D'Tutanelli's Pizza

Looking for a decent pizza in Amherst, OH? We stumbled up on this place after the district track meet this evening. Looked it up and had the highest rating in the area.It looks like a large house from the outside, and there is porch seating as well as indoor seating. We were greeted promptly by our server who took our order. I was immediately impressed with the cleanliness of the establishment and was surprised that there were not very many customers in the restaurant on a Friday night.We had a pizza supreme and an Italian salad with breadsticks and drinks for dinner. It came out quickly and well prepared. I was suprised that the salad dressing came out in a packet. Not judging....The menu was full of variety and had something to offer (even gluten free crust!) for all. Our pizza was tasty, the lettuce was crispy, and the bread sticks with marinara were hot and very good.It was a very good experience and there was good ambience . Would be good for families with young ones all the way up to adults only. I didn't recall if there were alcohol beverages offered. But they do offer BOTH coke and Pepsi .

This pizza is so terrible. The sauce is sweet and tastes like spaghetti sauce. The pie is small for the price and the crust is soft. The side salad had a good mix of greens, but I stand by my one star rating. The pizza was that bad.

Ordered some bread sticks for carry out. This place is downtown Amherst at 5 points. The order was ready on time and service was great. The inside it tastefully decorated. Get the twist.

Delicious pizza, lots of topping and pizza came out hot and fresh. They were able to accommodate a large party and the service was excellent. Servers and kitchen staff were great with our kids.

We ordered pizza for delivery to our home. The pizza arrived within 30 minutes and it was still hot.We had a large, thin crust with onions and pepperoni. The sauce, cheese and toppings were great!In fact I liked the pizza as much or better than Yala's, which has a great reputation in the area

Don't know why we have never ordered here, because it is close to home and they also have delivery. The menu is fairly extensive so everyone should be able to find something to satisfy their hunger.We always go for thin crust, pepperoni and onion. The crust and sauce were good and there was plenty of cheese and pepperoni. The onion was lacking and I had thought maybe we forgot to order it, but did find a few pieces.Delivery was prompt and I would certainly order again.

It's pizza so that's good? It was entirely flavorless pizza. The sauce was missing spice and the cheese had zero taste. We won't be getting it again

Visited here again the other night (Thurs.) and want to confirm a good review I gave back in September. My wife and I stopped in before heading to Workshop Players and our meal was simply great. First off, we started with the Greek Salad which we split and it was really good. The Romaine lettuce was very fresh and plenty of toppings on it. Our server Tyler, who happened to also make the salad, split it up on 2 separate bowls, ahead of time, so we didn't have to do it ourselves. I don't usually comment on salads, but this one was first class and we both enjoyed it very much.Next our pizza (Sausage & Mushroom) came out fresh out from the oven and it was one of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. Plenty of toppings and cheese. Wouldn't have changed a thing. We told Tyler how much we liked it and found out he is also the Manager. It didn't surprise us. This young man was everything you'd want both as a server, chef, and as an employee (if he was working for me). He was friendly and outgoing from the minute we walked in. We had him take care of us the last time we were here and we were impressed then too. Its refreshing to see someone who does their job well. Overall, we really enjoyed our visit and would recommend to anyone!!!

We ordered 3 pizzas and breadsticks for a family dinner and the pizza was great! The service was great, it was ready on time.They offered me the special of the day, and although I'm not a huge fan of breadsticks they were good. They have just enough of everything- except the pepperoncini- you pay extra for those toppings and there were like 6 pieces- that gage them a 4 instead of 5.Overall great job!!

Good pizza and wings. Pizza dough is always fresh and their pizzas are always consistently good. A little pricy but good.