Crostatas Rustic Pizza
Crostatas Rustic Pizza
Housemade risotto croquettes, hand-formed, tomato-meat ragù
Gorgonzola, fontinella, aged provolone, roasted red peppers, olives
Fresh mozzarella, cream-infused, roasted red peppers (filled with joy!)
Fresh red peppers, house-roasted, evoo
Hot banana peppers, housemade sausage filling, marinara
Prosciutto di parma, seasonal melon
Selected italian meats, cheeses, olives
Panko-crusted zucchini slices, aioli sauce
Sliced eggplant, marinated and grilled
Roasted whole artichoke, breadcrumb stuffing
Prosciutto di parma, gorgonzola, grilled asparagus, figs (seasonal)
Hand-made pasta, miceli ricotta/pecorino/reggiano filling, marinara
Housemade crostini, oven-baked, extra virgin olive oil (evoo)
Mesclun greens, balsamic vinaigrette, strawberries
Artisanal romaine, white balsamic dressing
Artisanal romaine, housemade caesar dressing
Mozzarella, tomato, basil, evoo
Bufala mozzarella, tomato, basil, evoo
Grilled chicken breast - on insalata mista
Grilled chicken breast - on insalata caesar
Sliced prime rib atop arugula, sea salt, lemon, evoo
Choice ny strip atop arugula, white balsamic, evoo
Seared tuna atop mesclun greens, mozzarella, ginger, sesame oil dressing
Nonna q's chicken broth, meatballs, vegetables, escarole, acini di pepe
Pennette pasta, tomato-meat broth, cannellini beans
With side salad, balsamic dressing
Parma cotta, salami, capocollo, provolone, tomatoes, greens
Housemade italian sausage, sautéed peppers, onions
Prime rib, roasted red peppers, au jus (john's favorite!)
Three large meatballs, marinara
Vegetarian - sautéed zucchini, roasted tomatoes, mozzarella, balsamic reduction
Housemade cavatelli, folded with miceli ricotta, marinara
San marzano tomatoes, oregano, garlic, evoo (no cheese)
San marzano, mozzarella, basil, evoo
San marzano, certified bufala mozzarella, basil, evoo
San marzano, mozzarella, italian sausage, evoo
San marzano, smoked mozzarella, roasted red peppers, garlic
San marzano, mozzarella, mushrooms, evoo
San marzano, capocollo, arugula, farm egg, evoo
Bufala mozzarella, roasted tomato, caramelized onions, mushrooms
Margherita, sausage, artichokes, mushrooms, roasted red peppers
Mozzarella, gorgonzola, shaved reggiano, evoo (no tomato)
Mozzarella, grana padano, ricotta, gorgonzola (no tomato)
Pizza bianca, prosciutto, arugula, reggiano, ricotta (no tomato)
Housemade basil pesto, bufala mozzarella
Chicken breast, basil pesto, bufala mozzarella
Shrimp, basil pesto, bufala mozzarella
Organically-raised berkshire pork cutlets ciabatta-breaded, sautéed, wine finished, over artisanal romaine & white balsamic
North carolina free-range 8oz. Chicken breast, ciabatta-breaded, sautéed, wine finished, over artisanal romaine & white balsamic
Wild chilean sea bass, potato-crusted, sautéed with capers, wine finished, with grilled asparagus
Line-caught arctic cod, breaded, sautéed, wine finished, with battered cauliflower
Farm-raised shrimp, panko-crusted, deep fried, with housemade cocktail sauce & potato salad
Grilled 28 oz. Usda choice porterhouse, tuscan style, with sautéed mushrooms & smashed fingerlings
Housemade pastry tart with fresh seasonal berries
Cannolo shell, housemade ricotta-mascarpone cream, pistachio nuts, chocolate
Espresso-soaked lady fingers, sweet mascarpone cream, cocoa
Housemade italian style ice cream
Hot calzone, nutella cream filling
Two scoops vanilla gelato, double espresso pour-over
Puff pastry tart, lemon curd & whipped cream layers, raspberry sauce
Hand-layered: pistachio gelato, double-dark chocolate, whipped-cream with candied cherries (the best in all the land)
Pizza Quattro Formaggi
Spaghetti al pesto
Crostatas Pizzeria
Crostatas Pizzeria
food
outside
Restaurant entrance
drink
Napoleon Al Limone
a box of crostata
a woman taking a picture
Prosciutto Con Rucola
Leftover pizza, took arugula off to keep crunchy-- perfect the next day
Burrata di Gioia, cream-infused fresh mozzarella, house-roasted red pepper, evoo
Quattro Stagoni
Pesto Con Bufala
Caprese
Ai Funghi
Small Plate, Eggplant Parmesan
Menu
interior
Small plate, Cucuzza Fritta (zucchini slices panko-crusted by hand, aioli sauce)
Wedding Soup (pastini, homemade chicken broth, beef meatballs, carrots, escarole)
Peperoni Ripieni (Stuffed Peppers)(Small Plate)
Chris W.
Feb 5, 2025
Food and service were both outstanding. The pizza was delicious. One of the top restaurants in the area.
Read More
Micaela M.
Dec 23, 2024
I went here for a late dinner. After we got sat we waited over 15 minutes for a server to even come to the table. Right as I went to stand up and leave, she didn't apologize she just slapped water down on the table and asked if we were ready to order. I didn't see her coming so it was a little off putting. Beyond the very slow service, the food is really high quality. We got the salsiccia alla Gianni and the Bianca dolce. Both were very good. I loved the caramelized onions and hot honey combo on the Bianca dolce. For the restaurant itself, It is spacious and wasn't too loud, but they still do put tables pretty close together which can be hard to navigate. I might get takeout from crostatas again but I am unsure if I would dine in the restaurant.
Read More
Lynn M.
Mar 2, 2025
Food is very good at this small Italian restaurant. I enjoyed the romaine salad with fresh mozzarella and my husband had the Caesar salad. We ordered a margarita pizza which was really good also. For dessert we had the lemon napoleon. This was a great choice. Service is excellent. This restaurant caters to both older and younger customers. Please stop by and enjoy the great food and hospitality.
Read More
Pam Pam G.
Feb 25, 2024
Came for my friend's birthday because we'd heard from an Italian native that Crostata's is the most authentic pizza in Cleveland. We were not disappointed! We came with a large group which was fun because we got to sample multiple pizzas. They were all delicious but my favorite was the pesto - the pesto tasted homemade and was so fresh and delicious. You can't go wrong with any pizza order. Our server was lovely and our food came out quick. Definitely a great spot to come with a date or a group of friends!
Read More
Jack H.
Jun 2, 2024
Love this place it's a little pricey but well worth it, the pizza is amazing the Italian food is also very good.
Read More
Rhonda W.
Sep 10, 2021
The caprese salad looked delish. Generous amount of mozzarella but sadly the tomatoes were not great ... needed more time. They were so hard it was hard to cut. We shared a mushroom pizza from wood oven. It was delish. Some fancy tomato sauce that wasnt as tart or acidic.The reason for coming is the cannoli... perfect and very crispy shell.The place is very cute if I lived closer I'd come here alot.
Read More
Lynn A.
Feb 9, 2025
The Short Rib Pappardelle and Arancini were delicious. The balsamic glaze on the salads was a nice flavor.
Read More
Taylor E.
Jan 22, 2025
Ordered the sausage pizza, cooked well and service was fast. Good pizza just not the best I've had.
Read More
John P.
Jul 27, 2024
What a wonderful lazy lunch we had with my Mother and Wife.... The flavor profiles are well balanced and capture the essence and simplicity of Italian cuisine. The menu reads like a wish list for authentic rustic Italian dishes. The wine and spirit list is well curated and pairs beautifully with their menu. The staff was so warm and welcoming... The entire place was immaculate from the open kitchen to the dining room to the bathrooms. I highly recommend this restaurant and we will be back!
Read More
Kate K.
Jun 24, 2024
Service excellent. Given great details on everything (first time there).Spouse said Crostatas chicken Marsala was the best he's ever eaten. I tried a special, stuffed zucchini blossoms....the best vegetarian dish I've ever eaten.They had blueberry cheesecake that was creamy, highly rated by our cheesecake lover companion.Definitely will return and recommend highly.
Read More
