La Pizzeria

1/9/2025. Look at what this guy did. I ordered pizza, pepperoni, green pepper, extra cheese. He charged me twice for pepperoni, twice for extra cheese. 4.75 over he quotes. The wings are 16 dollars for 10. The pizza was BURNED! Look at this mess! On top of that, Bill who runs the place is a total jerk. Not going back. Ever! 42 effing dollars. What a waste. Not the first time he pulls this crap. And wouldn't take the time to receive my complaint. Too busy training the new girl.

Delicious Salerno's meatballs- two for about $4. Cinnamon knots were a bit hard and the glaze wasn't anything great but they weren't bad. The white pizza with cheese was basic but flavorful with garlic and buttery bites- not a bad white cheese pizza at all! The tuna salad came with full cheese despite asking for light cheese. They were out of tuna so I asked for chicken as a replacement. The grilled chicken was mostly small, dry, harder pieces and in rather small portion but the rest of the salad was great with various vegetables and lettuce.

Placed an order on grubhub today at 11am for pickup of 2 sheet pizzas to treat my staff(hours listed 11am-11pm). Pickup time was estimated to be 12-15-12:25. I called at 12:25 too see if it was ready and got no answer. Went to pick up at 12:35 and they were closed. Doors locked, lights out. What a waste of time. Extremely unprofessional to not be open during posted hours. Will never have my business again.

Very disappointed in our experience this evening. Ordered two large pizzas and one was a white pizza. We were given a 45-50 minutes window. We ended up arriving early (30 minutes) and the pizzas were already done, boxed, and shelved. Quickly noticed boxes were not warm when carrying them. Home within minutes and discovered our white pizza had red sauce. Pizzas were room temperature. No flavor and the toppings didn't seem fresh at all. Both had weird burn markings but the pizza tasted undercooked. Honestly, it tasted like cheap frozen pizza shells and that the pizzas sat out for a while. We really enjoyed our past experiences and have no idea what happened here. Without the name on the pizza box, nobody at the table believed I got the pizzas from this place.

Great little Italian joint that serves a good pizza pie. We grubhubbed in and ordered a pepperoni with extra cheese light sauce, and dessert apple pizza. The pepperoni was nice a crisp with just a touch of spice, the sauce had a distinct herb flavor that was outside of the normal sweet sauce style we are used to. It complimented the crust flavor well. Speaking of crusts, this one was really good and reminded me of a really good homemade style crust that had nice crunch to it. The apple pizza could have used less apple pie filling on top; it was a bit overwhelming. The cream base was really great and kinda reminded me of a apple pie cheese danish. We did also have an order of mozzarella sticks and they too were good; the standard battered type.

Pizza was delicious!! The crust was crunchy but soft. The sauce was tasty and the vegetables blended well with the pizza. I was super happy and expected nothing less of Little Italy :) service was fast. Only thing was I got the medium but it felt like a small, so maybe order up a size!

Worst Pizza and owner! I wish we'd read all of the one star ratings because of the owners rudeness and questionable pricing before going to La Pizzeria!!! The $14+ two slices we had were horrible, inedible. Worst than anything you can purchase from your local grocery store. After we ordered, the owner told us there is a 45 minute wait. Why he didn't mention this when we first arrived, I don't know. Deciding not to wait, we ordered two slices already made, making the mistake of not asking about the price upfront. Our original order was the 6 slice small pizza priced at about $10, so who would have imagined that the two slices would cost more than$7 each. The guy was extremely rude when I reacted with shock when he told us the price. Then he says we should have asked when we ordered. He is the most obnoxious business person I've encountered in ages! Rude and just a nasty attitude. If you want to dine in Little Italy, avoid this hole in the wall like the Plague! His long history of being a jerk has not motivated him to improve his behavior. Not sure what his problem is, but it's pretty serious. And the pizza was absolutely disgusting on top of having to deal with him!

My girlfriend came to my job and I decided to order lunch. I checked on you up and found this place and I was familiar with this location but I had never eaten here before. I regret that I have not been here sooner. The pizza is great and the portions are huge. I have found a new spot and I will be back.The picture you see below was an extra large pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni and sausage and bell peppers and onions.

Was crowding pizza on an icy cold snowy night. Looked at Yelp and found good reviews for this place. Pizza was good. Parking wasn't hard to find.They also no longer do delivery.

Ordered a medium cheese pizza and substituted mozzarella for their standard cheese mix. I ordered the crust to be crispy. The texture of the pizza was perfect. The sauce was good, but it needs a good shot of Italian spice. Overall the pizza was very satisfying. However, I am concerned that this restaurant follows absolutely no COVID protocols whatsoever. There is no effort to social distance, and none of the customers nor staff were wearing masks. In my opinion, the owners have little to no care for the common good, and I won't be going back.