Mary Coyle Ice Cream
Mary Coyle Ice Cream
Comparison of a peanut butter sundae vs. a dish of strawberry ice cream
Peanut butter pie
A trip back in time.
the interior of a restaurant
Love that vintage neon!
the interior of a restaurant
diners at counter
a neon sign in the window
inside
outside, donuts
Mint Oreo and cookies and cream ice cream sundae with marshmallow topping.
food
outside
Too cute
US Mint Banana Bowl
Menu
menu, sushi and sashimi
dessert, food
Menu
outside
interior
outside
outside
outside
Nicholas M.
Feb 23, 2025
Best ice cream I've ever had! Service was great. It's a little bit like dicks last resort. Some people don't get the owners sense of humor... but I promise he is a really great guy. I've been going there for years.
Read More
Michael H.
May 8, 2024
We all know the owner resembles the character off of the show Seinfeld. (aka, no soup for you)I put up w/ the nasty cantankerous person for a long time, because the food was that good.But enough is enough.The food isn't that good to be treated that badly every time.I was told that I had to wait outside.The eff?Enough is enough.Eff that dude. he is the worst.
Read More
Sue T.
Jul 14, 2022
This is one of the best local ice cream spots in town. Not only that, it holds a lot of historical value to Akron, OH. Come here for generously sized sundaes and THE BEST peanut butter pie ever. I ordered a dish of strawberry ice cream and got a serving that would be a large anywhere else! The serving sizes are so generous; I don't understand how this place makes $$!There's a wider variety of flavors and toppings to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters! I'm not sure why but the pizza here reminds me of my childhood. It just takes me back to when I didn't eat pizza that much and didn't know about all the different types available. It was hot, fresh and the tomato sauce was tart but balanced the softness of the crust well. This is an ideal place to take a date. There's some outdoor seating available, perfect for people watching!! Whatever you do, please order the peanut butter pie. It's decadent, fluffy, and so delicious. I imagined, if I was going through a breakup.. this would absolutely be a perfect thing to eat my feelings. Even better, it's made from scratch from a secret recipe.
Read More
Jessica B.
Sep 29, 2023
Incredibly smug, rude service. I went in for ice cream and the older gentleman behind the counter had nothing for me but ugliness.
Read More
Tony W.
Aug 14, 2022
Very cold atmosphere....almost like they are bothered, by your patronage. It's a reason why this repeated, in the comments section.
Read More
Will S.
Jul 21, 2022
This place was the absolutely worst and most disrespectful place that I've ever been to in terms of customer service..He was sooo rude and when I asked him his name he said "Michael Trecaso, I'm the owner"!I asked a few other customers on my way out if he was like that to them and a few folks said "he's always like that"!Why are we supporting people who don't care enough to show everyone equal opportunity respect!#worstever
Read More
Jennifer C.
Oct 1, 2024
RUDE. The experience we had at Mary Coyle was quite unpleasant. While traveling, we stopped by a place where the owner, I presume, inquired if we had read the menu displayed on the door. We were simply looking to order a cone. However, as soon as we entered, the man began to rant and raised his voice at us for not having made a decision prior to coming inside. I have never encountered such behavior from anyone, particularly an owner. Needless to say we turned around and left.
Read More
Jacob S.
Sep 13, 2024
I purchased a nine dollar pint of ice cream and it was in a Chinese to go container which I don't even think is a pint overall experience horrible
Read More
Robert C.
Jul 9, 2024
The employee was extremely rude. He did not seem to have any interest in actually selling anything. We left and went to another ice cream shop. A great way to drive away business!
Read More
Greg R.
Feb 17, 2024
Everytime I visit this establishment I am always very much delighted to have such a wonderful place like this nearby. I have eaten here many times and I feel it's a real blessing to have something so special as this place Located in the heart of Highland square. I love the shakes here! My favorite of all time is the raspberry coconut ! Most Everytime I come here I get one of those too. I wish they had dine in service but as in most restaurants , help is really hard to find. I feel that if you are ever in the neighborhood you definitely need to check out this place. Everyone deserves a delicious meal or sweet treat. Life is short not to enjoy a little party in the mouth from time to time. 5 Stars here for sure!
Read More
