Jay's Pizza

I've been going to Jay's whenever I can over the past 30+ years. I haven't loved in Massillon for 22+ years, so it's always worth stopping through. I drove an hour out of my way today just to get a taste of Jay's. The people are friendly and the food is fast. It's in a small unassuming building on the corner of an out-of-the-way street, it serves the best pizza I've had worldwide. I'm always looking forward to the next time I can visit. I miss the old owners, but the new owners picked up where they left off.

Was very tasty and staff was very friendly, first time I ever ate from here. Will recommend

One of my favorite pizza places in Ohio!!Sweet delicious sauce I always end up ordering a sheet size so we can save some for the next day cold pizza is a house favorite!!We drive from Wooster for this about 3times a month!! If you want you can order half baked and finish when you get home for that fresh out of the oven taste so worth it !!

By far my favorite pizza, any time I come home to Massillon this is the first thing I typically eat. Double crust pepperoni is my go-to order. I've got nothing but good things to say about this place. I saw the only review on yelp gave it a one star, so I felt obligated to help boost the rating on the best pizza in stark county.

Do not understand what the fuss is about in massillon about this place. Got two large ( by the menu .. thought they were mediums myself) one pepperoni and one sausage green peppers. Crust was cheap , sauce was rather bland , and the toppings - while.not sparse -wasnt filling at all. Heard alot of rave reviews but honestly can't understand why. Not a fan

Love this pizza!! Great crust and the sauce is perfect!

I love jays pizza my family has been ordering pizza from here for more than 5 years. We order for parties and other sorts of events. My school even orders from here. It is really an awesome place and it's yummy too.

Recently discovered this little place and have been overly pleased. Food is amazing, great prices, and super nice people. Love love love Jay's. Now my go-to pizza shop and easily one of my favorites.