Mimi's Pizza
Mimi's Pizza
Garlic knot and sauce for dipping
Margarita pizza
Menu board
Ordering counter
Small place, mostly take out.
Small seating area
Flyer with phone, email, address, and specials
a pizza in a box
Strip-mall exterior
outside
Owner chatting with customers like a true NY pizza place
Pizza by the slice
The outside - can't miss it on Bagley. Across from heinens
Pizza by the slice
Two slice lunch special
Cheese pizza
Pepperoni pizza
BIG slices of pizza
He just couldn't stop looking inside at his new friends!
Vodka pizza pie
Ny style cheese pizza
Margherita pizza
Sausage pizza
pizza, food
Antonio T.
Feb 5, 2025
Here's a rewritten, longer review:"I'm absolutely obsessed with Mimi's Pizza! I've been a regular here for a while now with my wife, and the experience never disappoints. The service is top-notch - the staff is always friendly, attentive, and genuinely care about their customers. It's clear they prioritize making sure everyone leaves happy and satisfied. The pizza, of course, is the real star of the show. Fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked crust, and generous toppings make for a truly unforgettable meal. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just looking for a quick bite, Mimi's Pizza is an absolute must-try. Five stars isn't enough - I'd give it ten if I could!"
Read More
Frank B.
Dec 19, 2024
A wonderful addition to Middleburg Heights. Great New York style pizza incredibly kind owners and great service. Pizza by the slice. Highly recommended. I especially love the white pizza and stop almost daily for a slice Support our local businesses.
Read More
Steven B.
Nov 15, 2024
Cleveland Pizza Week is a great opportunity to try pizza shops that I have not been to before; I am so happy that I tried Mimi's Pizza. Even though Mimi's is on the other side of town, I figured I would grab a pie after work; it helped that the Yelp reviews for Mimi's were so good. Mimi's is a small shop in a little plaza on Bagley Road, when I got there the place was busy. Mimi's is a very compact spot, most of the shop is the kitchen with a small service counter and a display of slices and garlic knots, all of which looked great. There are 2 small tables jammed into the window, both occupied by families enjoying their pizzas. I grabbed my cheese pizza and added some grated cheese and garlic powder to customize to my taste. The pizza smelled so good that I had to have a couple of slices on the ride home; I also had the rest of the pizza over the next couple of days and it was delicious.Mimi's makes a New York style pizza and they do a great version; the crust is thin with just enough rise to add some chew, the sauce is nicely balanced and the cheese is generous and just the right amount of tangy. Overall the ingredients come to together to make a pizza even better than the individual elements. My only criticism was that the pizza was a bit undercooked for my taste, but that is the style; when reheated at home the pizza was near perfect. I would highly recommend Mimi's Pizza, it is the best example of New York style pizza I have found in the Cleveland area. They know what they want to do and do it very well. Check them out.
Read More
Marissa K.
Nov 15, 2024
Pizzas were tasty. I really enjoyed the pepperoni. They could have had more color and baked longer, but they reheated nicely too.I had wanted the white pizza either spinach they had listed for pizza week, but gave me a margarita instead, which I don't care for since I hate tomatoes. Overall I'll get pizza again here to try for a second chance.
Read More
Shelly C.
Oct 3, 2024
Pizza by the slice for my hubby and pizza fries for me. Waffle fries with sauce and toppings. They were SOOO good. I have a wheat allergy so it was a fantastic option. Everyone in here is super friendly! The owner will chat with you for awhile if they aren't slammed. He is STRAIGHT outta New York, so this pizza isn't messing around. It's a takeout place so the inside is small but there are a couple of tables if you decide to eat in and enjoy this Big Apple experience in Cleveland
Read More
Emily T.
Oct 11, 2024
This place offers pizza by the slice.I paid $8.50 for 2 big slices - one cheese, one with sausage & pepperoni. Both were tasty and had a crisp thin crust. I also got the banana pudding, which was *chef's kiss* Creamy, scrumptious, and had real slices of banana.Service was also friendly. It is primarily a carryout place, but they do have 2 small tables for people who want to eat in the restaurant
Read More
Evan F.
Dec 19, 2023
Remember the guy who used to make all the fresh NY style pies at Capri Pizza with the old ownership group? Welp...he's "the guy" here at Mimi's now!Came in for a few slices and was really wowed by the service and the quality of their pies. They have a two-slice lunch special that comes with a small bag of chips and a bottle of pop that is truly unbeatable, especially given the size and taste of this pizza! While I was sitting there, they'd also just taken a batch of garlic knots out of the oven, so I got to sample one of those as well (with sauce for dipping, of course)...delish!Small inside with limited seating as they are mostly a take-away operation, but either way get on your horse and get over here to give these folks a try! If you love a good NY slice you will NOT be disappointed!
Read More
Ross L.
Oct 12, 2024
NY style pizza in NE Ohio. They offer by the slice, but we did a whole pie, the Milano with their spicy sauce & cupping pepperoni & it was great! They make the slices wide, so if you don't want that, either ask, or cut them to your preference at home. Loved it & will be back!
Read More
Nikola K.
Feb 13, 2025
I went and got a vodka pizza with chicken on it last night. It was the first time for my wife and I. The pizza was so good. It reminded me of a real margherita pizza from Italy. There wasn't a bunch of oily sauce like everywhere else. There was a nice and light, well made crust and a very flavorful vodka sauce. Think artisan New York slices with a Neopolitano pizza style. I was pleasantly surprised. I asked if they had a white pizza with broccoli as that's my favorite. The guy said he was thinking of making one but didn't. He said come by tomorrow and it will be there. Sure enough, it was. Great guy to talk to, passionate and kind. I'm a customer for life.
Read More
Jack R.
Sep 27, 2024
Stopped by after seeing on social media and 100000% worth the trip! True New York style pizza. Crispy bottom, great sauce and cheese. Got a few slices and the garlic knots with pepperoni and everything was so good! We will be back for sure.
Read More
