hopes for this place but was disappointed. Ordered a cheese pizza and it had way too much cheese and was very salty. I like cheese but I want to taste more than just that. But hey if you're a cheese fan....

The good-Online ordering through the actual merchant, and not through a third-party, so no added fees.The bad-The " battered cheese sticks" were soggy and garlic bread with cheese was small.The ugly-If you have no issues with dairy skip this part. If you have any issues with dairy- DONT ORDER THE PIZZA! They put like 3 inches of cheese on it- check my pics. Seriously I've been dairy sick all night and I took 10 lactaid pills.You've been warned.

The owner's son, Phil, was friendly and welcoming. Our server, Bobby was sweet, attentive, and efficient. Always checking to be sure we had everything we needed. The food was fresh and wonderfully prepared. The pricing was very affordable. The atmosphere was charming and made you feel welcome and like you were visiting an old friend. It was a great experience, and we would highly recommend Papa Nick's to anyone.

We had not been to Papa Nick's in years. We use to go at least once a week for pizza night but moved out of the neighborhood. Well, we are back and tried it again for pizza night. They did not disappoint. We got a plain cheese pizza and a loaded pizza. Both were so yummy. We will go back again. Nice to know they still have great pizza!

This was the first place I ate at when I moved to Lakewood. As a lover of pizza, I can be critical sometimes, but I have nothing bad to say. Pizza is delicious, reasonably priced, and staff have always been friendly.

If you want a quick but delicious lunch this is definitely the place! The macaroni salad is AMAZING! I had the chicken Caesar wrap and it was pressed so it was warm and wonderful. I will definitely be returning and you should definitely stop in. They are so welcoming!Update: I tried the pizza! Holy crap it is OUTSTANDING! You can tell great care and love goes into each of his pizzas! Next time I'm in Cleveland I'll definitely make a stop here, and you should definitely make your way to lunch or dinner here sometime soon!

I felt the pizza was underbaked. It was still edible and tasted decent but would have benefitted from being in the oven a bit longer. Sauce was tangy and delicious. Service was fine.

Great old school neighborhood pizzeria. Out of all the local pizza spots, Papa Nicks takes the cake. Good dough consistency, nice light salted flavor and plush bite. The sauce is exactly what I look for in a pizza sauce, a nice balance between salty, naturally sweet tomato flavor and of course a nice acidic zing to cut the nice blanket of cheese sitting on top. A testament to a good pizza construction is if the cheese stays on top of the slice when you take it out of the box, Papa Nicks passes that test with flying colors. The guys behind the counter were awesome, happy to share their knowledge of their legendary craft. If I could give infinite stars I would. All in all, if you want a balanced bite of pizza with a nice punchy finish that makes the next bite taste better, Papa Nicks is your spot! Don't forget to tip well.

I can't believe how bad this option has deteriorated.I have lived in the area of and ordered from this restaurant for more than a decade..On the plus side, both the person who took my order and the person who delivered it were very professional and good.. kudos to them..In the minus side..I feel horrible about wasting food..But what arrived was disgusting and inedible..Eggplant burnt.,Cheese sticks soggy and not sufficiently cooked