Godmother's Pizza & Subs

I ordered a sheet pizza for a party, and while the price was pretty good, the pizza was just okay. Half of the pizza was thicker than the other, and it seemed like the sauce floated to the thinner half, leaving the thicker half dry. The staff was friendly and the order was done on time. I may give it another try but for now it's not my favorite in the area.

Ive only ever ordered to go but this is by far my favorite pizza ever!!!!!!! Always reliable and truly delicious! A little greasy but all the best pizza is!!

I came here at the recommendation of a friend as we are on the hunt for the best pizza in NE Ohio. He says that this is his favorite one hands down but I would have to disagree. The toppings were very solid and I liked the sauce. Just a little too doughy for my own liking, this is a great pizza and the sub was good as well with the homemade bread but it's not in my NE Ohio top 5.

Pizza is amazing and the subs are my husbands favorite. Wish we didn't move further away!

Ordered before, was delicious, ordered other day, very disappointing, lacked consistency, it was as if care was never implemted. And if they are giving up on what drew me, time for me to withdraw, sad, really was hoping for the same experience I got before, they dropped the ball and not sure why, but, they lost me. Sorry

Tried the meatball sub (wife) and Stromboli (me). Wife loved the meatball sub - it was HUGE, covered in melted cheese and beautiful fresh bread. Now, on to the Stromboli.....let me preface this review by saying I lived in Brooklyn (Ohio) from '94-'03 and had a Dina's Stomboli nearly every Friday night for that entire 9 years. Since I've moved to Parma Heights I've tried many places "attempts" at Stromboli (half don't even know what it is and misrepresent a Calzone), but none have ever come close to Dina's. If I want Stromboli, I drive to Old Brooklyn for it......till now.I won't call Godmothers Stromboli better.....yet. I need to have it a few more times to make sure they can consistently deliver the same incredible quality before I can proclaim that - but - my first made one thing certain. I will not be driving to Old Brooklyn for a Stromboli any time soon. Damn good Stromboli, and the side of sauce is 100% better than my old favorite. Wife also loved the sauce on her meatball sub. We're trying their pizza tonight....as difficult as it is for me to not order another Stromboli.....need to try those great looking pies...More to come!

Great pizza , service, choices. Definitely a repeat Loved the bbq chicken pizza! Nice people

We were given a gift card here and were very impressed. We ordered ours on a Sunday afternoon, and our food was prepared in a timely manner, and they offered curbside pickup. We went for a Chicken Parm Pizza and medium wings. The pizza was very good but the wings stood out to me. I am usually picky about wings, and will rarely get standard, medium wings outside of Western New York, but I bucked that trend here, and was very pleased.We have a lot of good pizza places around, but this is one that will definitely be joining our rotation.

Fresh and wonderful pizza and Stromboli will order again !! It's was easy to order and delivery was great

Decided to stop here on my drive back home. Carry out only. So that kinda sucks. I like to sit down at pizza restaurants so the pizza is hot and fresh lol. The staff was very polite. I loved the pizza. Had good flavor. I wasn't too big of a fan of the garlic bread with cheese. Probably just a taste preference for me, maybe not others. I think maybe was too strong garlic taste. Overall, I would come again for the pizza and try a different side.