Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes

I went out of my way on a trip go NE Ohio go stop here and it was 100% worth it. I had followed her on Instagram for the longest time and was just blown away by her creativity and how amazing her baked goods looked. Her stores smells like what I hope heaven smells like. The staff are the NICEST people who must love their jobs. They're helpful and so friendly. Highly recommend the chocolate chip cookie with sea salt on top!

There are several locations across Northeast Ohio to visit Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes. I love the story of this hometown business and think they're one of the best bakeries in the area.In my opinion, one of the best parts of the bakery experience is how often they have specialty / seasonal themes. Outside of the usual (and spectacularly photogenic) Christmas, Halloween, Easter, etc. occasions, Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes has also has themes like princess week, Gilmore Girls, Harry Potter, the Olympics, etc.Now, to the food. On a given day in the store, you can typically find many different kinds of cookies, cupcakes, and macarons - these are the core of the goodies that they make. They are also well known for their special occasion cakes, though I haven't had an opportunity to try one yet. The basic frosted sugar cookies they make are spectacular, and the macarons are truly special - so perfectly chewy and the rotating flavors are always a hit. I find the cupcakes, though, to disappoint - they're pretty consistently out of proportion for me - way too much frosting for the size of cupcake.One of the delightful things about coming here is that, when you order, the person helping you puts all of your selections onto a gold tray before packaging them up. It's such a nice touch and really makes you feel taken care of. It also helps me visually to hold back from ordering everything in the store ;-). Be forewarned that these are premium treats and so you'll pay more than at your average store. To me, that's totally justifiable given the skill with which the items are decorated and made.

Very sweet little bakery with some amazing goodies. We purchased macaroons, a cinnamon bun, some brownie batter and an oatmeal cookie pie, everything was really tasty. Some of the macaroons are overly sweet, choose wisely! My favorite was the tiramisu macaroon!

My son has his Orthodontist in this area, so we have always seen this cute little bakery. Today we decided to stop in and try it. I'm so glad we did. Everything we have tried has been absolutely delicious. The cupcakes are so good, the cake is so soft, and the icing is a thicker icing that is piped on, which is my favorite! They have all sorts of unique flavors such as Puppy Chow and Raspberry Lemonade, which was complete with a little straw coming out of the cupcake. The macarons are beyond good. I don't typically like these types of cookies, but these were excellent. They have just the right of "crunch" and chew. The filling is perfect for the cookies as well.We also tried cake pop and cookies. Everything has been amazing, and I honestly look forward to eating more!

Impeccable service and beautiful decor. Very pretty desserts and cakes We ate the most tasty cookie I've ever had in my life! Shout out to Karma for great customer service

If you want a decadent cupcake, oversized cookie sandwich or a macaron, Kelsey Elizabeth is the place to go.After eating lunch I realized I needed something sweet, so to Yelp I go. Number 7 on the bakery list was a win for sure. I got the rolo and fruity pebbles cupcakes, a chocolate chip double stuff cookie a chocolate chip cup! Everything was fresh, quality ingredients and delicious. The ladies behind these confectionary concoctions are great at what they do. The attention to detail in the packaging, placement of sprinkles and the right amount of frosting will keep us coming back. Oh and let me not forget the small town feel of this bakery, make sure you sit down at the selfie station on your way out.

I enjoy their baked goods, especially as someone who likes sweet things. However, their service is always lackluster. I walked in today to four people working there, completely ignoring me, talking amongst themselves. Finally stared at one of them who was standing around until she came over to ask if I needed help. It just feels very cliquey on the staff end and like I'm not welcome in.

Wow! How have I just now finally tried Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes?! It actually doesn't make sense because I am from Fairview Park but have lived in Columbus for over 10 years. I go back to the Cleveland area quite a few times a year. My sister (who still lives in CLE) has always raved about KE, but every time we'd drive past it, it would be closed. Well FINALLY I got a great taste of KE because we were there to pick up my sister's wedding cake! Right when I walked in, I fell in love. This is the cutest, most girly boutique you will ever see. I just love the light pink and floral decor! I couldn't stop taking pictures. I wish my whole apartment looked like this!Since I knew we'd be eating wedding cake the following day, I opted to hold on the cake and instead order macarons the day we were picking up the cake. My sister had told me about the fruity pebbles macaron and it looked so darn good. I was so excited to see they had it that day! I got two of those, a vanilla, a bday cake, a peach ring, and a white chocolate raspberry. I snacked on all of them as we were out and about running errands before the big wedding day. They were all very good (and I honestly don't even like macarons!). But the fruity pebbles was the best by far!!! It was everything I dreamed it would be. I could just get an entire box of those and be content!Also, while we were there, the staff was super friendly! One associate was very pleasant as she helped me with my macaron order. I also felt the other associates helping my sister and showing her the cake were very nice as well. The next day, I was really looking forward to the wedding cake! It was honestly the best wedding cake I've ever had! My sis got a three tier cake and also a 14in round to ensure everyone would have enough cake! It was all strawberry cake with vanilla buttercream frosting. YUM!!! Luckily, my sis and I have the same taste in cake flavors as that is my all-time favorite combo for cake and icing. It was honestly perfect and really hit the spot after a delicious dinner. Only thing was that my sis ordered WAY too much! lol! Fine by me as I got to take some home! Just FYI for other brides though, is that they do not deliver wedding cakes, hence why we had to go there to pick it up the day before.All in all, I am definitely a fan and will have to start adding a trip to Kelsey Elizabeth Cakes as a sweet stop (in addition to Malley's!) on all my CLE trips from here on out!

I pre-ordered 2 pints of Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie dough. When I picked up the pints they had no labels on them to indicate they were gluten free but the woman at the store reassured me they made them special for my order, which I trusted. Then I got home and put them in the fridge, when I went to bake them later the dough was rock solid (I was told the dough was never frozen) and I let it sit on the counter for 30min then still had to cut the dough with a knife to separate it out. It was very hard to form cookies and they never actually baked even with multiple minutes past the max bake time on the instructions. They were incredibly flat and raw. It also appeared they had either peanut butter or butterscotch chips in the dough as well - which was not what I ordered (turns out it was toffee?). I ended up throwing the cookies away because I did not feel comfortable serving them at my event. I called Dara the retail manager and she was apologetic but never offered any resolution or refund and said that's just how their dough is and I probably needed to bake them longer. I would not recommend buying anything from them because you just don't know what they are actually putting in the baked goods, not worth getting others sick.

This is the only place I could leave a message. I drove an hour to this store today to be very disappointed.....when I arrived, there were only a few cupcakes there that was on the daily menu, so i went ahead and got the one I wanted and 4 other cupcakes, to my dismay, when I got home and opened the box, after another hour on the road, the one cupcake I really wanted was not in the box, but a different one, and unfortunately, it was a flavor I do not like. This was an extremely disappointing trip. My recommendation is call before going to see what they have.