Jim's Pizza Box

We arrived at 7:00 on a Friday night expecting a wait, since the Yelp reviews are SO good. We were shocked to find the restaurant had hardly anyone inside. We stayed and are glad we did! The service was good, the pizza was absolutely delicious, and the homemade ranch was superb. The owner makes frequent rounds chatting with patrons, it's adorable, so small town and genuine. I loved it!If you're in the area make a stop. I wish we had had more time to walk around this hidden little downtown.

Visiting and heard about this local spot in Milan. Apparently the owner is well-established in the community and supports the local high schools!Only ordered a large calzone but wish I also got a pizza. The calzone was yummy - loved the doughIn this location, there is the pizza place with lots of seating. But it is also connected to a full bar!

I love their Pizza, meat lovers for me! The service is always great and the ambiance is good with lots of TV's and very clean.

The food was really good. Baked Rotoni was amazing. You can tell this is the local.hangout for all ages. The girls that served us were kind enough to tell us the difference between Cinci chili and how they all like it. Would definitely come here for a great meal

WOW!!! We got the meat-lovers pizza! It was absolutely delicious!!! My daughter said if we ever want pizza in the future, we're making the three hour drive from our home in Michigan to come here! Definitely will return!!!

There are a lot of Italian restaurants in the area, but you won't find a better tasting pizza or calzone in Milan. The staff is very friendly and there's definitely a small town mom and pop feel to this joint. It's always a great stop when in the Milan area.

Good pizza. Had somewhat of a pizza hit crust. We did take out so not much to write about the interior. Service was good.

One word: HAPPY. This place was awesome! It's in the cutest little square of town. The place is a lot bigger on the inside and there was plenty of room to sit our party of 11 though the place was packed. Our server was so sweet! She was on it even though she was being pulled in a million directions. The menu is huge, I had a hard time deciding on what to get but in the end chose the eggplant Parmesan sandwich and I'm so glad I did. The eggplant was perfectly battered without getting lost in the cheese and sauce. It came with potato chips and a pickle. My daughter loved her pepperoni pizza and even did the "happy dance" while eating it. They had really good cocktails as well- I had the pink polka dot and if you're like me and don't care for the taste of alcohol, this one is for you! Next trip to northern Ohio, we will certainly make it a point to stop here!

Beyond amazing food! We have been 4 times now over 8 months and are always happy. We always get pepperoni pizza which is great but this last time we took friends and ordered wings and the taco supreme. Our minds were blown away. I can't stop thinking about the Yukon gold wing sauce and the taco supreme was something I would never try and now am craving all the time. Well done!

We ordered takeout for a late dinner while traveling - shortly before they closed. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. The pizza was terrific. We had a Hawaiian and a build your own. Both were great!