Appetizer trio with mushrooms, pickles, and hot cheese. The batter is *really* soft, fluffy and delicious.
Wings are done in their "Fucked up" style, which is when they are cooked, sauced, and then cooked again. I did not love them!
cheesy jalapeno pretzel: super delicious. The inside of the pretzel is slightly underdone, and stuffed with cheese and jalapenos. Awesome
Perch basket
Our Perch Basket Dinner.
Breaded pickle spears
Menu 4/2024
Menu of 2 4/2024
Perch basket
Patty Melt and fries
Beef Tacos
Wings
Tacos!
Oh thank God
I grew up not far from here. Yeah, Point Place sees itself not as just another neighborhood, but as it's own town.
The basic cheeseburger. I ordered medium...it was well done. The cook is new, apparently.
The main "dining room." Casual, shall we say?
Very big fresh burger!
House rules
The perch Sammy was the bomb two big filets for 8.99
Chicken bacon ranch was great as well
Huge chef salad
menu
Alexander B.
Jan 23, 2025
Food is tasty, pretty standard dive bar fare.Servers are very kind. Came here for lunch, and it was very clean and felt spacious. Seems like a place that would be a lot of fun at night.
Read More
Dustin H.
Aug 6, 2023
The Mayfly Tavern is a classic neighborhood bar & grill. The staff is completely welcoming to first-timers, and the regulars, of which there are a lot, may give you a bit of a side-eye when you first enter but will be smiling and telling you jokes before long. One might assume there would be a heavy focus on seafood, given the location on the water, but instead, it's more traditional bar food, deep-fried, delicious, homemade, and all made to order. Yes, there is some fish and shrimp, but the regulars seem more focused on chicken and appetizers. I loved everything I tried, except for the reason my friend took me out in the first place: the wings. I ordered mine "fucked up" style, which has the kitchen cooking the wings a second time after they are sauced. The word on the street is they are amazing, and the intent, I believe, is to crisp and fry up the sauce to add to the texture and depth of flavor, but what I received was just slightly burnt and too heavily sauced for my liking. They were still pretty good, but felt like an odd miss for the upcharge.Long story short, the Mayfly should be on your Point Place radar, and I look forward to visiting many times in the future. No question I'll order the fried mushrooms and cheesy jalapeno pretzels again, but I'll likely skip the wings.
Read More
Amanda G.
Aug 23, 2023
Nice local bar and restaurant. I stopped in for early dinner around 4pm after seeing the high ratings and perch on the menu. Everyone was friendly and the place was clean. It looks like there is a nice enclosed patio in the back. The food was good and all very fresh. I had never had perch before and it was really good. The batter was well done and not too thick or greasy. It's definitely a good place to check out in the area.
Read More
Adela S.
Jan 25, 2024
This is a nice local bar close to the boat launch. It's always a good place to grab a drink and a bite to eat if you are in the area. I really like their perch because it is fresh, crispy and very light and flaky. The fried pickle spears with homemade ranch are delicious as well. There is a jukebox and keno available and the crowd is friendly.
Read More
Randy D.
Sep 9, 2024
Great service and delicious food. Found this spot after a day of fishing on the lake. Have already been back multiple times. Good food, good atmosphere and a nice weekly special rotation.
Read More
Tray B.
Nov 4, 2023
Really good food. Not all bars provide good food, this one does. Go check 'em out. U likely won't be disappointed. The perch, Italian sandwich &/or chicken wrap ought to satisfy the most angry hunger pains.As for atmosphere and ambience... bar management does a good job bringing fun activities like music trivia and good DJ's on weekend nights. This place can be real fun and serves as one of the only late night bar locations in the Point. Seldom see any fights or arguments. Good people.
Read More
Bryan T.
Sep 10, 2023
Mayfly tavern. Let me tell you something, wings are incredible. They have this sauce style called fuck boy. Crazy ass name but it's delicious, double dipped BBQ daddys are insane. I could have had 40 but I made a choice not to, having pot roast this week and I can't sit here and fill up on wings. Perfect spot for a football Sunday. My buddy boost recommended this spot and it's the only thing he's ever been right about. They even gave me a free beer holder, can't remember what you call them. Cootchie holder. No issues with the restroom situation. Easy 10/10 stars.
Read More
Jim K.
Jan 15, 2025
Your service totally sucks. Every time I go in there, you have to be a regular to get any service. Otherwise you're just totally ignored. Went up the street to the whales much better.
Read More
Don D.
May 4, 2024
Food had the fish fry perch basket. Absolutely the best on Lake Erie,. The bar overlooks Maumee River. Great atmosphere great service. Would highly recommend.Destiny is fantastic !!!!!!!
Read More
Stephen S.
Nov 20, 2024
Once you get past all the people with the side eye looking at you walking in... It's actually a pretty great place. No one is mean they don't know you yet ha ha ha ha it's OK
Read More