Pepperoni
Basic B
Piggy Bird
Firebird
Paradise
Heartburner
Burly Boy
Bio-Dome
pizza
Cookies!!!
a pizza in a box
Tasting
Large chicken and mushroom pizza
Basic B (small)
Piggy Bird
After School Special
Pizza
Cookies
Medium Vegan Firebird with Vegan ranch (my non vegan family prefers the vegan version of the Firebird!)
Thanksgiving Pizza
S'mores cookie
Bday Cake & Chips Ahoy
Small Vegan Pepperoni (OMG so good!!)
Philena A.
Feb 16, 2025
OMG! Did you know Ohio-style pizza was a thing? Neither did I! Apparently, it's all about the crispy crust! Days later I am still impressed. I ordered a build your own: onions, mushrooms, vegan sausage and jalapeno peppers. This was cheesy, crispy, flavorful, spicy, and just so good. The staff was also super friendly and the place was super clean. As you know, I reserve five stars for places that leave a great impression. This place deserves it because my pizza never made it from the parking lot!!!Side note: I especially appreciate the fact that they don't have delivery. It would ruin the crust, which is a total experience. Luckily, this place is just far enough away that I won't order it every day but could make a special stop or pass by after grocery shopping. Cause if I attempt to go on an empty stomach I know I'll be buying a large pizza and that is completely unacceptable. LOLBonus: they make cookies! Let me tell you. I ordered one the day before - look, we listen and we don't judge. Yes. I returned the very next day to try a pizza. Giggle.P.S. This is a takeaway only place.
Read More
Warren S.
Jan 26, 2025
WOW! When I say this is probably the best pizza I've had in Cleveland, I mean it!Pizza has sauce poured over top vs. under the toppings and cheese, and it's on the sweeter side. I wasn't sure I was going to like it but I do!The workers were friendly and had recommended some good cookies for me to choose from as their case was packed full of so many different kinds of cookies. They are delicious!We will back!
Read More
Samantha K.
Jan 23, 2025
There is NOTHING like Ohio pie!! This is my kind go pizza. I love the thick yet crunchy crust. I also could not leave a review without mentioning the COOKIES!! So many flavors that differ each day. Every girls night I make sure to get some pies and a variety of cookies, the best part? They have vegan pizza and cookies which works out great since one of my friends is vegan. It's nice to not worry about making sure I pick up something separate for my friend. Staff has always been friendly and helpful when I take too long picking out cookies. Would definitely be back time and time again!
Read More
Gillian S.
Nov 30, 2023
Now I'll be the first to admit, I was very scared of trying this "Thanksgiving Pizza" all my co-workers were talking about.... But wow am I happy I took the leap and decided to try it! Sounds crazy, but tastes delicious!!! Everything you could want in a Thanksgiving meal... all on one pizza!!! It's good. I promise. Since we were feeling adventurous this night, we decided to also try their Pickle Pizza....Which (in my opinion) was even better than their Thanksgiving pizza, but I'll admit I'm biased... I LOVE pickles! I don't know how they make these crazy sounding pizzas so delicious, but they definitely gained a couple fans tonight! I'm so excited to try their regular and other creative pizzas in the future! But I will also definitely be counting down the days till next November, when I can get this Thanksgiving pizza again!
Read More
Pat S.
Dec 4, 2024
Just wonderful pizza! Real close to where my kids live so occasionally they bring it over for a casual supper!
Read More
Ashley O.
Jan 7, 2023
As much as I wish they were equal, the Rocky River store just doesn't quite hit the mark as high as the Brunswick store. The cookies are always lacking and fewer. I also got charged for extra sauce today. Not sure if that is new or just something River does, but I feel like they should tell you that. Overall pizza was good. Their pepperoni continues to be my favorite outside of brunch.The mashed potato pizza special was okay, nothing to rave about. Overall, really solid pizza.
Read More
Ailin J.
Nov 29, 2022
Pretty darn good pizza. Ordered the pepperoni and the sauce had a subtle sweetness which I was a big fan of. Love the pepperoni topping to pizza dough ratio. Friendly staff, got takeout pizza in a reasonable fast time, excited to order again.They also have a cool selection of cookies which are thick and melty!
Read More
Joy P.
Aug 25, 2021
Ohio Pie in Rocky River just opened yesterday. Because I've had pizza from their Brunswick location, I have been eagerly awaiting this new location as its 45 minutes closer to me. I called and placed an order for two medium pizzas, one was the Piggy Bird and the other was the Cheesesteak. I ordered both with vegan cheese instead of regular as I have a dairy allergy. I was informed it would be about 45 minutes. When I pulled in the parking lot about 45 minutes later, there was a line at the door. Word has gotten out that they are open now! Some people paid for their orders and had to wait a little longer, as they were incredibly busy. Luckily, my pizzas were ready by the time I got to the front of the line. I added two vegan cookies as well. I got a Pumpkin Snickerdoodle and a Rocky River - they were two for $5. The whole order was $41. Just as I've had previously, the Piggy Bird was delicious! The cheesesteak was good, just not as good as I expected it to be from previous experiences. And the cookies were absolutely delicious too! Love that they have vegan options and can substitute vegan cheese for those that have dairy allergies or intolerance! And bonus with the vegan cookies!
Read More
Adam P.
Mar 11, 2024
Very Ohio style pizza. Great vegan options which is certainly welcome. Make sure you get a cookie.
Read More
Cheryl V.
Mar 2, 2025
Ordered a large pizza. The pizza was Thick and doughy with Hardly any cheese. Disappointed
Read More