Odd Fellows

Why aren't there more reviews of this place yet? I know so many people who have visited and LOVED it, so I finally organized a Girls Night Out at Oddfellows. First off, if you know Chagrin Falls, you know that parking can be challenging. But Oddfellows has a HUGE advantage because there's on-street parking right in front and the big Heinens parking lot in back. And yes, there is a very obvious back door to the restaurant, giving you amazing access to free parking. I went last night with 6 friends, several of whom are extremely picky. We were seated at a perfectly sized squarish table in front, making it very easy for us to converse (we don't like being seated at long tables). We ordered the mussels, Bell & Evans chicken, salmon, tandori cauliflower, beet salad (with salmon added) and 2 had the shrimp bucatini And though my friends are notorious for sending food back, EVERYONE was pleased with their meal the first time around :-) I've got to say, we marveled over the shrimp bucatini. Not only were the shrimp HUGE, but there were 9 of them! Several friends vowed to order that dish next time. Our server, Bianca, was fabulous. She came back to the table frequently to refill water, and just was always visible and checking in on us (without being annoying at all). She was so personable! And when we got the checks (which they split for us as requested with no resistance), each one was delivered in a little hardcover book. What a cute touch! The pages of the book would've been blank, except guests were invited to write notes inside. We'll definitely be back, and maybe next time we'll save some room to try the baked hot chocolate dessert.

The food was all fantastic! Probably best chicken I have ever eaten. Service was fast and friendly meeting. All of our needs. The ambience was upscale, but not overly upscale. Really liked the wall art. The vibe was really nice.

A friend and I went here January 2025 for lunch. We thought it was excellent! We shared three small plates. Calamari, sushi and mussels. We loved them all. The calamari crisp and came with a good dipping sauce. The sushi was excellent. The mussels were in a thick creamy mustard sauce which was amazing!!

Best damn burger I've had in memory. Consumed at the warm, convivial bar, which is tended by welcoming Mick and company. Great atmosphere and sensational food. Drinks list is top notch, too. Will be back.

I recommend going here! I Had the bone in ribeye was cooked perfectly. The atmosphere, service, and especially the hostess were exceptional!

Whoa, just stumble onto this place. Can't say enough about this restaurant. Drinks were incredible. Cauliflower app was delish, one of the best Duck confit meals I've had. Highly recommend.