Muscarella's Cafe Italia

Myyyyyy goodness gracious. Got the "Manzo" off the specials menu & I am so glad I did!What an absolute blast of flavors that all paired so well. Chargrilled 16oz. New York Strip, Cheese Tortelloni, Cacio E Pepe, Trumpet Mushrooms.. I'd eat this every day if I could. Came piping hot too.The KitKat Cheesecake (by DiLorenzo's) to finish off the night was good flavor wise, those KitKat chunks IN the cheesecake make it near impossible to get a fork through at some points, like a rock barrier! But who eats KitKats with a fork anyways? No complaint, I do believe they were "off-brand" though as I saw zero branding on the candy.Service was quick per usual even on the extremely busy nights they deal with

Great relaxing atmosphere with a great vibe. Our server was trying her best but it seemed the back of the house wasn't helping. Bar service was SLOOOWWWW. We ordered drinks, a few minutes later our app. A few minutes later our meal. Our app came before the drinks. Wife ordered no onions on her side salad or meal. Both came covered in onions. I ordered the Short Rib Pappardelle for the 3rd time and for the third time got a totally different dish. Two of the three were good though. One in our party ordered the Italian Fest which went mostly untouched because it was all so very dry. Wife's steak was good and chicken parm was eaten. The food was hit and miss, but the cannolis stole the show. They are by far the best part of this restaurant.

We have been here a handful of time since my last review, but I wanted to update as this place is always amazing. My husband and I enjoyed a delicious meal this past Saturday. We shared the fresh bread with dipping oil. We also ordered the hot peppers and they were spicy and perfectly flavored. I got one of the specials which was a steak tip Gorgonzola fettuccine dish. It was heavenly delicious and huge portion. My husband ordered the Italian steak on the menu. He said it was flavorful and delicious. Our meals also came with salad. Definitely one of the best restaurants in Mercer County.

Probably one of the best Italian places I have ever visited in a long time that felt authentic. The portions are large so you will not go away hungry or disappointed.

I'm traveling and stopped here with my daughter for some good food and it did not disappoint. I'm a foodie so I have high expectations but it was delicious! Very affordable for the large portions. Service was great too. Highly recommend.

Great food. Great service. Always hopping. Love it. Stop every time I drive east or west on Rt 80

Consider this some words of caution. It's disappointing to have to write this about a place I used to love going to. I've been going to Muscarella's with my family and friends for many years. The entire change of menu was a horrendous mistake in my opinion and I've only been back twice since the change. The second time was recently and it was later that night I became extremely ill with the stomach flu. I'm up to date on all of my shots and I also had two doctors tell me it was food poisoning, possibly due to cross contamination. Needless to say, due to recovering from the flu, having to miss work due to being sick and the quality of the food since decreasing in light of the menu change, I REFUSE to return and will caution anyone I know who is thinking about going. I'd hate for the same to happen to them. Be well and take your business elsewhere. There are plenty of options for Italian in Northeast Ohio that better by a landslide.

Went for a late lunch. Food was very good nice relaxing atmosphere ( however a rude table was FaceTiming on speaker with people and that was quite annoying. And should not be tolerated by the restaurant). Had the homemade tiramisu which was quite tasty. Had plenty of left over for a meal the next day. Other than the rudeness by others it is a nice place and recommended.

Delicious food, not overly salty; cozy interior; attentive and fast service. A great find this afternoon. Would recommend the wedding soup! Eager to try other entrees in the future!

We used to love this restaurant. Unfortunately they have changed their menu drastically and eliminated a lot of our favorites. I understand sometimes things have to change but these changes hit us personally. It's about a 20 mile drive for us to go there so now I'm rethinking my choices of restaurants. It was good while it lasted,but we're in for a new season.