Fosters Tavern of Hinckley

We were in the area to meet friends for fireworks and decided to try. Overall it was just ok. Not that impressed. I got the shrimp po boy. There were about 6 deep fried shrimp with 3 half slices of tomato and some lettuce and sauce. The bun was toasted which was good. But the sandwich lacked flavor. Shrimp you couldn't taste and the lettuce tomato and sauce was also flavorless. My partner got the cowboy chicken wrap. It was big. She also said it was just ok. Nothing to crazy on the flavor either. There was also a mix up on the sangria my partner ordered. The server didn't want to return it even though it was wrong. She finally did. And it was right. It was pretty crowded and people were in the patio which was where we sitting the rest were by the bar. Decor is just regular bar decor. The service was different. The server seemed pissed off. Not necessarily at us but just in general. Very gruff and not too helpful. There was a family with kids sitting by us and they let there little one run around the area. Which is annoying. Not saying it's the tavernas fault but gratefully they left after about 25 mins. Other diners don't want to have them making noises and running around their tables. It's annoying. I think that'll be the last time we eat here.

Came in on a Friday night around 7 after being told Whitey's had a 90 minute wait. Ordered fried mushrooms and warm pretzels. Typical bar food. Had the Italian burger with fries for dinner. Fries blew, undercooked and cold, but the burger was okay. Bread was excellent. Wife had the grilled cheese which was crazy good.Had a couple of giant Guinesses that were about $6 each, add back a star for that! Service was friendly and reasonably fast for a crowded Friday night. Small dinning room we sat in was super loud. Thought my head was going to explode at one point. One of the waitresses mentioned the place is soooo loud she just goes home and sits in a dark room for a spell to regain her sanity. Made me feel a but better that it wasn't just me. Add a star!

I was hiking near here. My companion and I were hungry and decided to stop here for drinks and food. I'm really glad that we did. The food was fantastic. I ordered the French onion dip and shared it. I had two Kickaround sours. Great Lakes Brewing Company brewed them. The beer was so affordable. Two of those were $9.90! The French onion dip was $10.00. I also ordered a personal Honey Bear Pizza. That was $10.95. It had sausage, red onion, mozzarella and provolone cheeses, a white garlic sauce and a honey drizzle. My companion enjoyed his burger. He said he didn't like the texture but it was good. He really enjoyed his fries though. The service was really good. The ambiance was cute. All in all this was a great stop and I'll definitely return, if I'm in Ohio again.

We were on our way home from Medina and we were starving. My wife remembered this place in Hinkley. I am SO glad she remembered and threw the name in the hat. The food was amazing! Compliments to the amazing chefs! The service was as good as it gets, the owner was welcoming and took her time to talk to us even though they were busy. Thank you Fosters, we will be back soon.

Fun little tavern with an extensive menu. Very local crowd, but everyone was friendly.

All the food is excellent, every time! Never have I left this establishment feeling disappointed. Great beer selection too!

When meeting elementary school friends for a monthly lunch gathering, finding a place that is convenient for all is tough. Fosters was easy to get to for all of us. Everyone was so happy with their food selection. Even ordered food for our spouses to carry out. We had the best server too. We will be back!!

Just tonight I Sat at bar had a few beers and got food to go. The bar server was extremely efficient and very friendly. True professional! The bar service was beyond outstanding. Food was equally as great as the service. Foster's Tavern is a true hidden Gem!!!!!

ordered a pizza online early on a saturday for pick up that evening. waited 25 minutes after the pickup time. believe they hadn't even started making it until I arrived. pizza itself was good.

We met friends here for lunch. I had a veggie pizza, the others had the fried bologna sliders and potato pancakes. Everyone enjoyed their food. We came on a very cold day and they had just opened, so we chose to sit in the upper level, because the lower level seemed like it still needed to warm up.service was good and quick. Will come again.