Girves Brown Derby
Girves Brown Derby
steaks and vegetables cooking on a grill
steak and potatoes on a white plate
steak and mashed potatoes on a white plate
Prime rib special sat. Wowza
Bar Specials
Specials
steak, potatoes, and a side dish
bread and butter
Fried Pickle Chips
14 oz NY 14 oz. New York Strip Steak side of mushrooms
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
14 oz. New York Strip Steak
House salad with no description on the menu
Specials
Steak Gristle
Rolls
Ceaser Salad
Strip steak, sweet potato, veggies, rolls
Wine
T-Bone Steak with baked potato slathered with butter and sour cream
House salad with blue cheese dressing and a variety of tomatoes. Note the soft rolls in the background
Let there be light!
salad
food, steak
Lizzy L.
Nov 16, 2024
Overall not a bad place. Food was decent but extremely overpriced. Not many descriptions on the menu itself which led to some complications with the house salad. The fried pickles were the best item we had. Perfect. The bread was doughy but the butter was delicious. Our service was terrible. Our rolls came after the appetizer which was disappointing. The Jumbo Shrimp dinner was alright, considering only 8 shrimp are included for $22.99. Red Lobster offers better shrimp for cheaper (especially on endless shrimp Mondays). The New York Strip had a lot of gristle which was also disappointing. This was for a $30.99 steak. The house salad that came as a side didn't arrive until after the main course. The steak we cook at home is more appetizing. The cook wasn't medium which was ordered. The ambiance of the restaurant was nice, they played some decent songs. Our server left a sour taste in our mouth. It seemed to be a lack of training / first day or week of working here which isn't her fault. However, we were able to obtain Cherry Cokes made with grenadine which is the bees knees. Generally not an awful place to dine, just not up to our foodie standards that we set with home cooked meals.
Read More
Norma V.
Jul 28, 2024
Had dinner with my grandson. Had French onion soup and their salad which was large enough for two people. My grandson had a burger with onion ring which he said were really good and he even had to take some home Nice server and Hugh portion, will definitely return !
Read More
Gary B.
Jul 6, 2024
Wonderful service from the moment you are greeted to the moment you leave. The salad was freshly made with crisp lettuce and all of the toppings were more than ample. The bread was fresh as well. I ordered the 16 oz rib eye and it was seasoned and cooked perfectly. The baked potato was perfectly done and ample in size. This is the kind of place for everyday favorite or special occasions. Easy to find and plenty of parking. I only wished that we had this restaurant in Indianapolis.
Read More
Jack A.
Jun 18, 2024
Food is good Service is good Atmosphere is intimate so a good place for a date or a special occasion We eat there as often as we can
Read More
Mike P.
Nov 29, 2022
Cozy steakhouse mostly filled with middle aged folks craving comfort food during trying times or looking for a warm place on a cold night. They have a T-bone special for $20 on Monday and Tuesday nights "while supplies last". So it might be prudent to come on the early side-you never know when a supply chain issue will come up. The special T-bone is a tasty steak but not exactly a beautifully tender slab. But it's decent for the price. I got the baked potato but they offer a number of alternatives as sides. The garden salad had some nice tomatoes especially at the end of November. I'm glad they had a bit of spinach in the salad to break up the monotony of iceberg lettuce. The real hit though is the freshly baked rolls. Soft and flavorful and perfect with a smooch of butter.
Read More
McKailyn W.
Apr 11, 2023
From the moment we walked in to meet friends there was bare minimum service if you even got that... (Keep in mind that for the following comments they were not busy AT ALL, maybe 5 tables max at any given time of 4 people or less including singles at the bar)when we first arrived The hostess just stood there so we just walked past to meet friends not "can I seat you" or "your party is right over here" once we took out seats with our friends who had been there 15minutes, they got the bottle of wine they ordered 10min ago, 5 minutes later. maybe 3-4 minutes after the waitress left, we had made the decision to try 2 cabs so we could pick a bottle. it took her 7 minutes to do so then another 10 to get our bottle after that and the glasses were definitely not clean. We cleaned them up with a napkin. We proceeded to enjoy our wine and our friend ordered an app with their wine that had finally arrived 30min later (fried pickles) and it was brought by someone else. after 10 minutes go by we decided to grab another person and let them know we would like to order. our waitress came shortly after and took our orders. 30-38minutes later our food arrives by the same young man (at no point in this story did the waitress check on us until our food was served) when it was served she immediately came over to ask how it was. Without having a bite yet we just said good, and my friend asked for a water with no lemon (mind you this is the second time) and she promptly returns with his second water with lemon.the food was good but not above average and you could definitely taste the gristle from the grill on your steak... I could taste every other meat that had been on the grill before they cooked mine on it.. i tasted pork chop on my filet but otherwise okay food.will not be returning here not worth the cost food or service. Maybe a different location of this chain would be a better bet.
Read More
Mark V.
May 12, 2023
First the good: dinner partner's ribeye was perfectly prepared and favorable. Baked potato was ample. House salad side item was huge. Virtually a meal in itself. Now the bad: Cajun salmon overcooked to all but inedible. Worse than that it had zero flavor. Tasted like it had been frozen for years. Why didn't I send it back? It took more than 40 minutes from order to arrival. I didn't have time to get replacement and make next appointment. Restaurant was only 1/5 full at the time.
Read More
Chris A.
Dec 28, 2024
Took our friends from out of town to the Brown Derby. I was embarrassed , I tried several times the next day to speak to a Manager but never would come to the phone. They tried to pass off a strip steak for a porterhouse, they totally got my wife's order wrong the crab legs were cold. We had reservations and they sat us next to the bathrooms and the woman's bathroom was gross and was under construction. Please take my advice and skip this Brown Derby in Middleburg hts. We were so disappointed
Read More
Patrick G H.
Sep 2, 2024
Had the large prime rib wife had the small one. Cooked perfectly with salad and veggies.
Read More
Myra E.
Jul 28, 2023
Fabulous! We sit at the bar Molly and Terry are the best!We love George the owner. Always happy to come inBest service and great food My favorite restaurant!Thank you!!!
Read More
Rated: 3.7 (450 reviews) · $$$
Wine Bars, American, Wine Tasting Room
