Geraci's Restaurant of Pepper
Geraci's Restaurant of Pepper
Manicotti w/ Alfredo
Manicotti w/ Alfredo
Entrance
Chicken parm.
dining area
the dining room
receipt
the dining room
Patio
Patio
Patio
Patio
Manicotti w/ Alfredo
Manicotti w/ Alfredo
outside
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parm
Chicken Parm
Chicken Parm
Chicken Parm
Chicken parm. Was okay. Would try something else next time for that price.
Mozzarella Wedge & Garlic Toast +cheese
Mozzarella Wedge & Garlic Toast +cheese
Mozzarella Wedge & Garlic Toast +cheese
Lizbeth H.
Oct 25, 2024
Such a great spot for date nights; we've come twice now. safe to say we LOVE it. the honey pie pizza and. buffalo pesto wings is what brought us back. if you havnt tried them yet, do yourself a favor and order them asap!! the staff is friendly and attentive, and the food is Divine. Same pizzas as the ones downtown by the baseball field!
Read More
Michelle O.
Mar 2, 2025
Went here and was very disappointed. Not at the food. Food was ok. Not quite as good as the original to. E honest. It was the prices. $45 for a large pepperoni pizza, salad to split and waters. Just seems outrageous. No drinks. I think we are done with this location. Staff was nice. The atmosphere is good, it's a cute location. Just can't get past the cost. With tip, a large 1 topping pizza and salad to split should come in around $32.
Read More
Patrick O.
Jan 18, 2025
I don't like to give a bad review, but it's hard to have below average pizza and this was. Got the veggie deluxe pizza and the crust was underdone and soggy. The eggplant had a weird consistency, and the tomatoes, were not close to ripe and were removed before eating and for this picture. I feel like they rushed this pizza out of the oven on a busy friday night.
Read More
Mary F.
Oct 17, 2023
Great experience!! A family member chose this lovely restaurant to celebrate my husband's birthday. We had never been there and had just a great experience. Our group was fairly large, a party of nine, luckily a reservation was made. We got seated fairly quick and do recommend reservation for larger parties.Our server, Melissa, was excellent!! She did such a wonderful job with our group. There was a mixup with our pizza, however, Melissa took care of it. We were given the other pizza to go. The food was just delicious!! Everything was great!!
Read More
Kim P.
May 31, 2023
I moved out of the area several years ago and when I was recently in town, I had to stop by Geraci's for their pepperoni pizza.Yes, it's still the best pizza ever!!! We ordered double pepperoni to ensure we had enough of those delightfully flavorful and slightly spicy little pieces of heaven.Even the chunky pizza sauce had the same delicious flavor. And the pizza was as cheesy as I remembered.We enjoyed our pizza al fresco in Geraci's little courtyard. The seats could have been a bit more comfortable, but I hardly noticed as I was devouring my long-missed pepperoni pizza.Thanks, Geraci's, for continuing to offer your perfect pizza. Don't ever lose that recipe!
Read More
Howard Z.
May 25, 2024
Awful. Pizza and spaghetti tarnish the legacy of a once great restaurant. The family should be ashamed
Read More
Jim L.
Jul 20, 2024
As my review said, we were not offered bread. When we asked about bread, our server did offer but it was after the fact. Unless other patrons are asking for bread as soon as they arrive for their reservations, they were brought bread as soon as the server approached the table.
Read More
Gene W.
Feb 25, 2025
Amazing service, amazing salad and pizza. I am from Indianapolis and that's the best pie I have ever had. Thanks
Read More
Heena S.
Sep 7, 2024
Always great pizza and service. Pricey but worth it. Family friendly ambiance and vegetarian options
Read More
A W.
Dec 1, 2024
The food was very good, had a meatball sub and salad. The house Italian dressing is delicious, the meatballs were very tender. However, he sub came with olives and banana peppers (it did not state that on the menu on the website, or I would have asked those to be held if I had known, not a fan of these which were not usually standard on a meatball sub- and lost more than half the cheese pulling these off my sandwich). But overall it was very good. I do wish they would offer subbing the fries for a salad, would be fine for an additional charge that most places do, but was not an option online), and that the menu was more clear on what comes on everything.
Read More
