Gray House Pies

Great ingredients and quality. Love the new set up of the store. Much easier to look around.

Heading into the holidays, I received their holiday order form. From their past endeavors (Grey House Pizza and the very short lived savory hand pie place, behind Grey House Pizza, as well as Grey House Pies), I knew they really push the envelope on pricing. But I was going to splurge, I ordered two Fruitcakes (spiked) and a quart of their eggnog (spiked). Total cost $50. Granted, I knew in ordering this that I probably would be discouraged based on what I get. But, I did it anyway. I accept it.The eggnog was good. Defiantly thinner, not thick and creamy. Taste of the alcohol came through. Was this worth $20/qt. - heck no. I got completely fleeced on this one.Onto the two fruitcakes (both spiked). They come in a LITTLE baking tin (measuring 5 inches long at the base and 6 inches long at the top). They are very good and not your typical thick chunks of dried fruit, defiantly more like a cake. Not overly sweet either. No really discernable pieces of fruit, other than maybe dark pieces of raisin or current that didn't get beat up/processed.Again, here is the problem - the $15 per fruitcake price - for a 5 inch cake. A 1 inch piece for a guest is very small, and that would represent $3. Realistically you would have 4 servings of the 2 fruitcakes. That's over $7/serving and that is absolutely ridiculous.Would I do this again. While the fruitcake is darn good, I am glad I tried it once, but I cannot see myself paying such high amounts for such skimpy amounts.Note: I am not surprised as the Detroit style pizzas were great, however they were pricey as can be. I took a large and a small over to a friend's house - and spent $60 on the order. The four of us finished off the order with no problem. The savory pie store behind Grey House Pizza was selling the "Hand pies" (they were round) - I believe (and I am going off memory, so I could be wrong) they were a 2.5 inch base and 4 inch top for something like $7 pie. Essentially 4 bites per pie. You need at least 2-3 pies for a dinner, complemented with a salad.The owner could claim supply chain issues and lack of staff, but your average Lakewood resident can't drop this kind of money. To me, the pricing is just on the upper edge.In summary, the products are good. I may not consider them the best that is out there but I would say they defiantly represent quite well. It's just a question of whether you think you are getting what you paid for. Obviously only you could answer that.

I ordered pies for our family Christmas on Dec 5th. Due to having 4 adult kids and significant others we celebrate our Christmas the following week. On Dec 20th Gray House Pies called me to tell me that they could not fulfill my order because they will be closed that week. The website took my order and took my payment with no notice until Dec 20th when it was too late to order pies from anywhere else. I wanted more compensation than a credit for my order. The manager was going to ask the owner and no one ever called me back...they just credited my credit card for my order total. As a person that works with the public I know that this was terrible customer service! They should have at least given me a gift card for 2 pies in the future for good will.

@grayhousepies Easter Pies today!!! Such a great selection. Be sure to follow them on instagram We got the Apple and the Chocolate Chocolate !! I wanted the cherry hand pie. So very good.

Picked up a variety of the mini pies and was disappointed at the amount of filling in the middle there was about a tablespoon..this bakery is highly recommended so to be fair I will try them again in case it was a mistake and the pie crust was delicious

Oh me oh my what a nice tiny pie! If you've been reading my reviews you know I always love it when a place offers mini/sampling sizes (shout out to flights and pairings!). If it's smaller you can try out a couple different kinds, or you don't have to worry about much waste if you don't like something, or you can just enjoy one and your craving is satisfied without feeling like a gluttonous Jabba The Hutt.So I really like that Gray House Pies offers mini sized pies (they call them "hand pies") AND they have a lunch special (11a-1p) where you can get a mini sweet pie paired with a savory pub pie, slice of Detroit style pizza, or mini quiche for only $6! They also have a deal on Tuesdays where you get three mini pies for only $5 which normally costs double!I've never had sweet potato pie before, but I was glad I took the chance to try it out, very tasty! I've also tried one of the mixed berry pies, and a spinach and feta quiche. I don't usually like pie crust, but here the crust is so light, buttery, and flaky that I would eat this part first! I've also tried a slice of their Detroit style pizza and it was good as well. This style of pizza is rather thick and I think next time I will ask for a side of pizza sauce to dip it into. My only slight negative would be that they did not have any of the savory pub pies and it does not look like they make cream or specialty pies in the mini version. I could be wrong and they were just completely sold out the times I have been there, I'll have to arrive early and ask them next time I go. But other than that, I think their offerings are tasty, affordable, and very easy to heat up in the oven!

Best pizza in town. Joe is a master. All products are simply the best. Friendly people always make it a great visit.

Ordered two pies to take to family Thanksgiving in Buffalo NY. Online ordering was the only option, but it worked perfectly and allowed me to select a pick-up time. When I arrived, the pies were ready to go and prepaid. Doesn't get much easier than that. Family raved about them. Win!

Stopped in for a quiche on Saturday. Bought a bacon, mushroom, and cheddar. Yummy!! It was flavorful and the crust was buttery. Of course I had to pick up a cherry pie. Lots of cherries with a nice crumble crust.

Major disappointment. I ordered several pies (for Pi day) and all of them were bad. The crust was overly thick/clunky and had no flavor. it was missing salt at a MINIMUM, but just tasted of heavy lard/shortening. No one at our company like them, so we ended up throwing them out -- and that was a lot of $$ to throw away. :(