Magic City's Remarkable Diner

Absolute only reason we came here was because the reviews. What is wrong with the palets of this town? I don't think I've had more inedible breakfast. Matter fact I didn't eat it. I tried by turning what they called stuffed French toast, over so that it might be softer. I would've needed a knife to cut into the toast. Wasn't toast... it was two pieces of bread that was attempted to be made into French toast, hard , & set on top of berries and cream. No. We asked for crispy bacon and got burnt and greasy. The decaf was the most bitter ever, and I did not drink that either. My husband managed to choke down 1/2 his inferior breakfast because he was ravished and he actually drank a half cup of coffee. When our server came I did explain how I tried and even took some of the center of the "stuffing" out ... the whipped cream. But it was not tasty. Our server was adorable and we gave her 20% because we saw her over with the manager or the owner pitching our case that I didn't like my meal and I didn't eat any of it. The manager apparently did not approve a comp. or a discount for that matter. She probably figured she's got regular customers that'll show up that have no appreciation for what good food is. I mean apparently lol !Thanks for serving us Gabby, and being a good sport trying to pitch our story.

The service here is top notch. I love the atmosphere. Everyone is happy and it's great seeing so many regulars come in. I love their specials and part of me really wanted the avocado with smoked Gouda omelette but after a liquid diet yesterday i wanted the whole menu. Food has been outstanding both times I've been there. I love that they have artwork for sale by local artists and have themed dinners. I spoke to one of the owners today and she was wonderful. It's such a friendly place to go to. I wish it was closer to home but it's worth the trip and always a special treat if you have to go to Barberton Hospital for anything. Can't wait to go back and I'll be following their events on their Facebook page.

First time visiting here and I was impressed. The staff made me feel right at home. Many unique items are available for breakfast. There were so many choices that I didn't feel I needed to look at the other side of the menu. Ordered the build your own omelette and it was delicious. All ingredients were very fresh. Great ratio too of bacon, veggies, and cheese to the eggs. Loved the seasoning on the potatoes! The portions are substantial here. I ended up taking home leftovers. The coffee was also delicious! Very smooth. The staff kept my coffee refilled. Enjoyed having breakfast here and will return soon.

When you are greeted with a smile from the owner upon arrival. You know everything is going to be ok. And I haven't been disappointed yet. I love coming here. The staff is beyond friendly. The food is plentiful and delicious. I think if you haven't been here yet. I'll ask what's taking you so long to get here.

This was our first time coming here, and it was wonderful. It was crowded, so we ate on the patio. The outdoor patio is well heated. They were very attentive to make sure that my coffee stayed hot. As we were leaving, the hostess was so delightful that she began to tell us about other waffle options and gave us history, and told us that they could be found on Facebook. Very friendly atmosphere and clean. I did not see one secret button either. Did I smell any cigarettes.

We stopped here for breakfast while traveling South. Adorable and sweet with a lot of local character. Staff was super friendly and welcoming. I love that the glass and coffee mug were Fall themed just like you were ata a friends house in the kitchen. Food was delish. I got the French toast which was thick, crisp on the outside and buttery smooth in the middle. My husband (not a breakfast person) got the potato soup and a burger. Both smelled and looked amazing. They had a charity event where each employee decorates pumpkins and you vote by donating to their charity. Sooooo cute! There looked to be a really cozy patio in the back when weather is nicer. Barberton is known as "Magic City" and the owners last name is Remark. What a great name for a diner!

Omg what a gem. Had no idea this was hidden in Barberton's. Nice touches for seasonal festivities. Non traditional celebrations

Cool little dinner with a friendly staff. The place was buzzing with customers' conversation. I enjoyed a mushroom Swiss burger on gluten-free toasted bread. Yum! The homemade potato chips were nice. I shared some fries with my husband the gentleman that a companies us loved his Ruben and my husband enjoyed his bacon burger. I'll be back to try their breakfast menu!

If you like a cozy, diner vibe, you will feel right at home here. Personally, I love the assorted collection of coffee cups, as it feels like everyone is gathering for a meal with their favorite, comforting mug. The food is made with high-quality ingredients and creativity. There are rotating weekly specials and they publish a great calendar for guests to follow along. This was my first time getting the Magic Man breakfast. In fact, all three in my party got it. Thankfully, the giant trays all fit on the table, because these things are huge! Absolutely worth the price. I have had great service here. Everyone is always friendly and helpful. Don't be surprised if you see Kathi, one of the owners, greeting you at the door or checking on your table. She clearly takes pride in the restaurant and she should. It's a solid spot in our area, so definitely try it out. My only knock on the restaurant is that there isn't a great place to wait for a table, as you are basically in the bar seating if you wait inside. Thankfully, I haven't had to wait too long for a table, so it hasn't been too much of an issue.

Customer service was amazing! They accommodated a large group with ease and the food was great! Definitely a good place to try